« first day (1822 days earlier)      last day (577 days later) » 

Random Person
Random Person
9:41 AM
@andrew.46 Can you at least confirm or deny if you edited the comment?
 
andrew.46
andrew.46
10:17 AM
@RandomPerson You know a 'confirm or deny' question sounds like something from a TV courtroom drama? Rest assured if I had edited your comment, and you questioned me about it I would be completely up front about it. And I would explain my reasons.
That is not the case here...
And for me that is the end of the issue, I don't mean that in an unfriendly way, and I apologise if this offends you.
 
Random Person
Random Person
@andrew.46 I didn't intend to make it sound like TV courtroom drama. Sorry if I offended you.
@andrew.46 ok. Thank you for the confirmation.
@andrew.46 No, you didn't offend me :)
 
Error404
Error404
10:51 AM
Hi!
 
Random Person
Random Person
11:18 AM
hello!
 
Alain Reve
Alain Reve
12:01 PM
Hello
I hope I'm not interrupting
I was wondering about question closure in the puzzle section. My question got this message :
Closed. This question is off-topic. It is not currently accepting answers.

This question may invite speculative answers, as the question is not fully defined. The validity of some answers may be based upon opinion. Good questions for this site have a limited number of objectively correct answers. See also: Why are questions off-topic if they invite answers which are not demonstrably correct, or are otherwise speculative?
But it does have one and only one demonstrably correct answer. I can easily prove it. I can give the answer to someone (and prove it by first-order-logic equations if someone wants me to).
Could someone please accept to hear the answer and then to help me qet my question reopened? (But without posting the answer, it would be a pity to spoil everybody's fun)
0
Q: Reasoning game : The little piglet

Alain ReveThe game of the little piglet is a typical French game for 3 players. The first player takes the ball and throws it. The second player takes the throw and balls it. What does the third player do? There's nothing wrong with my translation, even if the phrasing seems weird. It is a reasoning game, ...

logical-deduction
Ah, OK. Sorry I intruded. Have a nice day. Bye
 
Random Person
Random Person
1:00 PM
@AlainReve The right place to ask about this is puzzling.meta.stackexchange.com
or perhaps ask in
 
AncientSwordRage
AncientSwordRage
@AlainReve Happy to keep discussing in TSL (linked above), but the issue is not that there are multiple valid answers, but that the answerers have no way of knowing with confidence that their answer is correct or not before posting
If I have one item in my pocket and ask "What's in my pocket?" There's definitely only "one and only one demonstrably correct answer" but there are potentially infinite answers that might be correct!
compare to "I put my hand in my pocket, feel around for a while and confirm there's only one thing in my pocket; what is in my pocket?" <-- enough detail there that the answerer can figure out that the answer is hover for spoiler!
 

« first day (1822 days earlier)      last day (577 days later) »