What about the fact that all these kind of questions get upvoted to the moon, even if 5 people do decide to close them? Looks to me like the community is split or schizophrenic on the issue.
And honestly, the most useful questions on here are that kind of subjective, a-little-too-broad, closed or "should be closed" that we (for whatever reason) look the other way on or reopen after being closed via voting.