ah, OK. and then if he gives up I say what I think it was, and if I'm wrong all the attackers hate me for disposing of what might be a useful attack. Right?
of course the cheating opportunities here are considerable since @Randal'Thor can perfectly easily say "yup, that was it" whether or not I guessed what he had in mind
btw what are the rules if any on how, er, obscure clues are allowed to be? do they have to be reasonably straightforward definitions? can they be anything at all, on the grounds that if they're too tough they'll get no contacts?