15:51
And I thought 1.18 was a bad update
1.19.1 is going to be the death of multiplayer if they don't get rid of it and they fix the exploits
Even if they fix things like "night" and "assistant" being censored, and even if false bans are sorted out and only occur in 1% of situations, there's a million problems with implementing a global profanity filter and a centrally moderated chat reporting system on Java
1. Profanity filters are, at best, basically useless, and at worst, extremely harmful
E.g., if my name is Richard and I go by Dick, which is yeah a bit less common nowadays, it'd still be pretty awful to have my own name censored by default, and if a friend were to refer to me with that name they could likely get banned since there wouldn't be context. And filtering profanity gives a false sense of security, since you can still say really harmful and offensive stuff without any profanity at all.
2. Microsoft can't keep moderating chat for the rest of time
Java is pretty decentralized. Other than Mojang's central servers for authentication purposes, you can set up your own server and play with your friends, and this could continue for decades with little maintenance. But once Microsoft no longer has the profit or incentive to continue moderation, but there's an expectation in place that they do, the easiest option for them is to just get rid of multiplayer.
3. Custom servers are custom servers, and Minecraft is not necessarily a game for kids
I get censoring chat on Mojang-owned servers. I even somewhat get it on Realms, which Mojang sort of own. But on people's private servers? Hugely overstepping their bounds.
4. This removes authority from individual servers to moderate themselves, and choose their own policies
Servers could save a lot of time and money and just rely on Microsoft's moderation, which will likely be pretty ineffective. If they continue to use their own moderation, there will be conflict between the two which would lead to inconsistent moderation policies and twice the opportunities for false bans