« first day (1352 days earlier)      last day (1197 days later) » 

12:42 AM
0
Q: In this drawing of the Avengers, who's the guy on the right?

StayOnTargetIn Spider-Man: Homecoming, the very first scene shows a kid's drawing of the Avengers' battle with aliens in New York City: Who's the guy on the right hand side with the sword? At first I thought it was Clint Barton / Hawkeye, but after a closer look the details don't match. Here's a photo of C...

 
 
4 hours later…
4:23 AM
I have a question for a moderator, whenever one reads this and is available. Could you add yourself and me to a private channel or similar for a quick chat? It’s not urgent. Cheers.
 
5:10 AM
@Randal'Thor There was a chat flareup there more recently as well.
January 2019 to be more precise.
 
 
3 hours later…
8:15 AM
0
Q: What is the anime where...?

RyotStarterI have been trying to find a certain anime for years now! In the anime I am searching for, the main character dies by bicycle accident (from what I remember) and the anime continues with him as a ghost/spirit or something. If you can help me remember, you have my thanks!!

 
8:45 AM
@waxwing Done; let me know if you didn't get the ping.
 
 
2 hours later…
11:36 AM
0
Q: Asimov embarrassment over "Marooned off Vesta

SuperCreffI have been looking through “The Early Asimov Volume 1”. The first story that Asimov published was “Marooned off Vesta”, published in 1939 in Amazing Stories when Asimov was nineteen years old. Although it is not actually included in the book, he gives a brief description of how it came to be pub...

 
12:04 PM
Heads-up: it seems almost certain that Hal Clement will be our February topic challenge. If anyone wants to start reading some of his books before the challenge period starts, now's your chance.
2
 
 
1 hour later…
1:17 PM
1
Q: Webcomics/manhwa/manhua (not manga) about a hero who reincarnates as a noble lady

Diolle Adams Ecs'entricIt may be a discontinued one but I remember that the former hero was a woman (gender bender & yet not (she was dressed as a male and was a holy knight)), at the start upon defeating the demon lord has cursed him to reincarnate into a noble lady... Upon the mc awakening she found that the ex host ...

0
Q: Did Gene Roddenberry ever react to 'Vulcans are Space Elves'?

ShadeAccording to this answer, Gene Roddenberry wanted the Vulcans to look "satanic": From a behind the scenes perspective, prosthetic ears were easy to do, but also, Gene Roddenberry wanted a slightly satanic looking character. Nontheless, a lot of people consider the Vulcans to be the Space Elves....

 
2:07 PM
-2
Q: If the seeker only touches the snitch, would that count as catching it?

MBEllisFrom the explanation on flesh memories from Rufus Scrimgeour, it seems as if the first seeker to touch the snitch wins the game. "Correct," said Scrimgeour. "A Snitch is not touched by bare skin before it is released, not even by the maker, who wears gloves. It carries an enchantment by which it...

0
Q: In the DC universe, the Zeta Tubes, how do they work?

4.12.22.4.18.0.In the DC universe there is a means of travel called the Zeta Tubes. How do they work? (conceptually) Do they copy the info of what's in the origin and they destroy its contents and paste it at the end? Do they separate the body from the soul, copy the body, destroy the body, send the soul and ...

 
 
3 hours later…
5:05 PM
0
Q: Scifi short mystery about psychic alien with "remote-controlled appendages"

Dwayne TowellRead in 1980s (I think) as part of an anthology. The protagonist must discover an immobile alien is psychic and controls what appears to be unintelligent small creatures as its sensors and tools. The alien "brains" live in caves (or similar) never venturing out, but their remote creatures are qui...

 
5:20 PM
posted on January 24, 2021 by tech

Click here to go see the bonus panel!Hovertext: The 9.2 kept murdering but I'm probably cool. Today's News:

 
 
1 hour later…
6:22 PM
0
Q: How can Kong face Godzilla's atomic breath?

codeczarIn the new trailer of Godzilla vs Kong it is shown that both Godzilla and Kong are fighting with each other and Godzilla uses its atomic breath on Kong. In previous versions, it was shown that Kong was vulnerable and got injured with even helicopter blades. How can he survive the atomic breath of...

 
6:47 PM
0
Q: Day Schools in Wizarding world?

Mike StoneDo they have ordinary day schools in the Wizarding World? Or is the Wizard population too thinly spread for this to be possible?

 
@Marvin Duplicate:
25
Q: What good is the flesh memory of a Snitch?

DasonWe find out in the Deathly Hallows that a snitch has a "flesh memory" and can recall the first person that touched it. It is claimed that this is to help settle a "disputed capture". Does this imply that one doesn't need to "catch" the snitch as much as you just need to be the first to touch th...

 
7:04 PM
0
Q: Looking for the title and/or author of an older book... It was a book I read in the 90's, paperback, red cover, kind of racy for the times

Briana Chablis(I've italicized the things that I know are facts. the rest is possibly confabulated memories.) a. I read this book in the 90's, I don't remember the actual storyline. I do remember that the main character was a man and that there was mention of cocaine use and hookers. I remember this because I ...

 
7:25 PM
Anyone have an example of a deleted question that has an answer that has a positive score or is accepted?
@Jenayah Seems like your type of thing....
 
@Jenayah You're the best.
 
@Alex *blushes*
 
Your contributions to science shall be rewarded.
Perhaps.
 
 
1 hour later…
8:34 PM
@Alex FTR, you won't see a deleted question with an accepted answer, because question deletion cancels out acceptance (at least, the checkmark is no longer visible and the answer isn't pinned to the top; I don't know if the database still records that it's accepted or if it'll appear as accepted again when the question is undeleted).
 
Good to know.
Though for my purposes, a psitive scoring answer sufficed.
 
@Alex I've undeleted it. Not sure how dupey it is though, since the answer to the older question doesn't take account of the Harper incident.
Also, there was a funny typo - see my edit.
 
@Randal'Thor I wasn't even trying to start a discussion about that particular question; I was trying to figure out several things relating to closing questions when either one is deleted.
 
@Alex Psitive? You don't have to remove 0 from the word, it's not a positive number anyway.
2
@Alex Sure, I was just replying to an unrelated message from the transcript.
 
@Randal'Thor So would it be ironic if I closed it as a duplicate now?
@Randal'Thor Some people actually pronounce those words essentially the same.
 
8:43 PM
@Alex Well, I'm not sure how dupey it is. In fact, the best course of action might be to get the OP to reword their question as a further query, after having seen the old Q&A, extending the issue further.
OTOH, if you don't close it, someone else will. We have more than enough HP gold badgers, most of whom are more dupe-closey than you.
 
I think this is the reverse of the usual duplicate debate.
Sort of.
In that normally I say that the same answer doesn't make a question a duplicate. Here I would say that a different answer doesn't make a question not a duplicate.
 
Not sure I followed that.
> Famine: Not sure I got that.
> Death: I ᴅɪᴅ. Lᴇᴛ ᴜs ɢᴏ.
 
@Randal'Thor My general philosophy is that duplicates are determined by whether the two questions are asking the same thing. The issue is that sometimes two questions can on the face of it be asking two different things, even though the underlying question is really the same. In such cases I would still consider it a duplicate. One might then suggest using the answers to determine whether the questions are different or not.
My response to that is that I don't view answers as relevant in either direction. Even if two questions have completely different answers, I am comfortable saying that they are the same question and one of the answers is just bad or wrong.
 
0
Q: Harry Potter and Percy Jackson unite fanfic

HelloIt's about where Dumbledore calls two or three students from each house to help Percy Jackson and Camp Half-Blood in fighting the Titans (so it takes place in The Last Olympian). They gather in Dumbledore's office and start to read the Percy Jackson book series. Also, a Slytherin that attended wa...

 
@Alex I guess you're right at that.
 
8:57 PM
Of course there is still room to debate whether any particular question, including this one, falls into that category.
 
@Marvin Should we have a tag for ?
Oh, we kind of do.
 
Has anyone ever suggested as a criterion for a tag, that it be something that people would want to block?
I don't see it on the scorecard:
9
A: Why don't we have tags for each Harry Potter installment?

Rand al'ThorThis post has a tag scoring sheet, copied over from another site, to determine what makes a good tag. Let's see how a particular hp-book tag (a tag for a particular book in the HP series) scores: Does it make sense to be an "expert in hp-book"?* No (people can be experts in HP, but not in a par...

Never mind, it looks like #7 covers it.
Anyway, back to the Snitch discussion, on the face of it they appear to be different questions:
"If the seeker only touches the snitch, would that count as catching it?"
"What good is the flesh memory of a Snitch?"
But deep down aren't they both really just asking how to reconcile the contradiction between flesh memories described in the seventh book and the rules of Quidditch as followed throughout the series?
They phrase it differently, and perhaps come from different sides, but the problem that needs to be resolved is the same.
 
The old question also says explicitly:
> Does this imply that one doesn't need to "catch" the snitch as much as you just need to be the first to touch the snitch?
So I guess you're right, and the new question is more bringing a new piece of evidence to the discussion than posing a really new question.
On the other hand, it could be said that the new question is asking for clarification after the old question.
It's a case where I'd like to propose the possible dupe and let the OP decide ... but neither you nor I have non-binding dupe close votes here.
 
2
Q: Did Gaiman and Pratchett troll an interviewer who thought they were religious fanatics?

Rand al'ThorTVTropes says: In real life: Gaiman and Pratchett did a radio interview when the book came out, and slowly realized that the interviewer wasn't aware that the book was fictional, and thought they were a couple of religious kooks writing about what they thought would be the real apocalypse. They ...

 
9:13 PM
Anyway, you're the master of words -- do you think "lay hands on" implies something more than touching, as the answer to the original question argues?
 
@Alex I'd say it's ambiguous, as the original answer says. Especially "lay hands upon" which sounds a little more archaic than "lay hands on".
 
-3
Q: Please help me find this hentai manga

JgrddddddI am looking for a hentai manga I once read it was about a guy who picked up a homeless girl and then took her home they ended up having sex and there is only a couple of chapters.

0
Q: Can witches see octarine?

SethMMortonIn many of the Discworld books focusing on wizards, it is often mentioned that only wizards can see octarine, which is the color* of magic. However, I cannot recall it being mentioned in any of the books that focus on witches that witches can see octarine. I suppose this could be because witches ...

 
10:13 PM
0
Q: How wide/long is the quinjet from MCU? Am using this to design my own craft but need some help

Nascarlaser1I've been working on my own worldbuilding project for the last 2 years, and I've recently started working on vehicles. I'm designing a ship similar to a Quinjet, but designed for further travel so it comes with a 1 person bathroom for changing dirty gear/doing your do. Does anyone know the dimens...

 
11:04 PM
0
Q: Are there any Star Wars stories that are neither Legends nor Canon?

Frank RendarDo any of the Star Wars stories exist in a separate reality/universe than the mainstream Star Wars Legends and Canon? I think that maybe the two Ewoks movies and the Droids cartoon could be considered different tangent universes. In addition, the Star Wars comic books from the late-1970s/early-19...

 
11:56 PM
-1
Q: Why is carbon-freezing still allowed in the New Republic

Frank RendarI would think that the New Republic would have more "progressive, humane laws" concerning the capture, detention, and transportation of wanted criminals, than either the Empire or the Galactic Republic had. Carbon-freezing seems Draconian and Medieval to me. The fact that it can cause temporary b...

 

« first day (1352 days earlier)      last day (1197 days later) »