« first day (2459 days earlier)      last day (66 days later) » 

12:00 AM
RELOAD! There are 6379 unanswered questions (90.0759% answered)
yeah..none of those revenu streams sound amazing to me
need to read the accounts
the revenue itself isn't actually that bad
This, from your link above,...sounds like what it feel like
"The CMs have been actively told (read: commanded) that they cannot empathise with the community, a wedge is being driven between us, the community and our points of contact with the company, the CM team."
it's just ... not something the VCs behind a company like to see
@OliverSchonrock yea, that's been a smouldering issue behind the curtains for quite some while now
sorry, you mean : revenue= OKish...but not hockey stick => unhappy VC ... ?
12:04 AM
yea, basically
if that's the case, that makes lots of sense, and that might be driven some of the weird anti community decision from central
SO didn't used to aim for hockey stick type revenue graphs, which was a good starting idea
and it allowed multiple strong and cohesive communities to form
when did they get VC funding?
not at the beginning?
years and years back
not directly at the beginning, no, but reasonably quickly after
right...so the "we don't aim for hockey sticks", was a philosophy...not a fact
philosophy always gets overtaken by facts...of the financial variety
12:07 AM
actually... I checked back and there were four VC funding rounds
bascially they know they are hosed and are in the last twicthing throws & making a bunch of bad decisionsa
the first was two years after founding (in 2010), and then in 2011, 2013 and the last in 2015
right..and nothing for 5yrs
and the money has now run out
so the mgmt team is under huge pressure and they are trying to "crisis manage"..and making a bunch of mistakes
12:09 AM
the company is highly likely to be profitable, actually
From the public comments of the former CEO it seems that they're aiming for an IPO
it has to be more than profitable..it has to produce hckey sticks
and they changed CEO three months ago to work towards that IPO
wonder what the user graph looks like for SO
yeah I thought that guy was new
anyway...code review..is a totally niche corner, so you guys can basically do what yo want..non one wilkl care
you will be first to get shut down too
if you have flat user graphs..then defiitely
the public data dump suggests that SO signups are somewhat plateaued out at 1.5m / yr
and the "net"?
12:13 AM
I think the cost of shutting small sites down exceeds the cost savings
depends if there is manager
site costs nothing to run
it's not like the company pays a lot to keep the site running, it's basically a single webserver
well at 10 questions per week I shouild hope so
@OliverSchonrock I mean for all of the sites on Stack Exchange aside from Stack Overflow, you know?
but the real cost is in SW. How much does it cost to merge in the updates etc
12:14 AM
the cost is probably virtually nonexistent, because the software has been unified.
From my experience it doesn't quite work that way, unless they are more clever than me
there used to be a lot more cost associated with running the network, but they've unified the codebase there
but still the cost will be low
Stack Overflow runs on the same code as Code Review
basically, that is
yeah it's the "basically" which makes it "non-zero"
anyway..all mute
12:16 AM
there's some special cases for Stack Overflow around the SaaS thing as well as the Job platform
everything else is running off of runtime-configurable feature switches
my prediction..the IPO will never happen. The whole thing will go tits up. The VCs will be angry, but the community will be sold for a song and then it's a vaiable company. It should never have received VC funding....It's just a fancy forum..
I think you're vastly underestimating what the enterprise versions bring in as revenue
The company doesn't make the money based on users
but eh
That might be...but that's a "separate business" really....it might get spun out...still not worth the VC money which must be in the 10s of millions after 4 rounds...the public community os not moneytisable
@OliverSchonrock 68M
and they want 10x
12:20 AM
Actually the public community is monetizable through ads
Ads alone pull in close to 30M pa in revenue
love to know what the ad rev is
never seen one
Apparently the current revenue is close to 70M$
oh wait ... i run uBlock origin
it's a dev community
you have an overconfident inference there...
what does that mean?
12:22 AM
there's millions of devs out there that don't use uBlock or similar tools
just because you (and probably most people you know) use something like that, it's not reasonable to infer that this applies to the visitor base of Stack Overflow at large
do they pay the moderators at the top?
sure, I agree
"moderators at the top"?
i dunno..there is probably someone (or 10) who works for SO and "manages the colunteer moderator community"
yea... 5 people
you know the person that fired Monica..or whoever that was
12:25 AM
Anyway, it's been nice chatting. I think the idea of CR is great. I think the fomat is challenging, because it's hard to put "relevant amount of real code" in the space/time available, but it just about works...ish.
I think because it's hard, it is and probably will remain niche
and the "huge range of rules" and their enthusiastic enforcement (where it is feels like many of them were written because one question went wrong 5 years ago)...is an obstacle to growth. That's my oipnion based on my personal experience over the last 2 months. Sometimes it takes a "semi outsider to say that. So I am . Do with it what you will.

I would put it to you. At 10 questions per week and 20 modeators. it's a not site.
we're at ... 4 moderators.
I have personally interacted with more than that
at least they acted like moderators
everyone else is just normal users that were around for a while and got the ability to do some cleanup
from my POV
same difference
from a users POV
moderators set the culture
"active users" act as an amplifier
So anyway, It's late here. Thanks for listening. Maybe some of what I said makes sense to you. Maybe you will even discuss or do some of it.

If not, it's no skin off my nose.

I can write my own questions and the answers for them in a local file with emacs. Then I can invite a mate over for coffee.. Same traffic? ;-)

Have a good one.
1:15 AM
possible answer invalidation by Featurea on question by Featurea: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236206/revisions
1 hour later…
2:22 AM
Q: Find and replace a string in c/c++ without using standard library

Code_So1dierI'm solving a problem with find and replace a substring in a string. I've solved it using python with a couple of lines, in c++ using std library and now solved it with c by using allocation on the stack. I want to get genuine feedback on the code I wrote and perhaps make it simpler. The constra...

1 hour later…
3:23 AM
"Is there a way to make this better."—that's not what Stack Overflow is for. Consider posting on Code Review, after taking their tour and reading their "How to Ask" page. — Chris 18 secs ago
I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it belongs on Code ReviewChris 56 secs ago
2 hours later…
5:41 AM
6:08 AM
Q: find successor in binary seach tree

SowmyaI am trying to understand the node deletion as implemented in Python at this site. When a node has two children, I understand that I can just pick the right-most node in the left sub-tree (or the left-most node in the right sub-tree) as a replacement for the node to be deleted (referred as 'cur...

1 hour later…
7:25 AM
@OliverSchonrock What you could do, is compare the "A year on moderation" posts posted on most metas to compare some measure of site-activity, should you be really interested in that.
Q: 2019: a year in moderation

Shog9It's New Year's Day in Stack Exchange land... A distinguishing characteristic of these sites is how they are moderated: We designed the Stack Exchange network engine to be mostly self-regulating, in that we amortize the overall moderation cost of the system across thousands of teeny-tiny sli...

Q: 2019: a year in moderation

Shog9It's New Year's Day in Stack Exchange land... A distinguishing characteristic of these sites is how they are moderated: We designed the Stack Exchange network engine to be mostly self-regulating, in that we amortize the overall moderation cost of the system across thousands of teeny-tiny sli...

Q: 2019: a year in moderation

Shog9It's New Year's Day in Stack Exchange land... A distinguishing characteristic of these sites is how they are moderated: We designed the Stack Exchange network engine to be mostly self-regulating, in that we amortize the overall moderation cost of the system across thousands of teeny-tiny sli...

CR, Writing and Avation, as pseudo-random examples.
@Duga Another poor migration. Not touching that.
7:40 AM
possible answer invalidation by oscarfrederiksen on question by oscarfrederiksen: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236097/revisions
possible answer invalidation by Martin R on question by Utkarsh Sharma: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236190/revisions
7:56 AM
@Mast @Mast
@Mast @mast Haven't understood your numbers. But this morning the "policy" of putting off new users continues: codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/236212/… 2 "incorrect" and "hostile" comments, by an experienced user/.moderator....another one bites the dust? I see this every day.
As this is basically working code, you might find better answers on CodeReviewgermi 41 secs ago
8:18 AM
@OliverSchonrock They aren't my numbers, I just provide the link to them.
@Mast sure. I meant "the numbers you provided". More importantly: "the other point"...?
As for your classification of the comments, if you disagree with the overall tone of comments on this site and have a bunch of examples, please take them to meta. On meta, policy is discussed and at times even modified.
Over here, a couple of people will read your concerns. On meta, a much bigger portion of the community will.
I'd urge you to keep the question constructive.
I am not on a crusade. If people are not interested in having "no users", then I am not going to convince anyone. TBH the reactions I have had so far are that " no we don't care about having no users, because we are implementing the policy". I have tried many "styles" of presenting this "argument". None have drawn a receptive response. If there is no fundamental interest in growing the community from a low base, then I am wasting my breath.
I understand how the SE network can feel hard to fit-in as a new user. It's not a forum. It's Q&A. And that means having guidelines and a policy that's more strict. Even if that has unintended consequences, since the alternative may as well be worse. Of-course, if you know a good middle-road, please share. We might learn something.
The question is: "are you open to learning"?
8:25 AM
That, of-course, completely depends on what you're offering. If none of it is constructive, I'd be wasting my effort just like you feel you're wasting your breath.
Take that specific link above. The question is from a brand spanking new account. The code is competent, it compiles and works from what I can see. And the first comment is a) negative b) wrong. The "constructive" feedback I am giving is that "You should look to encourage new users", not "bark at them with poorly informed" comments. Is that constructive enough?
Which 'specific link above'?
The exchange on that question is very typical of what I have a) experienced myself and b) seen other new users experience.
There are a lot of links on my screen.
8:29 AM
@OliverSchonrock To properly review that question, we need additional information. For example, it's tagged both C++ and C, while it definitely looks it's C from a C++ background. So only should survive. The first comment indicates something along those lines. That's not negative, that's willing to help.
Not wrong either.
So no, I don't think your remarks about that comment are constructive. From my point of view, they're borderline harassment.
Wrong is the stdio.h comment...it's both negative and wrong
and yes there a question of clarity with C and C++
see my comment
where I try to demonstrate that I have a) made some effort to compile the code and the n ask for clarification
All that first comment by L.F. is requesting clarification, to improve the incoming answers.
whereas LF (and you) are concerned with the "policy of tagging", which is franbkly immaterial and can be addressed later?>
The stdio comment just a cheap point scoring shot
No, tags are not immaterial. They're used by the reviewers to shape their answers.
and you have failed to address it
8:31 AM
@OliverSchonrock No, it's an honest source of confusion.
reviewers will see it's C
it's so fundamental
if that user is confused about stdio and the OP's intent they should refrain from commenting
It should be clarified to make sure, otherwise the user may get wrong answers and nobody's happy.
I find this a lot: lots of knowledge about policy and (apparently) none about the subject matter
did you see my other comment
the question has been edited twice already
I have written more reviews than you, been around here longer than you, so the one without knowledge of what's going on is you. Can you stop with the accusations?
no-one has read the code yet
8:33 AM
I got work to do. Good day.
"i have been here longer than you": That reply is exactly the the issue. You have been modearting a site with no users longer than me, correct. That's the attitude which comes across. No acknowledgemeht that what is happening on that question is very poor. It's negative and wrong.
8:51 AM
Q: The CRUD interface I created for my new app. Creates, updates, deletes, reads and lists

Midori KocakHere is the Interface I am using in my working app. <?php declare(strict_types=1); namespace midorikocak\nano; use Exception; interface CrudInterface { /** * @param array $data Array data of an Item. * @return array Array data of an Item with id. * @throws Exception if ...

9:41 AM
This is a question for codereviewCid 25 secs ago
10:25 AM
possible answer invalidation by Leonleon1 on question by Leonleon1: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236188/revisions
IMO, it's better to ask this question on codereview.stackexchange.comPavel Anikhouski 13 secs ago
@Duga rolled back
10:55 AM
possible answer invalidation by user2910348 on question by user2910348: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236052/revisions
11:34 AM
Q: Recursive Descent Parser Implementation for Recursive Language

HugoI'm writing toy parsers for toy languages to learn how parsers work. Assuming a language as follows (in sketchy EBNF patois) expression := lparen [datum] [expression [datum]] rparen datum := any string of characters other than ( or ) rparen := ( lparen := ) These are some val...

11:54 AM
Q: ffmpeg batch script for video resizing - improved

user2910348I posted a question here ffmpeg batch script for video resizing but I forgot the issue of the rotation and the video files were scaled with wrong dimensions. Below is the improved version of the script #!/bin/bash set -eu status=true fail() { echo "$@" >&2 status=false } # Resize a ...

1 hour later…
1:02 PM
@Heslacher Did you remove one or more comments on the answer as well?
@Heslacher OK, I guess I'm glad the commentator rethought the comment.
Q: Tic-Tac-Toe game suggestion

Utkarsh SharmaThis is my first project and I am new to programming so I don't know that many functions, but I have made tic-tac-toe. Please suggest any changes to shorten the code or make it more effective. Any suggestions are welcome! .Keep in mind that I am a complete beginner and I don't know many of the fu...

1:51 PM
In this case I’m an intern so as long my logic is right I’ll go along with the code review as long as it’s not very obviously bad — xeu just now
Q: Function for calculating and ranking scores

gracie catherineWould love feedback on a vanilla JS challenge I've recently completed. It is a method for calculating and ranking scores. If possible, I would love to make it better. Any suggestions welcome. Challenge directions: "Please write code in Javascript to convert the data from Input format to the outp...

2:10 PM
I guess this is better suited on codereview stack — B001ᛦ 55 secs ago
I have tried to post on there however I get the following message: Questions on Code Review Stack Exchange must contain at least 3 lines of code. — InitialisingAttributes 29 secs ago
2:37 PM
Q: Code to test four conditions if C#

IngTun2018First I have two conditions on the number of list elements,then in one of these conditions I have two others conditons to treat it : My code: List<StringBuilder> result = ReadResult_WS_Import(NameFile); if ((result != null) && (result.Any())) { var is_No_Er...

3:03 PM
Ryan Donovan on January 27, 2020

We at the Stack Overflow blog want to provide our community, as well as the larger programming community, with interesting articles about what life is like as a coder today. Whether that’s coverage of research on security vulnerabilities in Stack Overflow code examples, insights into what it really takes to be a full-stack engineer, or a look at the never-ending migration from Python 2 to 3, we hope the articles we publish are the ones that coders—hobbyists, beginners, or professionals—want to read.  …

3:17 PM
for file in directory:
        with open(file, 'r') as input_file:
    except UnicodeDecodeError as e:
        # Can't read, probably not an error message or HTML then
        # Assume PDF
Perhaps not such a good idea.
Q: Generate random ids from specific numbers of auto generated unique ids

Eslam AliI have this class to generate unique ids and random ids from those unique ids. For the unique ids, it's a sequence of numbers between (start number = given number [start_seed]/or random number (0:1000000), and end number = start number + number of desired unique id -1) converted to string and h...

Why is it so much harder to write good code than crap.
possible answer invalidation by Ignacio Vergara Kausel on question by Marieke Pasker: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236198/revisions
@Mast Is there really any good code?
@Duga Not a great edit, but no invalidation either.
@pacmaninbw Every code you don't have to write.
That's good code.
4:27 PM
@Feeds this might actually be interesting
possible answer invalidation by Eslam Ali on question by Eslam Ali: codereview.stackexchange.com/posts/236238/revisions
5:10 PM
5:20 PM
@Duga looks like response to comments requesting code that benchmarks the performance
5:41 PM
Q: How could this Java CLABE control digit calculation be enhanced

Tom CumminsI recently wrote the following Java 1.8 snippet to generate a CLABE control digit based on the following subheading on the CLABE page on Wikipedia and I was curious on how it could be improved. private void generateCLABEControlDigit() { final int[] expectedResults = {0,1,2,3,6,0,0,0,0,3,7,8,...

5:52 PM
Maybe it's also a good idea to take the Algorithm and Code and post on CodeReview SE for a makeover. — Fildor 13 secs ago
Q: ASP.NET Core 3.1 Web API + Pure DI

PiotrI was playing around with ASP.NET Core 3.1 and tried to implement Dependency Injection flavor called Pure DI, i.e. without dependency container (even the built in one) to instantiate Controllers. You can see entire code here, but here's the rundown: I know I have to replace the default IControlle...

1 hour later…
7:23 PM
Q: Method to hide/show table columns with React/JSX

killer_manateeI am writing a function inside of a React component to hide/show columns in a table. The table is generated from an imported config object containing objects which model the column data. We render by simply mapping over the table content and rendering cells based on the columns. The method I'm wr...

Can you point to your specific problem? If you want a code review, you're on the wrong Stack Exchange site. — Martin Véronneau 18 secs ago
StackOverflow is not a free coding service. If you want help reviewing your existing, working code, then please head to Code Review instead. — B. Fleming 23 secs ago
7:44 PM
Q: Feedback on java code

MaxI have been programming for a while, but I've only made games and less serious stuff. I want to get more serious. I would like some feedback on this class that defines a person. Structure, readability, use of static variables, etc. Please point out everything that can be improved. public class P...

8:12 PM
@GhostCatsalutesMonicaC. What did you mean I fear they will just throw everything IT related together, are they want to combine for example SE with Security, code review ... together? — YCF_L 11 secs ago
@RMunroe hehe nice
8:45 PM
Q: Monitored parallel mapping across a Pandas dataframe?

user5601This code maps a function over a dataset in parallel in a monitored fashion, and returns the result in the variable out: import pandas as pd import numpy as np from tqdm import tqdm, trange from joblib import Parallel, delayed import multiprocessing import math n_jobs = multiprocessing.cpu_coun...

9:26 PM
Q: Python Kivy code working Poorly

Naman JainI've written a MP3 tag editor, using Kivy and Python but since last virtual environment build my code ui is working very poorly. The UI responds very slowly (almost 10 seconds to reflect any action) which makes the app unusable. I've tried previous build of the app but it is also not working prop...

Q: Generic CQRS Query handler with custom return type

mirind4I am trying to build a generic query handler using the MediatR (v8) library. Let's jump to the code: First of all I have an abstract query class like this: public abstract class Query<TQueryResult> : IRequest<TQueryResult> { public Guid Id { get; } = Guid.NewGuid(); public DateTime Time...

9:46 PM
Q: Converting numbers to words - JavaScript

Raman AujlaI recently worked on this problem that converts numbers to words. I was wondering if there is a better way to do it than mine, And I will really appreciate any reviews to my version of the solution and on how to make it better /** * Converts a given number into words * @param {integer} , num, ...

1 hour later…
10:48 PM
Q: Smart Mirror Code improvements

Megastrik3So as you could probably tell from the title of this post, I have designed a basic interface for a smart mirror I made. I coded it to include the time, date, and several phrases that refresh every 24 hours. I was wondering if there were anyways I could streamline this code or even improve the lay...

11:08 PM
Q: .NET Core Service/Console App Architecture

MoonKnightI have the following setup code for my .NET Core 3.1 console application/microservice app and I want to learn and improve what I have - I have a feeling I could be utilizing the core Microsoft .NET APIs better (including the way I have implemented my logging with Serilog) public class Program { ...


« first day (2459 days earlier)      last day (66 days later) »