« first day (59 days earlier)      last day (2474 days later) » 
00:00 - 23:0023:00 - 00:00

12:39 AM
0
Q: How did Jennifer Keller become infected with the alien pathogen from M2S-445?

OmegacronIn the "Stargate: Atlantis" episode 'The Seed' (S05E02), Dr. Jennifer Keller becomes infected with an alien pathogen that causes her to grow Wraith-like tendrils out of her body. Dr. Carson Beckett determines that the pathogen was developed by Michael on planet M2S-445, and that all surviving tea...

 
 
1 hour later…
0
Q: What happened to the Doctor at the end of "The Doctor Falls"?

Nathan K.This is the first time I've asked a question here, so I'm going to be extra cautious to avoid spoilers. In the final episode of Series 10, Then, at the end, My question is, at this point, I'm not sure which is the case--

0
Q: Regarding Pepper Potts and Tony Stark's relationship?

Alex KinmanSpoilers for "Captain America: Civil War" and "Spider-Man: Homecoming" In the first part of "Captain America: Civil War", Tony Stark tells Steve Rogers that Pepper Potts left him (I assumed that the real reason was that Gwyneth Paltrow was sick of the MCU). Later in the film, he meets Peter...

0
Q: title of space travel movie with undersea diving

M.A. GoldingI have a dim memory of seeing a movie on a TV channel in the USA in or before 1968. My impression is that it was a space travel movie, but I also remember the characters using aqua lung equipment for diving, presumably in an alien ocean. It was in English or dubbed in English and seen on a blac...

 
2:06 AM
@Randal'Thor I shall go forth in search of floof gallops off on white steed
daily floof - some time date
 
0
Q: Trying to remember a title

AnitaI remember there being children who come of age to be apprentices. There is a whole ta do about being chosen.There are a boy and girl character that I remember. The girl is chosen to be a muse or seductress type? Boy was a blacksmith or mage type of person. If not a blacksmith he visited the blac...

 
2:28 AM
0
Q: Why doesn't the Hogwarts staff stop Myrtle from spying on students taking their baths?

BellatrixMoaning Myrtle, the resident ghost of one of the Hogwarts bathrooms, has a bad habit of leaving her bathroom and spying on male students in various stages of nudity. She makes Harry very uncomfortable, and although she assured him she hadn't been watching him, he isn't at all sure if to believe t...

 
2:41 AM
Hi everyone! :P
 
0
Q: Science Fiction Book from the 80's about a group with Psychic powers

KngLugonnI remember that one of the main characters was a researcher into psychic abilities. He went to a remote Scottish location following reports of a girl with special abilities and found her, living like an animal because she was so overwhelmed by hearing everyone's thoughts. He helped her gain con...

 
They also don't take care of Peeves.
 
Yeah, Peeves is a poltergeist so apparently they've tried to remove him and failed.
Ghosts like Myrtle are presumably easier to handle than poltergeists, since the Ministry of Magic was able to make Myrtle stay in Hogwarts to begin with, when she was haunting Olive Hornby. Olive reported her, so reporting troublesome ghosts can work.
They stopped Myrtle once before, so she's not some kind of powerful unstoppable ghost.
It explains why they can't do anything about Peeves.
 
3:14 AM
0
Q: HP Fan-fic where an Imperioused Dudley jumps off a building

MöozI was reading this very funny Twitter convo where someone finds out that they've actually read a fan-fiction version of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. It's bloody hilarious, I'm crying from laughing so much! Fan-fic details: Dudley gets placed under the Imperious charm by Wormta...

0
Q: Is there any indication that X-24 is capable of intelligent thought?

OmegacronIn the 2017 film "Logan", X-24 is apparently the latest culmination of the Weapon X program, but is basically just Throughout the film, X-24 doesn't speak and generally just kills people. His handlers use very basic commands to control him, but as we see on-screen he can choose whether or not ...

 
3:29 AM
0
Q: Is a factory in space practical?

MaxWould an advanced civilization with regular space travel and access to other planets, build a factory in space? Would it be pointless or would it still be beneficial to have one in orbit around a planet?

 
3:42 AM
0
Q: Sense8 : Why did Lito not take his compromising photos after beating up?

Arghya ChakrabortyOk so in Sense8, we have the episode, What is Human?, where we see Lito(well with some help) beat up Joaquin. What I cannot fathom is that I would have tied up Joaquin and taken his phone and destroyed it(maybe I would have destroyed all his electronic devices and tortured him and asked whether h...

 
4:16 AM
0
Q: Female Mercenary Starship Commander - series of novels

SailsMan63I'm looking for a novel series that I only know from reading a teaser/sample exerpt. Main character is a woman raised in privilege, who bucked social norms by going to military college. (First woman in her homeworld's history, and they changed the laws after she was gone to make sure she was the...

 
5:00 AM
0
Q: How does the Omnitrix work

user85749Recently, I decided to rewatch Ben 10 I became interested in certain aspects of the Omnitrix. How does the Omnitrix convert a human (or any other species for that matter ) into another species. I know it has something to do with genetic manipulation but how does the Omnitrix go about doing that...

 
 
2 hours later…
7:07 AM
 
SQB
@Gallifreyan daily... something?
 
Riker beat me to the daily floof.
This is just an art from the Gwent game.
But it surprised me because this awesome scene was only ever featured in the novels.
So at the same time it's book fan-art.
 
SQB
8:05 AM
@Bellatrix hullo
 
@Gallifreyan do riker even come here ?
 
ohhh
 
8:29 AM
:P
I find that slightly ridiculous.
 
SQB
I don't have that big a discrepancy, but I do have some tags lined up where I basically just need to write a lot of answers that don't have to score at all.
 
Blame HNQness and HP hype
 
@AnkitSharma I am...
 
@SQB It happen to me a lot on movies.se
 
But I would like a dupe hammer...
 
8:35 AM
hmmmm
 
I thought I remembered a question about how the Hogwarts teachers normally get to Hogwarts, but I can't find it. Does anyone else remember it, or am I delusional?
 
2
Q: From what distance can Sting detect Orcs or Goblins

AlithHave re-watched the Hobbit and LoTR trilogies recently and I wondered if there was any evidence in any of Tolkien's writings as to the what is the greatest range at which Sting (and other elven blades) can detect Orcs or Goblins? In the Hobbit when Bilbo is watching Gollum kill the Goblin, Bilbo...

 
@Babelfish hmm, I've always thought of it as being when they could cause harm to the wielder of the weapon, but that's just my headcanon.
 
9:43 AM
0
Q: Is there any explaination what is exactly in the Love Chamber besides love itself?

Thomas MoorsThe chapter in book 5 that takes place in the Department of Mysteries sparks my interest ever since reading it and all these years later I still do no know what is in the Love Chamber ( please no bad puns ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ) and I hope there might be some interview or pottermore refference I don't know...

 
10:00 AM
0
Q: How did Scorpius survive gestation?

Magikarp MasterWe know that Scorpius is half Scarran half Sebacean, and that he requires special cooling rods inserted into his body to maintain a livable temperature (Sebaceans being incredibly intolerant of heat and Scarrans having extremely high body temperatures). But how did he survive gestation? His own...

0
Q: Searching for European Scifi Comic (80s-90s) about flight to new earth

Denny PrijadiAnyone know the title of a european comic (i think it is either french or belgian comic) that have this story : - Earth is environmentally unsustainable - survivor living on space in some kind of station with state of disrepair - They found a big starship on the earth , shaped like TTA Interstell...

 
10:14 AM
0
A: From what distance can Sting detect Orcs or Goblins?

VoronwëIn The Two Towers, Sting "gleamed dimly at the edges" while the Fellowship camped at Parth Galen. Aragorn suspected Orcs to be either on Amon Lhaw or Amon Hen. Nonetheless as the night wore on Aragorn grew uneasy, tossing often in his sleep and waking. In the small hours he got up and came to...

^ Wow. I thought the range would be much less, like twelve tiles at most.
 
10:27 AM
0
Q: What was Tony Stark doing in India?

Tushar RajIn a scene from Spider-Man: Homecoming, Tony Stark is shown to be attending a ceremony, very possibly a wedding ceremony, in what looks like India. (I'm Indian, I would know). Now, Tony Stark is obviously a very busy man. It seems like someone would be very important to him in order for him to f...

 
10:43 AM
@Babelfish I'm sure Big Brother knows
 
10:54 AM
@Mithrandir It's pretty inconsistent
 
Yeah, so my headcanon covers it all ;)
 
11:18 AM
@Babelfish Thought process: "urgh, another HP fanfic ID question" ... "wait, it's by a high-rep user?" ... "wth, it's on HNQ?!"
Also, @Möoz, you changed your username! Does that mean the two O's have always been pronounced separately? I always thought of it as just one syllable, like the sounds made by cows.
@Babelfish Saw the title, thought this was a Cursed Child question.
 
@Randal'Thor זה יותר מוזר עכשיו...
 
translate: זה יותר מוזר עכשיו
Darn bot.
Mithbot, activate!
 
It says 'it's more strange (moozar) now...'
@Randal'Thor heh, me too
 
11:46 AM
0
Q: Earliest use of life-prolonging therapies in SF?

Jeff ZeitlinLife-prolonging/life-extension therapies are now more-or-less a staple of science fiction, and do have a long pedigree. The two earliest stories I can recall that make use of them as a setting element are James Blish's Cities in Flight tetralogy (1950-1962), and Heinlein's Future History in 1941 ...

 
11:59 AM
0
Q: *Major Season 10 Spoilers* Why Can't The Cybermen Find The Doctor?

ImperatorAt the beginning of "The Doctor Falls" (s10, e14), the Doctor Later in the episode, two things happen of import to the question, and one in the previous episode. One of the former is that This means they probably used the elevators, or have been traveling a while. Either way, they are able ...

 
12:15 PM
@b_jonas, I agree with you about re-opening that post. But clearly everyone else is too stupid to read the comments, Oy Vey...
 
@Edlothiad The Lem post?
I upvoted b_jonas's comment just for visibility, and also left a comment of my own.
I think the question is rescuable, but should be edited to make it look less like a recommendation question.
 
Can you not just mod re-open. Considering it is an on-topic question?
 
Which question?
 
@Edlothiad I'm not certain it is on-topic as it stands.
1
Q: Books by Lem involving Artificial Intelligence?

DukeZhouI'm embarrassed to admit I haven't read more Lem, but a friend who has read a great deal of his work related to me that Artificial Intelligence does appear in his work. I'd appreciate any pointers to specific stories or novels where AI plays a role. Thanks!

 
12:31 PM
I edited it and then read the comments. Heh :P. I don't think I changed the intention, but I made it hopefully clearer.
And yes, I am aware that I VTCed before.
 
12:41 PM
0
Q: Where is Howland Reed?

conceptualinertiaWhy did Howland Reed not send men and/or come himself to fight with Robb in the war of the 5 Kings or with Jon at the Battle of the Bastards? And why did Bran send Rickon to the Umbers and not Reed when Rickon needed to be hidden away.

 
SQB
Voted to reopen, but it's borderline.
 
1:17 PM
1
Q: How should we handle questions that have reference to assault, suicide and similar stress-inducing topics?

NzallThe person who asked HP Fan-fic where an Imperiused Dudley jumps off a building also included a link to Lifeline, the Australian nonprofit that provides support to people who are affected or have been affected by rape, assault, suicide and similar events that may or may not cause extreme distress...

Not sure if this would have otherwise appeared in here, but I think it's worth discussing how to handle this
 
It would have, and will do
 
SQB
@Nzall Actually, we have a feed from meta.
 
@SQB I see. Some chat rooms have one, some don't, and I can't keep them apart usually
 
SQB
But good question. I wondered the same this morning. Of course, I immediately turned to a technical solution: use location from logged in user, otherwise guess location from IP, and display link to local organisation.
 
@SQB problem is that location APIs are inherently unreliable. For example, some websites place my office in London, but it's actually in Belgium, but our ISP routes our traffic through London
 
1:22 PM
If you see a suicidal user, flag for mod attention and we'll pass it onto the CMs/give them the link that SE uses ourselves.
 
SQB
@Nzall I know, but it's the best guess.
 
78
Q: What's the official SE response to serious mentions of suicide or self-harm in posts?

ShokhetLast night on Mi Yodeya, someone posted a question that was basically a suicide note, along with the question of what Judaism thought about suicide. The question was put on hold very quickly, and several supportive comments were posted ("You've listed Los Angeles as your location. A local program...

 
If someone actually seems to be suicidal, or a victim of rape/assault, you should probably flag for mods and we'll in turn alert the CMs.
Even mods aren't usually equipped to handle this stuff, and SE recommends that we pass it on to them - they're professionals, and presumably have some level of training in dealing with it.
But @Nzall's meta question seems to be more about how to pre-emptively deal with the possibility of such users.
 
@Randal'Thor but again, see chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/38329689#38329689 (mod-only link)
 
@Randal'Thor Thing is, this isn't reactive. as you said, a user proactively placed a message, but I consider that message to be woefully inadequate
 
1:26 PM
@Nzall So this link (that's a direct link) is where SE points suicidal users. That link is probably better than the one that was placed in the original question that sparked this.
 
I'm not sure if there's any official guidance on that. My gut feeling is "don't raise it until it's actually an issue". Mentioning the possibility pre-emptively, although well-intentioned, could cause somebody on the edge to get upset by the mere mention and go over the edge. But I'm very far from being experienced with such matters.
 
SQB
It's not uncommon in the Netherlands to find pre-emptive notices in news items dealing with such topics.
 
@Randal'Thor that's not what they do on the news. In Belgium, when a topic on euthanasia, suicide or child abuse appears on the news, it's always followed by "if you have questions about suicide, please contact the suicide hotline or child focus"
 
Well, then I guess I've just displayed my ignorance.
 
For example, the newspaper De Standaard places the following disclaimer underneath every article on Suicide: Wie met vragen zit over zelfdoding, kan terecht bij de Zelfmoordlijn op het gratis nummer 1813 en op de site www.zelfmoord1813.be.
which translates to "people with questions on suicide can ask them on the suicide hotline on the free number 1813 and the site..."
 
1:34 PM
\o @oliver
 
Woudl this be something to bring up on the general meta site?
as in "if a question or answer discusses suicide, should we add a default disclaimer?"
 
SQB
Seems like a good idea.
Perhaps we can migrate the one on meta to meta-meta?
So how about a migration path from our meta to general meta?
 
@SQB if that is at all possible
 
SQB
@Nzall Yeah, but we need a mod like @Randal'Thor.
 
Asking on main meta might be a good idea, but I'm not sure about migrating.
 
1:42 PM
@SQB meh. A migration path is always a two-way path and I doubt Meta.SE needs a migration path to 168 metas.
 
After all, it is relevant to this site (perhaps even more than most SEs), and SFF users will be more likely to browse SFF meta than main meta.
@Mithrandir No it isn't.
 
@Randal'Thor ...That's what I read; trying to find the source
 
SQB
A migration path is two-way? I didn't know that.
 
4
Q: How should we handle questions that have reference to assault, suicide and similar stress-inducing topics?

NzallThe person who asked HP Fan-fic where an Imperiused Dudley jumps off a building also included a link to Lifeline, the Australian nonprofit that provides support to people who are affected or have been affected by rape, assault, suicide and similar events that may or may not cause extreme distress...

 
@SQB No. I just checked on ELL, and migration to ELU isn't an option on the close menu.
 
1:45 PM
@Mithrandir thanks for the welcome :-) I just followed the film night link
 
Huh. i remember Null saying that it would be two-way, but I can't find it.
 
Between any site and its own meta, it's two-way.
But that's not a manually set-up migration path.
 
This was in the context of Arqade
\o/ Huh. I guess I was wrong. Sorry @SQB.
4
Q: Add migration path to Mother Meta for per-site metas

OldBunny2800There are multiple questions, feature-requests specifically, on per-site metas that affect the whole network. Migrating these questions here would make it seen by a larger community, likely bring it to the attention to the powers that be, and allow it to be answered in a broader sense. My propos...

 
2:37 PM
-2
Q: Why is Star Trek considered science fiction and Star Wars science fantasy?

Bryan McClureWhen comparing Star Wars and Star Trek, a friend of mine said that since Star Wars has magic so it is classified as science fantasy and Star Trek as science fiction. But doesn't Star Trek have more magic than Star Wars? I mean, there are creatures in Star Trek that can create entire planets by ...

 
SQB
@Babelfish is it?
 
@Babelfish Its all about the sword quota. You need at least 6 swords to be considered for fantasy
 
SQB
Only three swords at most in the original trilogy.
@Mithrandir no prob.
 
Anakin/Luke, Kenobi, Luke2, Vader, uh.....
damn
you are right
not enough
 
Star Trek has bat'leths, which are as much swords as lightsabers are sabers
 
2:42 PM
@Edlothiad They aren't stupid. Some of them just say it's off-topic not because it's a list question but because it's a recommendation question. That's a more valid argument.
I still disagree, because such a recommendation question where you restrict the scope to just the works of one author (and that author isn't Asimov or someone with such a huge output) is much more productive than the general recommendation questions we want to banish.
I wonder if it could be saved as a reading-order question: edit it to ask "I'm interested in Stanisław Lem's ideas about what artificial intelligence could do. In which order should I read his stories about artificial intelligence?"
@Randal'Thor ^
 
@b_jonas It's already been edited and reopened.
 
Also, now it's open, with five votes for open, without a diamond hammer.
@Mithrandir should it really say "which books"? An answer may try to be more granular. Someone asked in chat (not with these words) which six of the ten short stories in the Pilot Pirx book are about robots.
Although I guess the answer can still give fine-grained details even if the question says that.
 
@b_jonas feel free to edit
 
(That conversation was plagued though.)
 
@b_jonas Btw, have you seen this question on Lit about Lem and maths?
I've posted an answer, but you may be able to add something more as a Lem reader. Especially if you happen to speak Polish.
 
2:52 PM
@Mithrandir Let me try… I thought of changing "books" to "novels and short stories", but the question should cover Imaginary Magnitudes which is sci-fi but I'm not sure if it counts as short stories. That book is so strange it's hard to categorize.
 
'works'?
 
@Randal'Thor I have seen it, and I don't speak Polish. It's been a long time since I've read His Master's Voice, and I don't think I want to re-read it either now, so I can't add from that aspect. (If I ever re-read it, I should search for questions about it obviously.) You've already analyzed the mathematics aspect enough that I don't think I can add to it.
@Randal'Thor I had left one comment though.
"The difficulty of trying to explain our work to laypeople in any level of detail is a common joke among mathematicians. … Those who study number theory or geometry have an easier time explaining at least the basics of their field:" I guess there are some relevant MathOverflow posts that can be linked here.
@Mithrandir I guess I'll leave it at "books". That covers everything, novels, short stories, movie scripts, Imaginary Magnitude, and the answer can still be more detailed than what the question requires.
 
Oh, combinatorics is another field that's easy to introduce to a lay audience.
 
I should add Imaginary Magnitudes to my to-read list though, so thanks for reminding me.
 
With lots of open problems which are very easy to state.
Sorry, I tend to forget that combinatorics exists :-P
 
2:59 PM
@Randal'Thor Sort of. I know more about combinatorics than most maths fields, so I know about a lot of problems there that are specifically hard to introduce, but that's just bias. There definitely are popularly introducable problems indeed.
 
@SQB Hi! :)
 
Also I'd hereby like to point to David Madore's blog at madore.org/~david/weblog , where he does a lot of popular introductions to mathematical topics.
 
@Babelfish Aw, I was writing an answer to that and it got closed right before I finished it
 
I like that question because it made me start wondering what a fantasy story about seeking out new life and new civilizations would be like
actually, I guess those already exist. Something like Gulliver's Travels, or that one Tolkien story about the guy with a star in his head
ooh, or the Odyssey
which basically seems like the same premise as Voyager
 
@DaaaahWhoosh Star Trek?
oh, you mean fantasy as opposed to sci-fi
 
3:08 PM
yeah, because Star Trek is 'science fiction' whereas Star Wars is 'science fantasy'
the idea seems to be that Star Wars is more like a traditional fantasy story, but now I'm wondering how true that actually is
 
Ok. I don't usually care much about the distinction. The only time it matters for me is when there's a fantasy-themed movie night and I have to decide what movie to propose.
248
Q: Not especially famous, long-open problems which anyone can understand

David FeldmanQuestion: I'm asking for a big list of not especially famous, long open problems that anyone can understand. Community wiki, so one problem per answer, please. Motivation: I plan to use this list in my teaching, to motivate general education undergraduates, and early year majors, suggesting t...

Just wanted to link to that about the popularized maths stuff.
 
@b_jonas yeah, I much prefer the hard/soft sci-fi spectrum, but even that doesn't say much about how enjoyable the story actually is, or how interesting the world.
 
3:25 PM
@Randal'Thor Yeah, I was rolling my eyes so hard before I realized it was from an entirely different franchise.
@DaaaahWhoosh There's a difference?!
 
David Madore is my biggest internet hero, in the sense that he's a master I can look up on, but at the same time I can talk with him through the internet. This sort of thing, knowing more of the masters personally as opposed to just reading their books, is I think one of the greatest thing about the internet.
(Yes, there are some masters I can meet in person without the internet too. But that's limited a lot by where they live.)
 
@Bellatrix between science fiction and science fantasy? No, not really. Between Star Wars and Star Trek? Sort of, but not really any more
 
In these three questions: scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/… should I add [star-wars] tag?
 
yes
 
Since the previous name of the bot user that announces new posts in chat is tainted by the tomato blight, how exactly should we edit scifi.meta.stackexchange.com/a/7502/4918 which says "Since this time, even when Obie is not interrupting or ruining jokes, the Onebox previews are still referred to as "Obie"."?
Just edit to state that it was called Obie for a long time? Excise that sentence entirely? Remove even the screen shots of the blighted chat?
 
3:38 PM
Just leave it, IMO.
Historical significance :P
 
Purge the whole post with fire? Purge all other answers there that remind to the blighted room?
 
No, just edit in a [defunct] disclaimer, maybe....
 
Meta is full of references to Mos.
It's part of the site's history, even if no longer around.
 
@Mithrandir The whole blighted room has that. Which is why luckily common sense finally won and the room is now undeleted.
 
Just like, say, the "General Reference" close reason.
Which still has dozens of old meta posts about it.
 
3:41 PM
@Randal'Thor That wasn't blighted though, was it?
I don't remember its history.
 
Well, it was removed from the site.
Possibly replaced by other close reasons.
I don't know the details.
All before my time.
 
Does anyone know of any good sci-fi/fantasy podcasts?
 
4:01 PM
Lol blighted. What a funny word
 
@Edlothiad I don't think I invented it. When I asked about the chat room, someone mentioned tomato blight. Let me look up the comment.
 
Yes the "tomato blight" which poisoned the old room
 
why tomatoes, though?
 
Which links to scifi.meta.stackexchange.com/a/10922/4918 by Shog which says "If you've ever battled tomato blight, you know that once it gets into the soil there's no sense in planting new tomatoes there until it dies out; new plants will just become infected and die. Mos Eisley is infected soil; it is my opinion as a gardener and community manager that investing further time into it is a waste for both me and you."
So very likely Shog9 invented using that term here.
 
He uses a lot of food and gardening analogies.
 
4:08 PM
(And when I say "plague", I think it's just because I don't remember the term "tomato blight".)
 
@DaaaahWhoosh Yeah I meant science fiction and science fantasy. :) I've seen both Star Trek and Star Wars. I much prefer Star Trek. :)
 
Anyway, not sure if there's much point in dwelling on the fate of Mos here.
For better or worse, it's done now.
 
@Randal'Thor I liked the last avatar better
also really confused me for a moment who was red and frequented this chat
 
@Riker I liked its colourfulness, but not the crown and British patriotic slogan.
 
o
 
4:13 PM
@Randal'Thor Some internet communities get broken up because the people maintaining the server hosting them are no longer interested so the server just drops off the internet one day without much signs and the people don't manage to reassemble in a new place. I guess Mos has met a much better final fate than that.
 
@b_jonas Well, we have the Restaurant now, and a chance to make something new and better to replace Mos.
 
The new avatar also depicts Rand al'Thor the character, right?
 
Yep.
 
@b_jonas "A better final fate" What nuked from orbit?
 
Another Rand al'Thor picture I found online, which I've been thinking of changing my avatar to for aaaaaaages.
 
4:16 PM
What is dead may never die but rises again harder and stronger
 
"And an introduction to schemes is only part 2, the first part after "Preliminaries", of the standard treatise on algebraic geometry" (from Rand's answer of the Lem question literature.stackexchange.com/a/2979/139 ) Hehe. Mathematicians sometimes name very advanced textbooks "Introduction to" something or another. As opposed to computer people who name basic introductory books "Mastering" something or another.
 
@Randal'Thor I like it! :) If I ever change my avatar I'll keep my character too.
 
@Edlothiad It's not nuked, only frozen, we can still read it. That's a better status.
 
It's only visible for users with 10k+ rep
 
@b_jonas Or something or other "for Dummies" (ugh).
 
4:20 PM
2
Q: I would like to delete a question, given so much negative feedback, and the system isn't letting me

Alex KinmanI posted this question, and it got 5 downvotes and a string of snarky negative comments. I am trying to delete it, but the system is preventing me from doing so on account of someone having already posted an answer to it, so I shouldn't be ruining their time and efforts. The thing is, the perso...

 
@Bellatrix Well, of course! :-)
 
@Randal'Thor That's just one trademarked series though, I think.
Computer people also have "Learn" something or another "in 60 minutes" (the time length quoted varies between a few minutes to tens of days).
 
Amazing HP fanfic Twitter thread. Starts here: twitter.com/shelzhang/status/884496110454288384
 
@Shokhet Without clicking the link - is that the one we already got a HNQ and a meta post about today?
 
@Randal'Thor I don't know. Maybe? I didn't see the HNQ or meta post, so I don't know what you're talking about.
 
4:24 PM
Yep :-)
Hold on, finding links.
19
Q: HP Fan-fic where an Imperiused Dudley jumps off a building

MöozI was reading this very funny Twitter convo where someone finds out that they've actually read a fan-fiction version of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. It's bloody hilarious, I'm crying from laughing so much! Fan-fic details: Dudley gets placed under the Imperius Curse by Wormtai...

 
This one? ...I think so, yes.
 
19
Q: HP Fan-fic where an Imperiused Dudley jumps off a building

MöozI was reading this very funny Twitter convo where someone finds out that they've actually read a fan-fiction version of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. It's bloody hilarious, I'm crying from laughing so much! Fan-fic details: Dudley gets placed under the Imperius Curse by Wormtai...

 
Yeah, I think so. Someone started reading it, thinking it was the real HP series...
Friend tweeted their text messages and they are hilarious.
 
That's quite an embarrassing mistake to make.
 
Yep.
 
4:26 PM
I gritted my teeth and had a look through the fanfic in question. It's actually reasonably well-written for a HP fanfic.
 
I was actually wondering if there was a reason I got a bunch of random upvotes on meta.stackexchange.com/q/243700/266359 in the past few days.
 
Although it has a lot of rather unlikely-sounding romantic stuff.
 
@Randal'Thor Really? ...I probably won't read it, but
 
@Shokhet Or someone made up that conversation, possibly based on a real fanfic, with the goal of internet fame.
 
@Randal'Thor Yeah. That.
@b_jonas Could be. Probably impossible to tell, though. Poe's Law and all that.
 
4:28 PM
@Shokhet Yep.
 
I only saw it today. Didn't realize that it was older than a few hours ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
@Shokhet Poe's Law: if it exists, you can write gothic horror about it.
3
No, wait, wrong Poe.
 
@Shokhet Meh, stupid modern internet. With wordpress and blogger and twitter and lots of other websites designed only for reading (and possibly commenting on) recent posts, not for conveniently accessing an archive of old material. I'm disdainful at that.
Makes you guess anything you see on the internet is half a day old by default.
 
@b_jonas The first tweet I saw (retweeted by someone else into my Twitter timeline) was timestamped for this morning. I scrolled back through the thread, and didn't realize that it started a while before that.
 
@Randal'Thor In your post, I think "a sing e"unit" of the message" is a typo
 
4:35 PM
@b_jonas It's the same in Hamlet's quoted passage in the OP, so I'm assuming it's [sic].
Thanks for reminding me though - I'll check with Hamlet.
 
@Randal'Thor Ah.
 
@Randal'Thor Is this what kicked off the fanfic conversation in the Reading Room? Or was that something else?
 
"an existence proof, one which is not constructive. In maths, you can often prove the existence of an object satisfying certain properties, even if you can't actually find an explicit example. For instance, any result which uses the Axiom of Choice is likely to involve knowing something exists without being able to find it." =>
@Randal'Thor I don't think that's a good example. Is there a specific proof using choice you can think of where the problem is that finding the object isn't constructive enough, as opposed to that all the objects must be strange unmeasurable things you can't imagine? Choice is constructive enough when you use it in a way that any choice you make works fine.
A better large category of examples might be counting/probabilistic proofs, where you prove that a random object from a suitable distrib has a positive probability to work; or a parity proof where you prove that there's an odd number of solutions; or proofs with an indirection at every level of a long construction where you prove that at each step one of the choices must work in the end but you can't tell which one without trying out all possibilities and backtracking.
It's possible that I'm just thinking of the wrong uses of a of choice of course.
 
@Shokhet @b_jonas Actually, best as I can tell, the first tweet was from yesterday afternoon. So actually not so old, in fact.
 
@Randal'Thor Yeah! :) And I actually do look like her! ;)
@Randal'Thor Yeah, I read it and thought so too. Plus so far there's no Bellatrix meddling! :)
 
4:46 PM
@Shokhet No, the fanfic conversation in tRR came from one of Hamlet's ideas for encouraging different types of answers. That was several days ago; the HNQ here was just today.
 
@Randal'Thor Got it.
 
@Randal'Thor Ha, yeah! :P
 
I made some comments in that fanfic convo, but didn't really know how it started or where it was going :p
 
@b_jonas It's not the best example, because the very nature of the Axiom of Choice (and all its equivalent statements) is that you're axiomatically assuming existence of things without being able to find them explicitly.
Something like the existence of (irrational)^(irrational)=(rational) would be better, but presumably by this time someone's actually found an explicit example of that.
 
“makes me suspect that "closedness" here describes something more like a closed curve from geometry than a closed set from topology” oh, you mean like a combinatorial polytope having no boundary, or a compact manifold? that's not what I thought of, but it's supported by the text later at “But the description of a geometric solid closes”
 
4:50 PM
@Shokhet It started from here:
in The Reading Room, Jul 5 at 13:52, by Hamlet
5. What about an answer that drew on experience writing fanfiction? For example, "what happens to [character x]". One answer is "the story doesn't say." Another answer: I wrote a story about that; here's why I make the choices I make.
 
@Randal'Thor Hmm, good question. There's a simple proof for that where one of two examples definitely works (and it's easy to guess which one but hard to prove), but I don't know if there's a single explicit example.
 
@Randal'Thor Thanks.
 
@b_jonas I imagine that by now someone must have proved the irrationality of (sqrt2)^(sqrt2)?
 
@b_jonas @Randal'Thor You've lost me already.
> If the imaginary narrator were speaking to a colleague instead of to a lay audience, he would be using strange letters and symbols instead of words that anyone can understand, and it would be easier for me to tell what actual mathematics is behind it.
 
@Shokhet You mean our chat in here, or my answer?
 
4:54 PM
Hmm, math reminds me there's a question I should perhaps ask on Math SE. Not now though, because I must leave. Goodbye.
 
If my answer is too mathematical, let me know where and I can try to fix it.
Later @b_jonas!
 
@Randal'Thor In chat here, mostly. I skimmed your answer but didn't really make a strong effort to understand it.
 
Fair enough - it is loooooooong :-)
 
My math level right now is "slowly forgetting all of my Calculus I." Your answer looked to be a level or two above that :)
 
Well, I've alluded to some higher mathematical concepts, but tried to do so in an understandable way.
 
4:56 PM
@Randal'Thor And that, yes.
@Randal'Thor I've got to go soon, actually, but maybe I'll give it a try later.
 
@Randal'Thor I think it succeeds rather well in getting across the point that some of the concepts are real, and some less so, which is what the question asks about (as far as I understand).
 
I'm curious what math answer you guys are talking about. Can someone link?
 
1
Q: What are Spider-Man's goggles for?

DCOPTimDowdIn Spider-Man: Homecoming, we're introduced to Peter's new suit, given to him by Tony Stark, which has goggles over the eyes that can change shape and color. At the end of the movie, So what do they do, aside from allowing Spider-Man to have more expressions? What are the tactical reasons why...

 
@amflare This one:
5
A: Mathematics or gibberish? Understanding a description of an alien message in His Master's Voice

Rand al'ThorI'm a mathematician, and to me the style of narration in this passage sounds very familiar. Because of the extreme abstraction from reality of most of (pure) mathematics, we who study it often dread being asked what we do by non-mathematicians. The difficulty of trying to explain our work to layp...

 
cheers
 
5:00 PM
5
Q: Mathematics or gibberish? Understanding a description of an alien message in His Master's Voice

HamletI'm reading the 1983 Michael Kandel translation of Stanislaw Lem's His Master's Voice. The plot revolves around a secret military project to decode an alien message. The main character is a mathematician, and in one scene in the book he describes a mathematical proof of certain properties of the ...

 
Double ninja'd :-)
 
No, I specifically added mine to do a hat-trick.
 
Wow so many math terms I don't understand! 0_0
 
@Bellatrix That section about schemes?
I deliberately chose schemes as one of the most abstruse mathematical concepts I've ever come across.
I pity any algebraic geometer who has to try to explain their work to a non-mathematician.
 
5:16 PM
@all: please upvote the 2015 and 2016 answers on the meta list of all SFF blog posts. Ideally it'd be great to have answer score as a monotonically increasing function of years.
And 2017 too, in fact. It's accepted, but that doesn't pin it to the top because it's a self-answer :-/
 
@Randal'Thor I was about to say that, lol.
 
Oh, but try to space out your votes a bit.
 
Maybe you should copy it, write your own answer, and then delete @JackBNimble's, so that it can come out on top via accept.
 
Otherwise they may get reversed as 'serial voting', since all answers are by the same user.
 
@Randal'Thor Serial voting can apply to three answers to the same question? I didn't realize the threshold was so low.
 
5:19 PM
I don't know exactly what the threshold is.
But we may as well try to be on the safe side.
 
Fair enough.
 
2
Q: What is the Mule's namesake?

CalllackIn the conclusive few sentences of Foundation and Empire, the Mule says that: I call myself the Mule - but not because of my strength, obviously - They do not finish the sentence. Earlier in the book some Foundation denizens theorised that it was because of his hard-working attitude to gala...

0
Q: Why does Spider-Man's suit have this feature in Homecoming?

DCOPTimDowdThe suit in Spider-Man: Homecoming has a "one-hit kill" mode that keeps coming up, and it's only used for comedic purposes in the movie. From what I know Peter Parker doesn't seek to kill anyone, and has only ever wanted to kill one person: the guy who murdered Uncle Ben, but even then he doesn't...

 
huh, I just noticed, the new Spider-man movie came out. I didn't even realize
 
@DaaaahWhoosh :D
 
I guess that explains all the recent questions about it
 
5:31 PM
@DaaaahWhoosh Bu the way, can that query you wrote also display the days with zero questions with a specific tag?
 
@Gallifreyan probably not in its current state, but I could most likely join it to a query of all the days
find me a link to the query and I can edit it... eventually
 
5:49 PM
@Randal'Thor I knew keeping them in order would be a problem.
 
@JackBNimble We can probably manage it for now, but might be a good idea to get someone else to post the answers for 2018 and beyond, so that acceptance will at least pin the current year to the top.
 
Oh wow, this group is great.
 
@Randal'Thor Yeah... 0-0 I know evil schemes but that's about it. ;)
 
5:59 PM
@DaaaahWhoosh
 
@Gallifreyan I had the hardest time trying to figure out why every day was coming up zero... until I realized it was running the query on Stack Overflow
 
@Bellatrix Not affine schemes then?
Q: What did the evil algebraic geometer say?
A: *rubs hands gleefully* "I have a fine scheme."
 
6:14 PM
posted on July 11, 2017 by KutuluMike

The latest installment in the Marvel Cinematic Universe — and the first result of the Marvel/Sony partnership — hit theaters this weekend, and by all indications, it’s doing wonderful. That’s good, because this is a movie that deserves to do well. It has a lot going for it, and is a solid addition to the ... Read more

 
1
Q: What happens to Zadok Allen in The Shadow Over Innsmouth? (Spoilers ahead!)

G. ÜntherIn Lovecrafts "The Shadow Over Innsmouth" the narrator talks to Zadok Allen, who tells him things he isn't supposed/allowed to tell. This includes the following: The conversation ends like this: Zadok Allen isn't mentioned in the rest of the story. Later, however, the narrator notices thi...

0
Q: Do we ever find out who these Darkfriends are?

Pier PaoloIn the Prologue of Book 2 (The Great Hunt), there is a meeting between Friends of the Dark who receive orders about Rand, Mat and Perrin. Do we ever find out who they are? Here is an excerpt describing some of the Darkfriends (bold numbering is mine): (1) The man who called himself Bors [.....

-1
Q: Voyager top speed

Mickey PinsonIn Star Trek Voyager, the crew needs to travel 75,000 light years to make it home at "top speed". If their top speed is warp 9.97, why would it take them 70 years to get home?

 
@Babelfish Darn, that's been on my to-ask list for months.
@Babelfish Dupe?
 
6:29 PM
@Randal'Thor I have no idea what affine schemes are!
 
Ooh a review! :)
How do you write for the blog?
 
There's a Science Fiction & Fantasy Meta post somewhere, hang on
15
Q: Official Unofficial Blog Support Post

KutuluMike(I hope it's OK to do this here, since we don't have any better place to do it at the moment. I am looking into other options for support, so this post will hopefully be just an interim solution). Now that the SF&F blog is off-site, any support or troubleshooting has to go through the blog owner...

 
There's also a Contribute page on the blog itself.
@JackBNimble There's still a link to Mos Eisley on the blog's Contribute page; should probably change that to either this room or the blog room.
 
6:58 PM
2
Q: Can goblins or orcs see the light Sting gives off?

DCOPTimDowdIn LOTR, the sword Sting glows whenever goblins or orcs are nearby enough, and in the movies, it can get pretty bright. Can they see this light? If so, has it ever given the wielder away?

 
7:29 PM
0
Q: Have there been any other official foreign remakes of Marvel characters besides Supaidāman?

GGMGThe Japanese TV series of Supaidāman, produced by Toei, ran for 41 episodes with the full blessing of Marvel. Although it was based around the American Spider-Man, it went way further than just translating or modifying its source material for another culture. In this version, a motorcycle racer n...

 
@JackBNimble "In this 97 minute movie I’m pretty sure that cave scene represented about 400 minutes of the film." Best thing I've read all day.
 
Greg Egan's Dichronauts dropped in north America at long last today. Anyone else tackling it?
 
7:58 PM
0
Q: Short Story Time Travel from the Early 2000s, Maybe Earlier?

ImperatorI don't remember much about the story in general, but here's the details I can recall. It's a short story, intended for a 5th or 6th grade reading level, and I found it in the early 2000s in a collection of stories, the rest being lost to memory. In the story, somehow a kid finds out his neighbor...

 
SQB
8:24 PM
@JackBNimble what, no "Mos Eisley is dead to me"?
 
@SQB The chat room that must not be named
 
@KyleJones Haven't heard of it. Any good?
 
@Randal'Thor Only read a chapter or so over lunch, so I can't say yet. It's Egan though, so I'm expecting to knock a good deal of rust off my math skills at the very least. The big idea is that life has developed in a universe with two time-like dimensions instead of one. Egan explores the consequences of that in his usual mind-binding fashion.
 
8:40 PM
Who says time doesn't have two dimensions in our universe?
I believe that's been seriously posited as a theory of physics.
 
@Randal'Thor do you anything about block universe theory?
 
No idea what that is, sorry.
 
Oh okay. No worries.
 
I'm a mathematician, not a physicist, but I know some physicists and pick up bits and bobs about their work.
 
Gotcha. I was hoping there was enough overlap to ask if the math was legit or this was one of those wild theories people come up with.
But admittedly, I know little about either math or physics or where the line between them is. Sooo..... :P
 
8:51 PM
News to me. I thought 3+1 explained most things, and extra dimensions rolled up explained the rest. Anyway, Dichronauts seems to be another installment of Egan's alternate physics explorations. The previous three books were about a universe where all four dimensions were spacelike and the one you regarded as timelike depended on the way your worldline evolved.
@amflare Egan offers a large amount of supplementary material in support of his alternate universes, up to and including tensor equations if you've got the math chops to handle them. There are also gentler introductions to the material for people who didn't study any math beyond high school.
I'm not a mathematician or a physicist so I'm not going claim any knowledge of whether his speculations are BS or not, but Egan seems to have put a lot of thought and effort into the worlds he's created.
 
9:07 PM
@Skooba That would be an awesome name for a chat! :P
@Mithrandir Oh thanks! :)
@Randal'Thor Neat! :)
 
9:20 PM
@amflare That's when you build a really big Lego city! :P
 
@Bellatrix Oooooooooooh.... That makes sense.
 
9:51 PM
The Chat Room died in March I thought.
 
0
Q: DS9, season 4, episode 19 "Shattered Mirror"

Liz GWhy do all the Klingons in this episode have such nicely straightened teeth? Is this something peculiar to the alternate galaxy? It looks very strange to me...

 
@amflare Hahahaha! ;)
 
10:46 PM
1
Q: Weapons that glow when the enemy is near. Are there precedents before Tolkien?

GinasiusIn Tolkien's works are notorious elvish blades like Sting that glow when there are orcs or goblins nearby. Although Tolkien's work is profoundly original as a whole, the author himself always attempted to integrate ancient elements of European legends and folklore, especially from the northern pe...

 
00:00 - 23:0023:00 - 00:00

« first day (59 days earlier)      last day (2474 days later) »