@Xander Will you take a look at my comment below
this question, which came up in reopen queue, due to an overambitious suggesting editor? I see this every single day, many times; other users step in to beautify a question, after it's closure, thereby robbing the OP the chance to improve the question, and having the improvement sent to the reopen review queue. Can we consider a meta post, or comment template, to address this sort of situation?