1
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e4cd4/e4cd4065f156b1f2322d5cb923ca1436da6bd3ad" alt="Science Fiction & Fantasy"
The portraits in the Harry Potter world - they talk, they act. Are they reflections of the person whom they portray, or are they, at least potentially, independent? Do they have free will? Do they, therefore have a soul?
We know that the Fat Lady could be afraid (3rd book) and Sir Cadogan could ...