Dont really wish to make a deal out of it, so not posting on Meta. But I just saw that post even if provocatively posed, it did express itself as a valid physics question. In reference to the question, there were strong opinions on either side, but all it amounted to was to educate further by knowing more of the criticisms and its defense. It is my opinion that there are lots of issues that remain unresolved, but it doesn't help to close them off just because they are.
Yes, it is a valid physics question, but it is not a valid SE question -- it is just not suitable to get a defined, useful answers and only produces discursive clutter instead.
Again, chat is a place where such discussions are perfectly valid and readable for further visitors.
I can help organizing some kind of event if you think current chat traffic is not enough -- but this should start as a meta thread.
