« first day (2561 days earlier)      last day (1927 days later) » 

12:21 AM
@TheSimpliFire you should avoid deleting your answers and just vote the question for closure, and let it be deleted that way, assuming the community agrees
2 reasons I say that. First is that theres nothing wrong with your answers, the problem is with the questions. And second is that I really don't want self-deletetion of this nature to become a fad... The line between pruning and self-vandalism is fuzzy, and self-vandalism is probably the single most annoying thing for mods to clean up.
 
12:40 AM
@Shaun that one will stay deleted, I'm afraid. I'm not opposed to the occasional fun question nor the occasional big-list soft-question, but that is just not to the type of question I want representing MSE to the world. It would be a good fit for r/math, probably.
 
 
4 hours later…
4:39 AM
? This is very close to personal advice-seeking. I have not voted to close, as perhaps it is appropriate for MSE. Does anyone else have an opinion?
 
 
3 hours later…
7:22 AM
@quid No, I don't think so. The 7 delete votes I have daily are separate from the ones for answer - I don't yet have the rep to delete answers anyway.
@AlexanderGruber Sure, no problem.
@quid (except for self posts of course)
 
8:05 AM
think that's all for today
 
9:10 AM
@XanderHenderson I do think that that question is a personal advice-seeking question (and I voted accordingly).
 
 
2 hours later…
10:58 AM
@XanderHenderson Technically, opinion-based or career-advice questions are unambiguously off-topic, and even have a dedicate close-reason. But I personally never vote on them if they seem to be asked in good faith. You won't go wrong if you vote to close them, and you can also consider commenting that they ask somewhere else such as Academia SE or Math Educators SE if it would be on-topic there.
 
11:48 AM
Totally wrong answer: W. Also see this: X.
Close? A, B, C,
D, E, F.
 
12:06 PM
Choose my graduate thesis topic math.stackexchange.com/q/3075648/29335
 
12:29 PM
Delete? G, H, I,
J, K, L,
M, N, O.
 
 
1 hour later…
1:56 PM
@user21820 @user21820 Thank you for the input.
 
PSQ from a user that is not new at all.
 
In my previous message I accidentally linked to the review, here's the question.
 
2:15 PM
 
2:28 PM
Should we close this question as a dupe of this question and tell them to edit it?
 
2:47 PM
Question asks "what does this definition mean" for something Smarandache invented. I half feel that it might just be driving metrics up at researchgate.net for bogus research , but suspicions aside, the question is unacceptably unfocused: math.stackexchange.com/q/3075446/29335
 
3:00 PM
@user21820 I've downvoted W, but it needs more downvotes.
 
@JoséCarlosSantos Actually it doesn't. Once it is negative score, it is open for deletion (you can refresh the page to get the option). Unfortunately I don't have any delete-votes right now.
 
3:21 PM
@user21820 Now, it only needs one more downvote.
 
@JoséCarlosSantos I'll have to come back to it tomorrow. =)
 
@user21820 My guess is that some kind soul will cast the remaining vote. ;-)
 
 
1 hour later…
4:34 PM
-6
Q: Math Olympiad Question (GEOMETRY)

Sindid∆ADB Is A right angled triangle where Angle ADB is 90°,EF is perpendicular to AB From any point E on BD.Line AE intersects the circumcircle of ∆ADB at H,HF and DB intersrcts at G.DE=5 ,EG =3 then What's the value of BG?

 
4:51 PM
PSQ and the icing on the cake is the followup comment "Please! Badly needed!"
 
5:32 PM
This poor question somehow ended on the HNQ.
 
RRL
@ArnaudD I voted to close.
 
RRL
5:59 PM
Another bad question for closure.
 
This has no pedagogical value. "Go look up a formula in a book" is not an answer. X(
 
6:23 PM
@XanderHenderson I agree. It can be deleted now.
 
@XanderHenderson I don't agree with the idea that such a solution needs deletion at all. I've seen lots of answers of the form "this follows from an application of such and such a theorem thusly..." If it had just been the formula with no context, I might have agreed, but the citation makes it a complete and useful answer. it's doesn't even merit a downvote. I think it makes perfect sense for an answer like this to exist with a low, nonnegative score.
 
6:40 PM
@rschwieb Even when the proof is so simple as in this case?
 
@JoséCarlosSantos I don't see how that is a criterion for deletion. Things that qualify as legit answers should stay put, and then the voting can be the measure of how good it is. Of course, I'm assuming all other things are equal.
In fact, it seems to be the only answer that draws attention to the fact it follows from a known formula, one which is useful to know in general. In that respect it has something the other answers do not...
 
6:56 PM
@rschwieb Right. It was a lack of judgement from me. :-(
 
7:31 PM
@rschwieb I did not vote to delete the answer, but I did downvote it. The hovertext for the downvote arrow reads "This answer is not useful." I don't find the answer at all useful. "Go look up a formula in a book" is not, as far as I am concerned, useful.
On the other hand, if the answer read "This is a well known formula: [formula]. It can be derived as follows: [two lines of computation]," then I would feel it was useful.
 
@XanderHenderson Sorry, yes the combination of your comment and the next gave me the wrong impression of intent.
 
I agree that calling attention to known results can be helpful, but a good answer needs to be more than the correct Google term (though I do think that "Try Googling geometric series" is a good comment.). ;)
 
also agreed
 
Groovy.
 
 
4 hours later…
RRL
11:17 PM
For closure: C1, C2,C3, C4, C5
 

« first day (2561 days earlier)      last day (1927 days later) »