« first day (2354 days earlier)      last day (1546 days later) » 

12:38 AM
[meta-tag:deprecated tags] YCor added some comments into post about : meta.mathoverflow.net/questions/862/help-cleanup-tags/2744#2744
3
A: Help cleanup tags!

user9072Done (suggested Feb. 2016, done March 2016) I propose to deprecate abstract-algebra. It seems redundant with other tags, very broad, and the usage seems inconsistent. I feel it is comparable to the meanwhile removed topology and the deprecated geometry. (Explication on terminology: To depreca...

> Not (yet?) done (YCor Feb 01, 2020): I'd suggest to blacklist . This tag exists in about 270 questions, including about 15 in the last 2 years (probably it was written many more times in spite of being deprecated, but has been often replaced or removed by users like me or Martin Sleziak.
> Actually, there was about 17 questions with the only tag , and I've systematically retagged these questions, so at this time there should be none. (Alternatively, I'd suggest to burninate it although I prefer the first option.)
@YCor Regarding your recent edit: The same suggestion was posted here (basically without any response): The existing deprecated tags should be blacklisted. — Martin Sleziak 1 min ago
I have posted some summary of deprecated tags in December: chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/10243/2019/12/23
There are about 400 deleted questions tagged (abstract-algebra): data.stackexchange.com/mathoverflow/query/883845/…
Number of removals of (abstract-algebra) per month: data.stackexchange.com/mathoverflow/query/1186177/…
A (subsequent) same suggestion concerning abstract-algebra with some more info: meta.mathoverflow.net/a/2744/14094YCor 1 min ago
One should first retag all questions using exactly one of these tags. I've done the job for abstract-algebra, namely about 17 questions. For geometry there are about 30 such questions and it's possibly a bit harder. For discrete-mathematics I haven't counted, but it should be easier (as co.combinatorics is a good replacement in most cases) . — YCor 1 min ago
3
Q: How to find questions having only given tag (and no other tags)?

Martin SleziakFor various reasons it is often useful to be able to find questions which have some given tag as a standalone tag. (For example, when discussing whether some tag is useful for this site or not. Or when burnination of some tags is discussed.) Is it possible somehow find those questions which only...

It seems that there are 6 questions which have only the tag: mathoverflow.net/… data.stackexchange.com/mathoverflow/query/131389/…
2
Q: a conjecture about a specific subset of $S_n$

user40096Let $n>3$ be a positive integer.We denote the symmetric group of $n$ elements by $S_n$ and the identity mapping by $id$. For every $f\in S_n$, $f(1,2,\ldots,n)=(a_1,a_2,\ldots,a_n)$, denote $a_n$ by $m(f)$. For any positive integer $1\leq k\leq n-2$, define $f_k\in S_n$ as follow: $f_k:(1,\ldot...

1
Q: the "compact good array" in a "good $N^+$-cycle"

user40096We use $N^+$ to denote the set of positive integers.For any finite array $A:(a_1,b_1),...,(a_k,b_k)$,where every $(a_i,b_i)\in N^+\times N^+$,we call $A$ is good if for every $i\in \{a_1,b_1,...,a_k,b_k\}$,$i$ appears exactly two times in $a_1,b_1,...,a_k,b_k$.For example,$A_1:(1,1)$,$A_2:(1,2),(...

5
Q: Computer platforms for combinatorial search problems/mathematical music theory?

David FeldmanI'm finding programming various combinatorial searches (connected to mathematical music theory) in a general purpose computer language tedious, so I'd like pointers to computer platforms/environment purpose-built to enable such searches. If the answer has the form "Maple can do that" or "Mathe...

1
Q: recursion formula for odd holonomic function

Xuanting Caisuppose we have a map $f:\mathbb{Z}\longrightarrow\mathbb{C}[t^{\pm}]$ with property that $f(i)=-f(-i)$. The algebra $\mathcal{T}=\mathbb{C}[t^{\pm}][L^{\pm},M^{\pm}]/[LM=tML]$ acts on $f$ by $(Lf)(i)=f(i+1),(Mf)(i)=t^if(i)$. Should the annihilating ideal of $f$ generated by annihilators in sy...

2
Q: Calculating greatest common divisor series

user111103How to compute the value of [G(1,x)+G(2,x)+G(3,x)+....+G(x,x)] efficiently? When x can be as large as million.G = greatest common divisor.

3
Q: Choosing k pairs l distance apart from n numbers

IguanaI need to choose $k$ pairs of numbers out of first $n$ natural numbers such that the elements in each pair are $l$ distance apart. For example, if $n = 10, k = 3$ and $l = 2$, $\{(1,3),(4,6),(7,9)\}$ is a valid choice. How many such valid choices are there? I worked out for $l = 1$ and it seems t...

0
Q: Suggestions for a good abstract algebra book

spartani am early undergraduate looking for a good textbook gor algebra, i don't want a too wordy book@@

SEDE returns 29 questions which have only the tag : mathoverflow.net/… data.stackexchange.com/mathoverflow/query/131389/…
1
Q: Identity involving dot product of solid angle and gradient

abhiHow to prove following for $n\geq0$ ? $$\int_{4\pi}d\vec{\Omega}(\vec{\Omega}\cdot\vec{\nabla})^{2n}f(\vec{r})=\frac{4\pi}{2n+1}\nabla^{2n}f(\vec{r})$$ Where, at any point $\vec{r}$, the $\vec{\Omega}$ can be described by the polar angle $\theta$ measured with respect to the z axis and an azimuth...

74
Q: Light reflecting off Christmas-tree balls

Joseph O'Rourke'Twas the night before Christmas and under the tree Was a heap of new balls, stacked tight as can be. The balls so gleaming, they reflect all light rays, Which bounce in the stack every which way. When, what to my wondering mind does occur: A question of interest; I hope you concur! From each poi...

2
Q: What is the sequence that maximizes this distance?

TomásI have posted this question here without answer. Maybe I can get some light here. Suppose we are given $n$ segments $l_1,...,l_n$ in $\mathbb{R}^2$ such that $|l_i|=i,\ \forall\ i=1,...,n$, where $|l_i|$ is the length of $l_i$. Let $\alpha_1,...,\alpha_{n-1}$ be $n-1$ angles such that $\alpha_i>...

2
Q: Determine sub-polygon from line segments with known member connectivity

sidbTest Polygon: Consider the following polygon as attached. Let the known parameter be as follows: •Member to member connectivity, i.e. it is known that A – B, X – E, F – B, etc. for all the members. •All the space co-ordinates (x, y, z) for each co-ordinate is known. Note that we do not kno...

1
Q: Overlaying two domino-like constructions such that all individual pairs of domino-like cells in the overlay have matching symbols

PerpetuumImagine I have two $n$ x $m$ assemblies of $P = (n*m)$ unit square cells on the plane, $(c_{(a,1)}, ..., c_{(a,P)}) \in A$ and $(c_{(b,1)}, ..., c_{(b,P)}) \in B$, where every cell, $c_k$, in a particular assembly must have a distinct color/value. Here, $c_{(a,i)} \neq c_{(a,j)}$ & $c_{(b,i)} \n...

1
Q: Find the bounding box of a circle segment.

lysgaardYou have three points. A,B and C. They define a circle segment that starts at A, goes through B and ends at C. Find the smallest bounding box that encompases the circle segment. Here is a picture: https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/14YwCO0UeMzu-rTLmqULg7HDU5XPYZvSBQdyfu0l71Fs/edit I started cre...

0
Q: Best fit circles inside a square based on side of the square

NeerajaHi, How to calculate number of circles in side a square, if we know the side of the square and the circles all are equal size. Thanks.

7
Q: Euler class of S^1-orbibundle

Shisen LuoGiven a topological space $M$ with a locally free $S^1$ action on it, assume the slice representation holds,(this is often the case, e.g. M is a smooth manifold) then this will make $M$ a principal $S^1$-orbibundle over $M/S^1$. What's the proper way to define the Euler class of this $S^1$-orbibu...

0
Q: Minimum cardinality of the intersection of 2D rectangles

Jiangwei PanLet $S$ be a set of 2D points $(x,y)$ with positive real coordinates, i.e. $x,y>0$. An 2D rectangle $R$ is called an ${Origin-Rectangle}$ if it is decided by the origin $(0,0)$ and another point $(x,y)$ with $x,y>0$. Denote $S_R$ as the subset of points in $S$ covered by $R$, i.e. $S_R = S\cap ...

-3
Q: How to get rotation angles of Image Plane relative to the World Plane?

Ole JSo we have such situation: In this illustration, the first quadrilateral is shown on the Image Plane and the second quadrilateral is shown on the World Plane. [1] In my particular case the Image Plane has 3 quadrilaterals - projections of real world squares, which, as we know, have same size...

0
Q: Is there an algorithm for soving such projection reconstruction geometric problem?

Ole JWe have a grid with red squares on it. Meaning we have an array of 3 squares (with angles == 90 deg) which as we know have same size, lying on the same plane and with same rotation relative to the plane they are lying on, and are not situated on same line on plane. We have a projection of the s...

4
Q: What Islamic tiling patterns are constructible?

Brian WichmannEric Broug in his book Islamic Geometric Patterns gives straightedge and compass construction of some simpler patterns. It is clear his techniques will provide constructions for many Islamic patterns. Looking at formal constructibility, the Wikipedia pages gives Gauss' result that 7, 9, 11, 13,...

10
Q: Triangle centers as power sum minimizing points: Which is the locus of all these points?

Andreas RüdingerSome of the classical triangle centers can be expressed as solutions to minimization problems: Given a triangle $A_1, A_2, A_3$ define $d_i, i=1,2,3$ to be the distance of a given point $P$ to $A_i$, and $f_q$ as the sum of the $q$-th power of these distances:$f_q = \sum_{i=1}^3 d_i^q$. I'm looki...

4
Q: Intersection volume of two tori (Quantitating the orientational freedom of catenane rings?)

Rob GreyAt the risk of posting too low-level a question... Please consider two tori, with tube radii $r_1$ and $r_2$, and center-of-the-hole to center-of-the-tube radii $c_1$ and $c_2$. I'd like to find an analytical expression for the overlap volume as a function of the distance between the hole cent...

1
Q: How does one map regression depth to undirected depth of a point?

Umar SheikhThe regression depth of a line is the minimum number of points it has to cross to take it from its initial position to vertical. The undirected depth of a point is the minimum number of lines a ray originating at the point will cross before escaping. If we use projective duality, then regression ...

1
Q: H-representation versus V-representation

Lior EldarThe $H$-representation of a convex polytope $S$, is just a set of linear inequalities corresponding to the intersection of halfspaces: $S = ( x | Ax\leq b )$. One could also represent a convex polytope as the convex-hull of its vertices, called the $V$-representation: $S = conv(a_1,..., a_m)$. ...

0
Q: How many different rectangles (in terms of area) can fit in a 20-unit-wide square?

user9107How many different rectangles (in terms of area) can fit in a 20-unit-wide square? The rectangles can be squares, and their dimensions are integers.

4
Q: Cosine sum problem

Richard TConsider any n points on the circumference of a circle. Draw a straight line link between each pair of points with a link weight consisting of the cosine of the angle the link subtends at the centre. It seems that If the convex hull of the point set contains the centre of the circle, then some p...

0
Q: Settling a Circular Argument: Room for One More?

GmackematixBy using a regular hexagonal arrangement it is simple to fit 19 identical circles into a larger circle of five times the radius with no circles overlapping. This leaves an area equal to six smaller circles uncovered. Is it possible to rearrange the 19 circles to accommodate a twentieth circle of ...

2
Q: How to pick a random direction in n-dimensional space

dsplaistedI want to pick a random direction in n-dimensional space. How can I do this? The reason I want to do this is to pick a neighbor for hill climbing optimization.

1
Q: Intersection between a line and a cube in $D$ dimensions

Carlos Navarro AstiasaránSay we have a space of dimension $D$. Say we have a $D$-cube of side $l$ centered at the origin and inside it we have a point $P\in \mathbb{R}^D$ and a collection of $D-1$ angles $\phi_1, \phi_2, \ldots \phi_{D-1}$. Then, say we have a line $r$ that is defined by the point $P$ and the angles. Is...

-1
Q: Points in circles that form a given geometric pattern

EllipsissiI am not a specialist in maths, so I thank you very much for any help you can give me. Consider two circles C1, C2. Q1: Find the points that are in the intersection of C1 and C2, this is easy ! Q2: Find two points p1 and p2, such that (p1 \in C1) and (p2 \in C2), and (distance(p1, p2)= D). Is ...

0
Q: 3d width and cross section

ojalaGreetings, We have a horn-shaped 3d body, which is represented as a list of vertices and faces. Each face is a triangle represented by 3 vertices. The body is positioned along the Z-axis (height). We would like to make several cuts at certain heights. Each cut (a plane perpendicular to the Z- ax...

2
Q: Linear transformation takes a polygon to another one.

AAKSay we have $n$-gons $P$ and $Q$. Is there any necessary condition for $Q = f(P)$, for some linear transformation $f : \mathbb{R}^2 \to \mathbb{R}^2$? Sorry if this is too elementary / general.

0
Q: What happens to the volume of an ellipsoid as the number of dimensions increases?

EdwardWould the volume of an ellipsoid continuously increase if one keeps adding radii along new dimensions? What is the volume of ellipsoid with infinite dimensions?

0
Q: Explicit example of a smooth - but not analytic- closed curve without self-intersections

LouisThere exist smooth - but not analytic - closed curves without self-intersections. I just would like to see a simple example of such a curve.

0
Q: Shortest distance along the surface of the hyperboloid

Igor DemidovGiven two points A and B on the surface of the hyperboloid x^2+y^2-z^2=1. How to find the shortest distance between them along the surface?

0
Q: Polygon Chain - Conversion to non-crossing while preserving shape?

MonteI have polygon chains similar to the following... http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/62/Self_crossed_polygonal_chain.svg/220px-Self_crossed_polygonal_chain.svg.png ...given the chain in the image, how would I go about calculating a chain that defines the same shape but withou...

1
Q: Irrationality of square root of 2

Christian It is possible to explain me the 18th proof of the irrationality of square root of 2 from the following site? http://www.cut-the-knot.org/proofs/sq_root.shtml

 
 
8 hours later…
9:01 AM
There are now 800 questions with deprecated tags. There were 900 such questions in June 2018, 1000 in August 2017.
 
 
2 hours later…
10:36 AM
@MartinSleziak YCor edited the tags on that question: mathoverflow.net/posts/65617/revisions
-1
Q: Suggestions for a good abstract algebra book

spartani am early undergraduate looking for a good textbook gor algebra, i don't want a too wordy book@@

I have wrote quite a bit about blacklisting the deprecated tags both in my post on meta and also here in chat: chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/10243/conversation/…

Blacklisting (deprecated) tag while they still exist

Feb 27 '19 at 17:05, 2 days total – 68 messages, 2 users, 0 stars

Bookmarked Mar 2 '19 at 6:13 by Martin Sleziak

Since various ways of removing tags were recently mentioned, let me just summarize what are differences.
Of course, a tag is removed if there are no questions in the tag left. (Or if there is a single question, the tag is older than 6 month and there is no tag-wiki.)
Of course, manual retagging would mean a lot of bumping for big tags (such as the three deprecated tags).
Moderators can merge tags. This does not bump any questions.
For example, if all remaining questions in are suitable for , if a moderator merges (abstract-algebra) into (gr.group-theory) then of (abstract-algebra) are changed to (gr.group-theory). (And this also changes the name of the tag in the revision history.)
On MathOverflow, the mods sometimes use merge into the tag - which basically removes the merged tag, but the (tag-removed) remains there instead. Meta Stack Exchange: Burnination vs. merging into a specific tag.
Things which cannot be done by moderators are burnination and blacklisting - to do such thing, Stack Exchange staff has to be involved.
Blacklisting doesn't mean that the tag is removed. However, it means that the tag cannot be added to new questions. (And if an existing question - which already has the tag - is edited, the edit isn't allowed without removing the tag.)
I have also mentioned these things in the question on meta and in the chat conversation that I've linked above.
Burnination means that all instances of the tags are removed (both from the question and from the revision history). Meta Stack Exchange: What does it mean to “burninate” a tag?
These two things are independent - it is possible to blacklist tag without burninating it, it is possible to burninate a tag without blacklisting it.
In both cases (burnination/blacklisting), no questions are bumped.
So far I did not get any response from MathOverflow moderators about the suggestion to blacklist the deprecated tags.
This comment by François G. Dorais suggest that maybe he had merging of deprecated tags into some other tag in mind (after sufficient clean-up). Still, he did not say clearly whether this is the reason for the suggestion he made:
Aug 9 '17 at 1:34, by François G. Dorais
For , I think it's a good idea to first retag all the questions that don't have any of the obvious replacements: , , . That leaves a little over 200 questions...
From these comments, it seems that the moderators are not too keen on blacklisting the deprecated tags (or blacklisting the tags in general):
@MartinSleziak The tag-excerpt option only. Blacklisting is mostly useful for repeat offenders: deprecated tags that get created over and over again. That problem is very rare on MO. — François G. Dorais ♦ Feb 25 '19 at 6:04
May 17 '17 at 12:57, by François G. Dorais
@MartinSleziak we hardly ever blacklist tags. We do blacklist other things but not tags. "completeness" and "untagged" are the only two.
@YCor I have summarized above what I know about blacklisting, burnination and various ways to remove tags.
I thought that writing this in chat is slightly better - I did not want to leave too many comments on meta. (And also rules about discussion in chat are less string that discussion in comments on main/meta. Messages in chat are rarely removed by mods.)
I have also mentioned the response from the mods that I got so far.
I have sent you an invitation to this room, so you should get some notification.
On an unrelated note, I see that you have created the tag .
As I mentioned yesterday, this tag has been created and removed before. There is also a related post on meta - Tag for errata of books - maybe you'd like to leave a comment there (or post an answer).
We will see whether some users object to the new tag. (As you can see, the previous instance of this tag was removed on the same day when it was created.)
The tags which only have only a single question are automatically removed after 6 months, unless they have a tag-wiki. So if you think that this tag should be kept, perhaps it should eventually be added to one more question or the tag-wiki should be created.
If the tag stays on MO, the famous question "Errata for Atiyah-Macdonald" seems like a reasonable candidate for this tag.
For other, to have context to the above conversation, I'll copy here the recent post and some recent comments.
16
Q: The existing deprecated tags should be blacklisted

Martin SleziakTL;DR: I suggest to blacklist the deprecated tags that still exist on some questions, in order to prevent them from being added to new questions. There are a few tags which are deprecated and should not be used at all, but still exist on the site.1 Ideally such tags should be completely removed,...

One should first retag all questions using exactly one of these tags. I've done the job for abstract-algebra, namely about 17 questions. For geometry there are about 30 such questions and it's possibly a bit harder. For discrete-mathematics I haven't counted, but it should be easier (as co.combinatorics is a good replacement in most cases) . — YCor 10 hours ago
@YCor Since you've mentioned questions which only have single tags, I have posted the summary here in chat. However, I suggested blacklisting those tags mainly to prevent them from being added to new posts - I think this can be done without retagging the old posts. (Burnination would be a different matter - but nobody is going to actually suggest burnination or merging of those tags without major cleanup before that.) — Martin Sleziak 10 hours ago
@MartinSleziak I actually thought of burninating the tag abstract-algebra and I'm definitely suggesting this (I thought blacklisting was strictly stronger). Browsing through the list of about 270 posts with this tag, almost all have a reasonable tag in addition (I have retagged all tagged only abstract-algebra, and also retagged a few more, notably when they had only narrow or non-specific or meta tags). — YCor 5 hours ago
3
A: Help cleanup tags!

user9072Done (suggested Feb. 2016, done March 2016) I propose to deprecate abstract-algebra. It seems redundant with other tags, very broad, and the usage seems inconsistent. I feel it is comparable to the meanwhile removed topology and the deprecated geometry. (Explication on terminology: To depreca...

I have copied the recent addition also here in chat: chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/10243?m=53411689#53411689
@YCor Regarding your recent edit: The same suggestion was posted here (basically without any response): The existing deprecated tags should be blacklisted. — Martin Sleziak 11 hours ago
Actually I meant burninate as well, which wasn't part of the linked question. Burninate and blacklist seem to be quite disjoint facts since one concerns the past and the other concerns the future. Taking care of posts with a single tag was obviously having in mind burnination. — YCor 5 hours ago
 
 
1 hour later…
12:25 PM
Maybe I should have mentioned synonyms as another way of dealing with deprecated tags. For example, there is a synonym , which means that user cannot create the tag (topology). (Which used to be deprecate, then it was removed and created again.)
Of course, it might sometime cause incorrectly tagged questions. (A user might put without noticing that it is automatically changed to .)
Some comments on this tag synonym are here: chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/10243/2017/8/23 In the same conversation, François G. Dorais also made this suggestion:
Aug 23 '17 at 16:11, by François G. Dorais
I had an idea to prevent reappearance of deprecated tags merge into and create a synonym. Thoughts?
However, it seems unlikely that a tag synonym would be a reasonable way of dealing with .
 
 
2 hours later…
2:15 PM
Apart from the questions which had this tag before it was removed, this question also seems like a reasonable candidate for the tag: Errata database? (Assuming that this time the tag is kept.)
 
 
2 hours later…
3:47 PM
Speaking of deprecated tags sleepless in beantown has taxonomist badge for discrete-mathematics, vonjd gas taxonomist badge for abstract-algebra.
 
 
1 hour later…
5:04 PM
This question was bumped recently: Hyper-Complex and quaternionic Kahler Geometry. I guess that would be suitable there or possibly - but I'd prefer somebody who knows more about this area to make the call. The question is also missing a top-level tag.
8
Q: Hyper-Complex and quaternionic Kahler Geometry

Jean DelinezWhat is the exact relationship hyper-complex and quaternionic Kahler manifolds? From Wikipedia we get that hyper-Kahler manifolds are both hyper-complex and quaternionic Kahler. Thus, the two families have a non-empty intersection. But this is all I can conclude. Moreover, quaternionic projectiv...

 
 
5 hours later…
10:04 PM
I haven't created the tag "errata". I retagged the question where it was created (and hesitated to remove it). mathoverflow.net/posts/351640/revisions
About "Hyper-Complex and quaternionic Kahler Geometry": I've added the tag "hyperkaehler". I think it doesn't necessarily need a top level tag because complex-geometry is broad enough (2.2k questions), but I've added dg.differential-geometry (the two main top-level tags above complex-geometry would be dg.differential-geometry and ag.algebraic-geometry, here the first one seems closer)
One could indeed make 'discrete-mathematics' synonym of 'co.combinatorics'. In a few cases it would not be optimal but this would be little harm. No such synonym seems doable for 'geometry' and 'abstract-algebra'.
 

« first day (2354 days earlier)      last day (1546 days later) »