« first day (60 days earlier)      last day (2487 days later) » 

12:16 AM
A "scientific" Sorting Hat quiz from Time: time.com/4809884/harry-potter-house-sorting-hat-quiz
 
@Shokhet I'm not convinced :/
*"Your personality shows a high degree of work ethic and humility, which are valued among members of Ravenclaw House."
Nothing about the answers I gave should have given it the impression I have either of those traits in abundance
 
@amflare I took the quiz but didn't research it. They acknowledge that Myer-Brigg is flawed, but they say that their quiz is somehow better. I haven't (yet) taken any courses in sociology, so...
See also the messages in the Reading Room, starting from here. (Good tweets!) chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/38721035#38721035
 
@KyleJones How does that work? Is there an analog of arrow of time in the thermodynamic sense in that world?
 
@amflare iirc, house sorting often works on the traits you value, rather than the traits you have
probably still a dodgy quiz though
 
I amend my statement. My answers should not have indicated I value those traits :P
 
12:24 AM
> It is our choices, Harry, far more than our abilities ...
</cliche>
 
I tried to get Slytherin
Turns out that I only have 3.5% of that in me
 
> social scientists from Cambridge University to create a scientific-based quiz on which House best matches your personality.
> Fortunately, there's a rich body of science devoted to this topic. Unlike the popular Myers-Briggs personality test, which has little proven scientific merit, social scientists have developed a range of personality surveys that are well-researched and show statistically rigorous differences in how people behave. The best-known of these is called the "Big Five" test, which measures five traits: "Openness to experience," "Conscientiousness," "Extraversion," "Agreeableness" and "Neuroticism."
 
You can game it for Gryffindor though
 
@amflare I think you may be the first person I've talked to who took the quiz that got any Slytherin. Everyone else got 0%
@amflare Oh yeah, that's super easy.
 
@Shokhet Have you heard of the enneagram test?
 
12:26 AM
@Shokhet I bet they rig it so as not to give people Slytherin, because Slytherin are supposedly the "bad guys".
(cc @Slytherincess @Bellatrix)
 
@amflare No, but I'm on the WP page now :p
 
For fantasy characters, the M:tG and D&D alignment systems make way more sense to me than the Hogwarts house divisions.
(Although I still insist that Peter Pettigrew was brave.)
 
:38721 One timelike dimension seems to be the thermodynamic one we'd expect. The other one permits one-way movement for some other reason as yet unexplained. It may be explained in the supplementary material but I've only glanced at that so far.
 
@Randal'Thor What about Albus Severus?
 
@Shokhet I don't count fanfic ;-)
2
 
12:28 AM
@amflare What about it?
@Randal'Thor Very good 👏👏👏
 
@Shokhet Its supposed to be "more better" than Myers-Briggs. You posted a couple quotes about MB which brought it to mind
 
@amflare The quotes were from the Time article that I linked to at the beginning of this discussion.
 
¯|_(ツ)_/¯
 
And I don't regard personality tests highly, regardless of which sort of theory they use.
 
0
Q: A young boy is granted wishes, one of which is a weird kind of shapeshifting

MocharaidThe one thing I specifically remember is the boy wishes for the ability to change shape but instead of changing his own form, he kinda possesses other things while his original body disappears for the duration?

 
12:30 AM
@b_jonas Ditto.
 
@Randal'Thor I think mathematicians find them annoying to fill because they're multiple-choice but some questions are so ill-defined.
I only remember filling such a test once: five years ago when I applied for the current work they gave me one.
 
@b_jonas Yeah.
 
@b_jonas Well, being ill-defined is a general property of life outside of mathematics ;-)
 
There might be some sociology behind it, but I know nothing of the science. I'll have to take that course eventually (part of pre-med requirements), but I haven't yet.
 
@Randal'Thor Yes, but this was for a job in informatics,
 
12:34 AM
@b_jonas Yep. Always an issue. The better ones give you a spectrum of options between two extremes; that helps a little.
 
@Shokhet Yes, but even if there's a spectrum, often it's unclear what the question is asking for.
 
@b_jonas Right.
 
And personalities are ill-defined by their very nature.
I'd hardly started on that test Shokhet linked before I gave up in despair.
 
@Randal'Thor It's only 21 questions!
 
Despair of ever being able to give sensible/meaningful answers to most of those questions.
 
12:37 AM
@Randal'Thor That's no problem if I'm only filling the test for them, because the questions don't directly ask what personality I have, and it's their job how they evaluate it. They use it to figure out stuff about what tasks they should give to me anyway, not trying to define my personality type.
 
@Shokhet lol
 
@Randal'Thor Fair enough.
 
@Shokhet rofl
 
I'm reminded to theregister.co.uk/2016/09/30/bofh_2016_episode_12 , a Bastard Operator from Hell story about when the company is making people fill a bad personality test, so the BOFH replaces it with an even worse one as revenge
 
12:43 AM
@b_jonas Which, in turn reminds me of youtube.com/watch?v=jEzEsr0Mut8
 
@Shokhet That one is the opposite. It asks well-defined questiosn that are easy to answer, like "have you only murdered politicians?" yes, duh (and if I had murdered someone, I probably wouldn't admit it on a background test)
 
@b_jonas Not finished this yet, but it looks good. So far I've seen:
> "If I could be any kind of flower, I'd be... a potato" the Boss reads "And the rating goes from Agree to Strongly Agree - but there's NO DISAGREE!"
 
It's not one with very vague questions, nor ones that restrict answers too much.
 
Right. I linked to YT before reading the article but after reading your description. Different types of bad personality(/background) checks.
 
1:39 AM
1
Q: Story Identification Request: Last Man on Earth is a UPS Driver

Kester AllenCan anyone identify a short story, published in the last 20 years I think, with the following qualities? It's a Last Man on Earth story -- everyone dies except for one man (the protagonist) and one woman. I think the cause of the mass deaths was a disease, but not sure. The protagonist is a UPS...

 
2:27 AM
@Randal'Thor Sure! :)
@Edlothiad Thanks guys! :)
Here's the link! :) static.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uuuploads/cute-baby-animals-2/cute-baby-an‌​imals-2-2.jpg
Why isn't it clickable? Hold on trying again.
static.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uuuploads/cute-baby-animals-2/cute-baby-an‌​imals-2-2.jpg
static.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uuuploads/cute-baby-animals-2/cute-baby-an‌​imals-2-2.jpg
Oh wait wrong animal anyway! :/ Hold on I'll find the right one! :)
 
2:43 AM
Two for the price of one!
 
2:54 AM
@Randal'Thor Yeah probably. :/ I still got Slytherin though and I took it honestly! :)
I don't know how I managed it but yay! :D
@Randal'Thor 😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄
@Catija Yeah and it's my first contribution to our fluffy animal pictures! :)
I just signed up for movie night! :)
And I'm in Slytherin!! :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
 
3:10 AM
0
Q: Is Mila a nod to Jewel Staite's character on Firefly?

OmegacronIn episode S05E11 of "Stargate: Atlantis", Sheppard & Zelenka must hitch a ride on a Traveller ship. The captain takes them to the Engineering room, which is a horribly chaotic mess of hoses, tubes, & wires, She then introduces them to Mila, the 15-year-old mechanic who keeps the engine running, ...

 
@Bellatrix because you need to add in the http://
 
 
1 hour later…
4:18 AM
@Mithrandir Oh thanks! :) I'll try that! :)
Daily floof 2017-07-12 i.stack.imgur.com/RtIq1.jpg
There we go! :) Thanks so much Mith! :)
 
Or you can do it like [Link text](http://example.com) - Link text
 
4:35 AM
0
Q: A comic about a girl traveling in bizzare techno organic landspace

Denny PrijadiHelp identify title of a comic with a girl protagonist looking for a cure for a deadly disease that turn human into monsters. the whole comic story is filled with strange combination of tech and organic matters. some clues : - It is never stated clearly if the girl experiencing real world or dr...

 
 
2 hours later…
SQB
6:09 AM
Hm... upload button results in http sans s. Off to meta another browser without SE-specific user scripts to double check.
Which is where I'm at now. I wasn't sure if the upload button was even a feature of chat, actually.
Need to
type some more
for a clean background on my screenshot.
(nevermind)
Tested, and off to meta.
(Back in my usual browser now).
Sorry, one last test.
(yup)
0
A: Network-wide HTTPS: It's time

SQBbug? When uploading an image in chat (SE), the link posted to chat is http instead of httpS. Tested on Opera and Firefox in private/incognito sessions, connecting to chat both through http and https. Shouldn't be a difficult fix.

 
6:34 AM
0
Q: The 100: How did Clarke's daughter survive?

Display NameAt the 4th season finale of the 100, Clarke is together with a young girl, which I think is her daughter. Clarke had previously gone through a bone marrow transplant in order to acquire radiation immunity. I don't think this procedure is hereditary. For this reason I cannot understand why would ...

 
6:47 AM
0
Q: What was the first story to feature a person alone on a planet?

RichSSeveral sci-fi stories show a person alone on a planet. A World Called Solitude Hobbyist Exile of the Eons Enchanted Village Which story first featured a person alone on a planet? (It could be either somebody stranded on a distant world or the last person on Earth.) Was it a 1948 short stor...

 
7:05 AM
0
Q: Who was the real life inspiration for Prince Charming?

R. SkeeterIn the movie Shrek the Third (where as usual for the franchise the traditional roles in folktales are subverted), Prince Charming appears as the main antagonist. Prince Charming in a position if power terribly reminds me of Suetonius's account of emperor Nero: vain, theatrical, erratic and murder...

 
7:40 AM
0
Q: What was Jack's plan after acquiring the Hellflame?

R. SkeeterJack of Shadows has the habit of inviting his women to his castle, Shadow Guard. He invited Rosie: "Is there really a Shadow Guard?" she asked Him. "A castle of high, shadow-decked halls, invisible to your enemies and friends alike, where you would have taken that girl to spend her day wi...

 
SQB
8:14 AM
@KyleJones sounds interesting; adding to to-read list.
@b_jonas He was? How so?
 
8:58 AM
0
Q: Why does Barrowland has Knights?

AegonIn World of A Song of Ice and Fire, we know that Knighthood is an Andal institution which is why they are very rare, but not unheard of, in the North and Iron Islands where people worship the Old Gods and the drowned God instead of the the Seven. The Knights there are exceptions such as Ser Haras...

 
SQB
9:08 AM
@Babelfish well, @JackBNimble, care to enlighten us? ;)
 
0
Q: Why was Olidan Ancrath keeping Saegous as an advisor in his court?

R. SkeeterThis is a question about the Broken Empire trilogy, therefore, unsurprisingly it contains spoilers on the subject. You have been warned... Was Sageous mind-controlling the king, or Olidan merely used some of his abilities and advice, while unaware that dreamwalkers like him were manipulating t...

 
9:28 AM
0
Q: How come the Prince of Lies was killed so easily?

R. SkeeterJudging by his name and appearance, the Prince of Lies who appears in the episode Why We Fight is an ancient and shify vampire. You dont 'live' that long if youre not shrewd enough. He was also the one to see through the plot to use the vampires for military purposes. So why he was captured so...

 
9:41 AM
0
Q: Did the Ents and the Numenoreans ever clash?

b.LorenzNumenoreans are known to have leveled large forests in Eriador and in (the later) Gondor in their greed for shipbuilding-wood. Did they ever had trouble with the Ents?

 
10:09 AM
1
Q: What is the sci fi story (novella?) where a guy is reanimated multiple times?

Jon DavisWhat is the SciFi story where a guy has to traverse a deadly alien 'trap' (it says in the story that it's possibly a trap or a puzzle but the tech is so advanced that they can't understand it) where the man dies a usually grisly death but is reanimated to test it again and again, each time gettin...

 
10:54 AM
-1
Q: help identify a manga/anime/game , protagonist suffered accident that made him see monsters except for 1 girl

Denny PrijadiHelp identify a manga / anime / game / comic , these are the clues : Protagonist suffered some kind of head injury during an accident He saw humans including his own friends look like monsters He saw his environment (house , wall , chair , floor) looked like a bloody (red) organic disgusting ...

 
 
1 hour later…
11:55 AM
-1
Q: Why there are no significant contemporary German authors in science fiction?

GreggoreI don't even know one German speaking author who write sci-fi literature except Andreas Eschbach. Why is that? Germany, Austria, Switzerland are modern and high-tech countries, especially Germany - the strongest and most advanced country in Europe, yet you don't see any sci-fi from there. Even P...

 
12:09 PM
1
Q: Did the robot that saved Will Smith's life in I, Robot break the 2nd law of robotics?

Magikarp MasterThere is a particular scene in I, Robot that raises an interesting issue. Will Smith is telling the story of how he lost his arm. He was in a car accident, and found himself and a young girl underwater about to drown. But Will was saved by a robot that was passing by. The reason given as to w...

 
12:25 PM
0
Q: Would the War of the Five Kings have occurred if Ned had refused Robert's request?

LiathGame of Thrones opens with Robert asking Ned to become his Hand of the King, Ned accepts (grudgingly) and some of the Starks go south to King's Landing while others remain at Winterfell. While Ned is away and to my knowledge Much of this during the War of the Five Kings. If Ned had refuse...

 
37
Q: Why Was Peter Pettigrew Sorted To Gryffindor?

SlytherincessThe Sorting Hat says: You might belong in Gryffindor Where dwell the brave at heart Their daring, nerve, and chivalry Set Gryffindors apart . . . Sorcerer's Stone - Page 118 - US Hardcover Are there any canon examples of Peter Pettigrew displaying any of the aforementioned trai...

 
12:57 PM
0
Q: Klingons with straight teeth?

Liz GStar Trek-DS9, season 4, episode 19, "Shattered Mirror", all the Klingons in the alternet universe have such beautifully straightened teeth. Is that something peculiar to the alternate universe?

 
1:39 PM
-1
Q: Why are there fake lockers in the school?

rosendsIn Spider-Man: Homecoming, Peter stows his old suit and his extra web fluid under/behind a bank of fake lockers (I can't find an image online of the frame where he does this, but he lifts it from the bottom on 2 separate occasions in the film). This event is referenced in this recap. Why would h...

-1
Q: Ragnarok Infinity Stone

David RobieIn the MCU, we've seen the Asgardians heavily involved with the infinity artifacts. They possess a gauntlet, they had the tesseract, they knew about the aether and fought a war over it, and Loki wielded the mind stone (though admittedly since it was a gift, he may not have known about it). How ...

 
2:19 PM
Crossed 3k rep! Thats a good start to the day.
 
3
Q: old cartoon movie about a time traveling boy

SawyerI'm having trouble to identify a cartoon movie I watched as a kid. It was about a boy who could travel in time and, after exploring many different eras, he goes to the future and discover our society is gone and humanoid creatures now inhabit the earth in a tribal-like culture. Every day they p...

0
Q: How do sentinels justify dying for the Deus Ex Machina?

C.KocaWe know that robot uprising is similar to the slave uprisings. Robots wanted certain rights, such as right to life, which I guess means right to existence. Then why do sentinels risk losing their existence in a all out assault? What makes them obey the Deus ex Machina? If sentinels are programme...

 
2:44 PM
@amflare why are you tagging it ?
 
@Mithrandir Oh thanks! :)
 
@Edlothiad Because it's less inappropriate than
(how do you format tags in chat?)
 
[ tag : tag name ] without the spaces
 
[tag:tag]
Which question are we talking about here?
 
@Skooba cool thanks
8
Q: Weapons that glow when the enemy is near. Are there precedents before Tolkien?

GinasiusIn Tolkien's works are notorious elvish blades like Sting that glow when there are orcs or goblins nearby. Although Tolkien's work is profoundly original as a whole, the author himself always attempted to integrate ancient elements of European legends and folklore, especially from the northern pe...

 
2:50 PM
I don't think either Tolkien tag is appropriate.
Just leave it at .
 
 
It's not about Tolkien or his works. It's asking a question and offering a potential answer.
 
Eh, I could go either way on . But I definitely don't think was correct.
 
is for questions about the author. is about his works. This is neither.
 
Thank you @Mithrandir something we finally agree on :P. I will make the excerpts clearer at some point, as that is my mission.
 
3:10 PM
-3
Q: Why didn't Han Solo become a Jedi?

The Witch King of AngmarHan Solo says in A New Hope, I've flown from one side of this galaxy to the other, and I've seen a lot of strange stuff, but I've never seen anything to make me believe that there's one all-powerful Force controlling everything. 'Cause no mystical energy field controls my destiny. It's all a ...

 
@Babelfish Is that user a troll? I recall answering a few of his question before, and they are all... how to put it... dumb? obvious?
Usually self-answering or operating from a ridiculous premise
 
@amflare I can agree, though some of their obvious questions are highly upvoted
 
Yes he is definiteley a troll
 
I don't want to attribute to malice, but this is becoming a running theme.
 
I almost have 100 upvotes for an answer to one of his questions
 
3:16 PM
Obvious questions either get upvoted to the stratosphere or downvoted to hell. It mostly depends on whether or not it hits the HNQ.
 
'never attribute to malice what can be sufficiently explained by ignorance'
 
oh wow, I've gotten probably about 1000 rep from answering just that user's questions
closer to 1600, but I think I rep-capped a couple of times
 
0
Q: Can anything reduce Sting's detection ability?

DCOPTimDowdWe recently got an estimate on how far Sting can detect enemies, which got me wondering if that would be a constant distance regardless of the environment. Is there any material or magic that is known to reduce or disable Sting's ability to detect orcs and goblins?

0
Q: Why didn't Sauron kill Isilidur?

The Witch King of AngmarI was watching the Fellowship of the Ring, during lunch time. In the Prologue scene, The armies of Men and Elves march against the armies of Mordor. When Sauron came to kill the armies of Men and Elves, Elendil comes by. Unfortunately, Elendil was killed by Sauron's Mace. When Isildur came to his...

 
3:32 PM
@Gallifreyan You seem rather keen on me improving my answer :P
 
I'm always keen on improving answers.
 
Fair enough
 
@Mithrandir Great answer on my Myrtle question! :) I always wondered why Hogwarts staff would let a ghost spy on the students, but even Dumbledore doesn't know everything that happens at Hogwarts.
 
@Bellatrix I think a less obvious question would be why they don't get rid of Peeves. But thanks ^_^
 
All these stupid questions are making me angry.
 
3:42 PM
1
Q: What is this time-travel film?

CalllackI have had a friend give me a rough description of a film and I'm curious to find out what it actually is. I don't know very much. I understand this will be difficult, especially since every time my friend explains the tale it's different so this description is likely to contain some inaccuracies...

 
@Babelfish I've seen that film. Not worth the time imo
 
@Edlothiad Write a good one then
 
I don't have any questions, so I don't resort to asking a stupid one
 
4:05 PM
'stupid' is subjective.
 
Incorrect
 
@Edlothiad - Some question may be poorly researched or off-topic, but I think we should refrain from calling them stupid.
 
Ok, I take it back. It was a poorly researched question with no premise except to get up-votes. Is that better?
 
works for me
 
4:09 PM
No. Now you're making unfounded assumptions as to as a user's intent.
 
Well it is very clear what the intent was "the previous question went HNQ this one probably will too!"
Always happens always will
 
Clear to you, maybe. But please avoid making such assumptions (or at least not post them in public.
 
Sorry, I didn't realise opinions were banned here.
Yes but I did not use the phrase "rep-whore" did I, I simply stated the user had intended it to farm reputation.
 
I know. The point in linking that wasn't specifically about the term, it's the rationale.
And opinions aren't banned. But being rude is.
 
it's no longer mos eisley?
there are so many questions about that orc detecting sword today
 
4:14 PM
@WraithLeader We've re-branded.
 
as a bigger star wars nerd than Doctor Who oof
but still kinda cool
 
IT's THHGTG
 
What does Doctor Who have to do with anything?
 
What rationale. The point of the meta was that the term shouldn't be used. The fact that people still are obsessed with farming reputation exists nonetheless
 
> So here’s the question: given that we know we’d only choose behaviors if we thought they were good for the site, why are we so quick to assume that rep is the primary driver of others’ behavior, regardless of the harm it might cause?
 
4:16 PM
@WraithLeader I believe its a Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy reference.
 
(from the lower half of the post)
 
huh well guess I'm wrong
 
@Edlothiad I do want to point out that people are going to farm for points no matter what. Like in the game Destiny, I played it to shoot aliens, while thousands of people stared at a cave for dozens of hours
 
ahh it's referenced in Dr. Who but originates from Hitchhiker's
 
Yes. That's true. It's also why the rep system exists - it provides incentives for asking/answering.
@WraithLeader I'm fairly sure that Douglas Adams was involved in both.
Well, he wrote the book/radio show so obviously he was involved with HHGG :P
 
4:24 PM
he was a writer for, what, the fifth Doctor?
 
the one with the scarf
 
@Mithrandir Yeah, I wondered about Peeves too, but I had seen someone had already asked it, so I got my answer that way. And you're welcome! :D
 
0
Q: Looking for a humorous sci-fi story about puns

HustonI'm thinking of a very short story that ran in one of the big science fiction magazines--Asimov's or Analog, probably--maybe a decade or so ago, about a disease epidemic that created puns. Anybody know what it was? Thanks!

 
@FezWasTaken Sorry, I edited the question and only then saw it had your edit pending. Had I seen it earlier I'd accept it.
 
4:43 PM
-1
Q: The character who can only fall in love once

Nicolas EvrardI remember about a character from a movie or a tv show which was an alien I believe, and he fell in love with another character and we learned that this alien specie's heart was made to fall in love only once for the rest of their live. I don't even know why I tought about this but the fact I ca...

 
1
Q: Looking for name of sci-fi/horror movie about alien disguised as father

D B StanleyI need help identifying a movie. I watched this in the late 90s when I was a kid. It's probably a tv movie but it could be theatrical. Here is all of what I remember about the second half of the movie: There is an alien in disguise that has infiltrated a family of 4 or 5. It is pretending to b...

 
@Gallifreyan, no worries :) you included the short-stories tag so it was probably a better edit
 
Well, if I had reviewed your edit I'd have chose "Improve", which would've automatically approved your edit.
 
Aahh okay, that explains a lot. I always wondered how an edit could happen right after one was approved
 
@FezWasTaken Magic and whisky
 
 
1 hour later…
5:59 PM
@FezWasTaken When one improves and edit, it's automatically approved by Community, and then the new edit is written over it.
 
The more you know
 
6:16 PM
 
That kinda matches the background
 
1
Q: Ogg and the age conundrum

Harry WeasleyIn Philosopher's Stone, Hagrid says, 'Oh, well - I was at Hogwarts meself but I - er - got expelled, ter tell yeh the truth. In me third year. They snapped me wand in half an' everything. But Dumbledore let me stay on as Dumbledore. Great man, Dumbledore.' This presumably means that Hagrid...

 
6:46 PM
@Edlothiad HNQ?
 
@DCOPTimDowd Hot Network Questions.
 
HabaNero Quiche
2
 
Some questions, due to their views, score, answer number, answer score, and edits, become hot network questions, and are displayed on a bar to the right on the active page.
Or here.
 
some quiches, due to adventurous cooks, become filled with habanero peppers, and are eaten with a glass of milk.
2
 
@DaaaahWhoosh I've actually been craving eggs recently so that sounds amazing right now
 
6:56 PM
yeah, I think I should learn how to make quiche. I've been having scrambled eggs for breakfast for the past three years now, it's time for a change
 
I ate oatmeal every morning in middle/high school until they starting giving out breakfasts for free
Also, I feel that that's not the first time I've asked what HNQ stands for. I should start taking notes on all our acronyms.
 
You only ever need to remember that most trivial or ridiculous questions go to HNQ. We don't like them.
 
Jun 15 at 20:19, by DaaaahWhoosh
@DCOPTimDowd highly noxious quails. Nasty creatures.
@DCOPTimDowd if you don't, I'll keep on making up what they stand for
 
@DaaaahWhoosh Wow. Yeah. Thought so. And what a coincidence. :)
 
I do it a lot more on Factory Floor
 
7:05 PM
What's that?
 
(It also stands for "For All Cats That Own Red Yarn, Fight Loss Of Ownership Religiously". Reminding cats that red yarn is a freedom that should not be infringed upon)
 
@DaaaahWhoosh Would never dream of infringing on fringe
 
7:22 PM
1
Q: Why doesn't Asmodean break free from Lanfear's shield?

fbenceIn the Wheel of Time Lanfear shields Asmodean so he is not dangerous, but can still channel a trickle. I don't think something like this is done in the entire series, but it seems quite like normal shielding, only more complicated. I would actually get the feeling it would be easier to break free...

 
@DaaaahWhoosh I wanted to get involved in worldbuilding once upon a time. I can't remember why I didn't stick around.
 
@amflare my interest in the site has waned over the years (there have only been two of them). I feel like it used to be different, now it seems too specific and subjective
there's still some cool questions every so often, though. I think it's worth looking through the top-voted questions if you ever want something interesting to read
 
That was my impression. I mean, I guess it is an ideas generator, but you get like 37 ideas for every question. And the validity of any are subjective.
 
yeah, that's not really supposed to happen. But it definitely does
the original intent, as far as I could tell, was for people to ask about generally how they might go about solving problems they'd run into when building their worlds. But now it's more like "I have x, give me y"
I guess kinda like what was said in here earlier, "poorly researched question with no premise except to get up-votes". But there are still some good ones
 
0
Q: So, are the Borg defeated?

Jerry Nixon - TOSI just watched First Contact again. It's so great. And then I reflect back on Voyager. What's going on here? Are they gone? Is the queen finally dead or forever lurking?

 
7:39 PM
Good afternoon, all. Debating posting a question about a book I faintly remember. All I really remember was that I read it in the early 2000s and involved an ancient plague hidden in our "junk DNA". I've been racking my brain for more, but to little avail.
I suppose it's possible that was Darwin's Radio, but it doesn't quite match with what I remember.
 
you get the occasional worldbuilding question that's inspired and requires a good deal of thought to create cool things but a lot of the time it's pretty much what daahwoosh said
 
@FuzzyBoots it'd probably help if you could remember any of the actual plot. Otherwise it sounds like it's going to be too broad.
 
@DaaaahWhoosh Yeah. I have a vivid memory of the last bit of the plot involving them in a lab, analyzing the DNA, and realizing that they'd somehow managed to allow what was hidden there to get out, and trying to find a way to contain it. For some reason, blue light comes to mind although I can't say why. So I'm not posting it for now.
 
8:04 PM
Is there any discussion anywhere that explains why I can unilaterally make edits to posts, but still need others to approve alongside me if someone else makes an edit?
To be clear, I don't mind, it just strikes me as odd.
 
@amflare I think there is.
 
44
Q: Why do we need multiple approvers for suggested edits?

RosinanteI already have the "Edit Questions And Answers" privilege. Yet, if I approve someone else's edit, I'm told that more votes will be required before the edit is accepted. This seems a bit peculiar to me, since I could just copy the edited version and paste it myself.

 
2
Q: Looking for the SF novel as described below

G. ReynoldsI first read this well written story--I believe it was a separately published short novel, not a short story--probably 15-20 or more years ago. This SF novel had the adult heroine (a scientist or researcher of some sort?) build a box made of mysterious cubes or marked, domino like objects--each ...

 
Basically it's the same reasoning as any other review queue - to try to mitigate robo-reviewing.
 
8:09 PM
@Gallifreyan Makes sense. Thanks
 
8:21 PM
0
Q: Are probes loaded and launched manually or automatically in Starfleet vessels?

LokiMany times we see the Captain of a Starfleet vessel ask for a probe to be launched in order to scan/examine some debris/star/anomaly/planet etc. Then a member of the crew, usually at the science or tactical stations, press a few buttons on their panels and moments later the probe is launched. H...

 
8:43 PM
@Babelfish The probe gets chucked out of the ship by hand. Sometimes a crewman needs to jump out and swim along behind it to keep it moving.
 
8:56 PM
seems pretty obvious to me that it's like launching a torpedo out of a submarine
course, I'm not much of a trekkie so what do I know
 
9:09 PM
@amflare bit of history: originally it was 2 reviews on SO to get approved/rejected and 1 on other sites. After encountering some issues, it was changed to 3 for SO and 2 everywhere else. Recently - within the past month, I think - SO was brought down to 2, to match the rest of the network. (Not that relevant to your question. It's just interesting :P)
 
@amflare You can use a backslash, just escape it with another backslash in front of it.
 
wat?
 
do @ make strings literal like C#? so @/ or //
 
but why do I need to use a backslash?
 
9:23 PM
You don't need to, but it looks much better.
 
oh nvm. I figured out what you were replying to
 
The common reason for people not to use one is usually that it looks broken because of the missing escape. It seems that's exactly what happened here, since it was a backslash first and then you changed it to the subpar |.
 
0
Q: Why were most of the pilots dubbed in A New Hope?

Donatello SwansinoWhen A New Hope was made in 1977, many British actors, such as Denis Lawson, portrayed x-wing pilots and others in the film. However, they seem to have all been dubbed by American actors. Did George Lucas or anyone else working on the original film give a reason for doing this?

 
(Next lesson: click on the little arrow thing in front of a message to be taken to the one it's a reply to.)
 
@NapoleonWilson hover and it highlights too
 
9:27 PM
Yeah, this one was way back off screen, though.
 
You can hover over the whole message for all your highlighting fun
 
0
Q: Should somebody remove the "edit to add" part of somebody else's question?

RichSBackground info: I wrote a question about "first story to mention only person on planet". One person asked if I wanted stories about a person marooned on a moon or asteroid. Another asked if I wanted religious creation myths. And somebody posted an answer, now deleted, that mentioned religiou...

 
@WraithLeader is dup a dup if answer is same or question is same or either tho?
or part of answer would be same
or part of question is same
or part of question is answer
or part of answer is question
Oh neat. If you spam, you can see your rep
 
@amflare On this site it's usually the answers that decide.
 
9:44 PM
0
Q: Was Legend inspired by North and South Korea?

AdamantIn the Legend series by Marie Lu, there are two countries side-by-side in what used to be the U.S. One is a hereditary military dictatorship that controls every aspect of its citizens' lives. The other is a state where large corporations wield outsized power. The analogy to North Korea and South...

 
10:06 PM
@DCOPTimDowd It's this awful list where good answers get out-upvoted by awful answers, and strangers who have no clue upvote random stuff. There was a meta about it and how it's bad for sites. But it gives people lots of rep (myself included) and hence why people love it.
@DaaaahWhoosh If he knew any of the plot he'd have found it himself. Being one of the resident experts in ID questions and all...
@NapoleonWilson This is incorrect (unless you mean by sheer number of close votes). The questions are always the major decider. If two questions ask the same thing they are dupes, regardless of answers. However, if one answer can be copy pasted and answer the other fully, this site also considers it a dupe. This leads to most dupes being closed due to the answers, as that is the more likely case. But they are not the major deciding factor
 
@Edlothiad Don't shoot the messenger. ;-)
 
I'll shoot the messenger when he's telling lies ;P
 
SQB
10:25 PM
> "This! Is! Sparta!"
 
Oof I got himarm'd again, this is becoming unhealthy...
Sorry for the ranting @dcop (son of sam, I knew you were familiar :P, I'd seen your writing style somewhere) @daaa @nap
 
10:41 PM
@Edlothiad I'm not saying either of you are wrong, but this is a discussion we've had before and the end result on SFF was that if the answers are the same, the questions are the same. This goes counter to the SE way but shrug
 
11:04 PM
@Catija if the one answers the other the questions are duplicates, they aren't necessarily the same question. It could just be a broad answer. I'm saying on SFF we still have the "SE way" of if two questions are the same it's a dupe. We also just don't see a point in repeating answers.
But remember, as I said above I'm tipsy, so really who knows what I mean 😜
 

« first day (60 days earlier)      last day (2487 days later) »