@CarLaTeX I know. However, I think a very big part of it is the translation program he uses. What I want to say he sometimes makes statements that are very reasonable but after translation they do not sound appropriate. So I would not read too much into it. ;-)
@CarLaTeX Yes, but he is also very good at cherry picking. (What I mean is that you write an answer, explain why the OP's attempt fails, and solve the issue. So far so good. But after a while another cherry-picking user comes, takes your code, draws one line in a bit different color, and gets the check mark for it....)
@CarLaTeX I guess the main problem are those who accept the cherry picker's posts and those who upvote them. This encourages cherry picking. But I also think that in the internet actions often seem more offending than they are meant to be. Typically it is better to talk to someone in person than writing an email, say. So I guess to some extent we have to live with it.
@marmot Such cases are very difficult to fight, you can't leave a message to explain a downvote because there is the risk of a revenge by him. Maybe the only way is to gather a list of such answers and inform the moderators.
@CarLaTeX I guess after the recent suspension of a user here I am not really in the mood to interact with the moderators. (I am not talking about our local moderators.) There is zero transparency in these actions. (But I also refrain from downvoting.)
I took a look at this nice answer longtable package: Stretch height of last row on page and I need to apply this answer in my arabic document (right to left document).
The problem that I can not get the same output in RTL context (the table is not stretched)
\documentclass[12pt]{article}
\use...
@marmot True, but material can be in camera. Here, the thing to bear in mind is there are several people who can see any evidence of issues, and that sometimes it can be pretty awkward stuff.
@marmot Also, some sites have a lot of suspensions, and real issues between people. Those would basically bog-down meta if each case was discussed before any action. So as a network-wide policy, have local mods who are able to review stuff without a public 'trial' is a way of finding some workable balance
@marmot I think you also have to bear in mind that the 'victim' (where there is one) might not be too keen on a completely-public discussion
@JosephWright This is all true and I have no reason not to believe that all your actions are fully justified and reasonable and so on. It is, nevertheless, not the way justice in the real world works, and this a reason for it. Do I know how to handle this? No. But do I trust some institution behind the scenes of I cannot look? No. (That's one of the main reason for preferring LaTeX over Word, after all.)
@marmot One additional thing to bear in mind is that IP addresses/emails are one aspect that is important in some mod decisions. Those are personal data, which can't be disclosed in general, but which can support conclusions about issues.
@marmot The staff only do very limited stuff: mainly handling sock puppet accounts, spam, etc., where it is cross-network, and usually when altered by local mods on one or more sites
@JosephWright This is certainly true, but does not prevent you from saying things like "there were 10 users linked to one email or IP address who mutually upvoted each other like crazy". Everyone would get the message, and there is no need to know which precise email address is behind that. (No, I am not that paranoid. ;-)
@DavidCarlisle I am actually not convinced that TikZ really uses \pdfsavepos. Indirect evidence: you can compile to dvi and TikZ will still work. (But yes, there has been an issue that in some recent years some things did no longer work perfectly for dvi.)
@marmot Short-term suspensions are meant to get a message across to individuals not to do the problematic stuff again. Making the discussion public doesn't help with that aspect (the aim is reform not punishment). For permanent bans, I can see things are slightly different (though they are likely to be either due to being sock puppets or out-and-out hate speech)
@marmot Unfortunately, pdfTeX called most of the new primitives \pdf..., which is a pain. For expl3, I've tried to tidy that up in the \tex_...:D names
@JosephWright Again, I fully trust you. But you may agree that in the end our real world governments work slightly different in that there is some sort of checks and balance in place.
@marmot Of course. All suspension messages to go all site mods plus to the Powers, so there is oversight. We could have a bigger mod team if the community feels that is useful.
@JosephWright Thanks. I really have no idea about all that. However, I try to find the post which reported the issues of tikz vs. dvi. (BTW, I have a side question: How do you, @DavidCarlisle, @egreg, @UlrikeFischer, @MarcelKrüger and those who I forget if discussions mention that "do that for me questions" get answers "for free". Don't you do a lot of work "for free"?)
@DavidCarlisle Well, I just want to say I appreciate all the work you are doing to keep LaTeX working and to improve it. Therefore, I am sometimes wondering what you feel when you read that "do-that-for-me" askers get answers for free. After all, most users here get a real lot for absolutely free.
@TorbjørnT. Thanks. I believe the basic things are already explained in section "1.1 The Layers Below TikZ". (Not that I understand them.)
@marmot I actually don't worry too much about that. I only ask for MWE to be supplied if it would help me write an answer not to "train" or "punish" the person asking the question.
@marmot of course that means for any tikz related question i pretty much always need a MWe as I struggle to draw a line without a helping example to get started:-)
@FaheemMitha The new years resolution is to get a tikz gold badge by answering tikz question with tex primitives, picture mode, or if really pushed pstricks, doing quite well so far this year.
There have been a few questions here on MSE along with some on various child metas about how fixed/permanent the new site redesigns are. I'm posting a new question rather than answering so that we can have more real estate for dialogue (in answers) and because I was missing all of your pings from...
@marmot yes. All questions here get answers for free. I don't answer "draw it for me" because I normally find the question boring (I prefer other problems) and having to build a minimal document to start makes them even boring, but I don't downvote them and I don't care if something else do (and I sometimes have used answers to such questions, so had actually a gain from them).
@UlrikeFischer Yes, I fully agree with that. (I was just curious why "do-that-for-me" has the nimbus of being very awkward. Nobody is forced to do things, and for me it is sometimes like solving a cross word puzzle. There is no deeper sense but it helps one to relax. I do not see why one should have to defend this behavior.)