@Bebs I'll keep posting updates and questions here as I edit the tag wikis, then. Thanks for approving the edit :) I think at least two reviewers need to approve it before it gets accepted?

Ah yes, of course

Not a problem, there's no urgency :)

@Bebs I've answered one of your Meta questions on the tags instrument-identification and identify-this-instrument.

@Bebs I'm guessing it's because there is very little discussion going on in Meta, so it's hard to judge what the community wants if very few speak up? My feeling is that mods generally prefer to be "implementers" rather than "enforcers", if that makes sense.

@Bebs Fair point.

@Bebs This answer seems to be removed now, since I see the 404 page not found message

@Bebs I flagged it as rude/abusive from my side, too.

Is it possible that we don't have enough regular users who handle the review queues?

On Mathematics SE I have enough reputation to go through the Low Quality Review queues, and I've often "Recommended Deletion" of many such spam or abusive posts there.

If very few users go through the review queues here (or very few have the reputation to see them), then we'll have to rely on the mods more than is usual on other SE sites.

@Bebs @Donald.McLean The wiki for identify-this-artist says the following: Please, consider asking identification for an artist you consider famous enough to be identified for people all over the world.

Hmm, I see how the tag could be misused, but don't you feel it is far too restrictive? There is a lot of popular music in the world that is not necessarily "global".

Yes, I completely agree that we want to avoid these situations you mentioned.

My feeling is that the usual voting and flagging mechanism should take care of these scenarios, though. I feel that there ought to be a way to reword the tag wiki to be less restrictive and yet in line with our goals.

Ah, the wiki for identify-this-band does specify what sort of restriction is meant: . . . (e.g. don't ask to identify a garage cover band you have seen on your local bar, street music bands...).

Perhaps a line like this could be added to the wiki for identify-this-artist too?

@Bebs On it! :) Also, I think it would be helpful to have a link to the Meta question "What should I do to improve my identification question?" on all the identify-this-xxx tag wikis. Some of them already do, but some of them don't. Shall I add the link to each of them?

But the tag is also used to ask generic questions about live performances. For instance, the top four upvoted questions with this tag are about general live performances, not about a specific performer.