« first day (3506 days earlier)      last day (1459 days later) » 
01:00 - 18:0018:00 - 00:00

6:09 PM
@NautArch That's a great question. Back in the early 80's, my Fighting Man was flying around on the back of one of those Ebony Fly magic items. He maneuvered to a high position for a diving shot over a dragon and took a long shot down, dragon was fleeing/bugging out. (Between me and our Magic User, we had done some damage) The DM estimated that the shot, once it hit (I rolled a 19! woot!) had travelled over a half of a mile, but most of the distance was in the vertical.
 
@KorvinStarmast that's pretty cool! Was that a legit range for that attack?
I just really question some of these super-long range extension options 5e has. They dno't seem viable during an actual battle.
 
@NautArch If you believe in verisimilitude, yes (both the DM and I were in flight training at the time, and immersed in Boyd's Dog Fighting/OODA loop stuff)
If you went by how many inches? Uh, prolly not.
 
hehe
 
@NautArch Theater of the mind was near ~200 ft (5E). I tried to hit an escaping displacer beast with a longbow (no sharpshooter). I missed.
 
Specifically in D&D, or can this include other tabletop games?
 
6:11 PM
@NautArch Lemme check Long Bow range from Greyhawk, as that's what we were using: OD&D Plus Greyhawk.
 
@Kuerten I think long ranges have more viability in ToTM.
 
Two hundred yards/600' for a long bow shot? Yeah, it's doable, but it's a tough shot even for a good archer.
 
But in general, it just doesn't seem practical. which is disappointing.
 
D&D is a bit about "larger than life" and such, though.
 
@KorvinStarmast Yep! It's also why i'm still considering letting resistances stack.
1d4
 
6:14 PM
4
 
@NautArch I agree. The usual grid my group uses isn't enough for a 200 ft. vs 200 ft. battlefield.
 
2d4
 
4d10
 
6
6
1
9
 
6:17 PM
2d4
 
@NautArch Long Bow range in Chainmail/OD&D was 21", which outdoors was 210 yards; indoors was 210 feet.
The DM certainly gave me the benefit of the doubt on the "down hill shot extending the range ..." all in all a lucky shot.
Longest shot I took ToTM / 5E was with Nits DMing during a chase in Port (Nyanzaru?) in Chult. Trogdor (Paladin) and I were chasing a spy/rogue/Assassin kind of NPC who had that bonus action dash, and he was getting away; only reason I could keep following him was that I'd already cast hunter's mark. I got two shots in at long range, both of which hit and the second dropped him; I'd not have been able to get a third based on Nits debrief afterwards.
That flat +2 bonus for archery fighting style was the clincher.
 
@KorvinStarmast nice!
 
That was before we met Bludfont in the jungle, I think.
 
I once used Hunters Mark to chase a cambion.
 
6:25 PM
@NautArch Vengeance Pally?
 
@KorvinStarmast Yup. Damage dealing machine.
 
I hope our first campaign's DM can return from real life haiatus. Our vengeance paladin dwarf had just hit level 7 and was beginning to get into his own as a damage machine.
And I miss my tempest cleric. :(
 
I miss playing my paladin, too.
Level 20 vengeance pally is a beast.
That's a fun capstone.
 
Wow, getting to level 20, glad your group could stay together. THat's rare.
 
@KorvinStarmast And we're still together! Almost 6 year long campaign. New campaign now with the previous DM now a player, and a player moved up to DM.
Sadly on hold. But that's why I"m running Dead in Thay.
 
6:29 PM
Coolness. Our group is now in a home brew world, my brother's, which we take turns DMing. I have a new batch almost done with Sunless Citadel, and I have the hools out to get them into Forge of Fury. But my evil plan is to get them to Hidden Shrine.
 
Yeah, these main campaigns are all homebrew.
If you can do DOomvault, I'd really recommend it.
WHite plume...notsomuch.
 
Oh, we will, but that will take a while. I expect our group will want to do White Plume, but I may run them through the Giants. Not sure yet.
My brother has confirmed "drow exist in this campaign world, but are rarely seen on the surface"
 
@KorvinStarmast there is some fun stuff in there but managing the weapons...not easy
 
@NautArch I think our group will do fine with those weapons; and hilarity will ensue! 8^D
 
 
2 hours later…
8:40 PM
If a question has several comments beneath it saying "related: [related question here]" should they be tidied up into a single comment and have the others flagged for deletion or just leave them be?
 
Personally I think they ought to be tidied up
 
Are they drowning up other comments? How many is several?
 
Oh that's a good metric, if other comments are being lost/hidden
The question I was thinking about was this one and anything else similar, but none of the comments are being lost so it should be fine
 
@KorvinStarmast I've hit targets at 100 yd, but it's target shooting at that range, not bullseye shooting. I can imagine a heavier draw and getting out to 200 yd, but it's kind of a crapshoot at that distance. (Unless I've got a hundred friends standing alongside me, doing the same thing!)
 
@nitsua60 100 yards is still a fine shot. :) (I have reached my voting limit today, so I guess I need to step back, and ... wait, there's the fridge. And lookee there, a cold beer... Later, folks )
 
8:58 PM
@KorvinStarmast Vaya con cerveza, amigo!
 
9:20 PM
6
Q: Can 2 different martial fighting styles used together at the same time? for example protection and defense from a fighter champion lvl 10+

DT8A champion fighter gets a second fighting style at 10th level. Can the 2 different martial fighting styles be used together at the same time? For example protection and defense from a champion fighter, would it gain both bonuses?

 
10:06 PM
5
Q: Do Bane/Bless apply to death saving throws?

IzzyPossibly related. The text of Bane reads: Whenever a target [...] makes an attack roll or saving throw before the spell ends, the target must roll a d4 and subtract the number rolled from the attack roll or saving throw. Emphasis mine. Bless reads similarly. Based on this text, and the lin...

 
Ben
10:47 PM
Morning all
 
Evening
 
Yawp.
 
Hey there everyone. I just wanted to drop this reminder from your friendly moderator team:
Note: discussions about gender and sex (including discussion about pronouns) have the opportunity to harm others. Please be very careful when engaging in such discussions on this site. It is unacceptable to, in any form, denigrate someone's personhood or identity on this site. Knowingly and intentionally harming others in this way is unacceptable, morally wrong, and against the rules, and will result in moderator action.
11
More often than not, we tend to be pretty good about this here, but when we aren't, people get hurt. As always, be kind and wonderful to each other.
 
Has a thing happened?
 
Yes, but nothing that needs to be discussed further in public.
 
11:01 PM
No need for that, I only asked, and deliberately didn't ask for details.
If it was intended as a that.
 
Oh, I meant "public" as in "with anybody but the person/people involved". So yeah, I think I understood what you were saying.
 
Worldbuilding: manilla (European term; each region has its own name for the currency) is a bronze or copper currency used in West Africa into the 1940s. The Leopard People in Nnedi Okorafor's Akata Witch (Sunny's Adventures) novels have a magical version called chittim which falls from the sky when they learn something, because in their society knowledge and insight are true wealth.
 
11:22 PM
that ^^ might be my favorite thing this week.
 
The Akata Witch novels are so good.
 
Am I an A-hole for fudging a roll and making a player go down if I think it would help motivate the party?
 
@Himitsu_no_Yami As long as your table is theoretically ok with narrative over rolls gameplay, you're totally cool!
It would be hard to find a D&D DM that hadn't fudged a roll here or there.
 
At my tables I conspire with the players to make dramatic things happen to the characters, so it'd be a collaborative choice rather than GM fiat.
 
@Himitsu_no_Yami I'm making an assumption that this is D&D BTW, in many other games it would be even more ok. :)
 
11:28 PM
yeah, it's D&D 5e
 
Black Armada's smaller games are temporarily PWYW, and their larger games (L*vecraftesque, Bite Marks, Flotsam: Adrift Amongst the Stars) are 19% off.
 
Ben
Speaking of fudge rolls, I'm a fan of the "hey what's your <stat>? Hmm... (Roll dice) ok. Ty"
:P
 
Heh, I used to do that.
 
Ben
It's important to not overdo it of course :p
 
11:45 PM
CONSEQUENTIAL REDEMPTION by breathingstories is a solo-or-group game about a supervillain finding a chance for redemption during a teamup with superheroes against a larger threat.
 
@Himitsu_no_Yami Only the player can be the judge of that. Removing player agency is generally a contentious move, because you've invited players to play and then suddenly they're sidelined and can't participate. Or, maybe, the player is happy to sit back and watch the cinematics. So you'd have to ask them about it.
 
Well, the player I downed ended up rolling a nat 20 on his death save
 
01:00 - 18:0018:00 - 00:00

« first day (3506 days earlier)      last day (1459 days later) »