« first day (1804 days earlier)      last day (2277 days later) » 

10:20
23
Q: Which way should you turn to avoid another aircraft?

ratchet freakDuring visual flight conditions, when you see another aircraft in your path, you should strive to avoid hitting it. In shipping there are standard international rules about which way boats should turn in order to avoid each other. Are there similar rules in aviation?

 
4 hours later…
13:57
@ratchetfreak Hmmmm, thatʼs a pretty good explanation of the regulations.
But it doesnʼt answer the question of how you can tell, visually, which way to turn to avoid the conflict most effectively.
you can't really
when it matters most, the traffic is not moving across the sky anyway
Makes sense.
Maybe the important thing is: if itʼs moving to the right across the sky, donʼt turn right to avoid it.
And likewise with the left.
 
1 hour later…
15:22
you can tell which way an aircraft is going by the nav lights
well, you can tell which way it's pointing - even if you see a red light it could be moving left-to-right in your field of view (i.e. its bearing is increasing)
 
3 hours later…
17:59
Sailors have a saying: Constant Bearing, Closing Distance means Collision!
Meaning: If another vessel is at a certain bearing (say, your 3 o'clock), and a certain distance, then several minutes later, it is still at your same bearing (3 o'clock again), but the distance is closer, then you will collide.
Instead, if the bearing changes, the traffic will pass in front or behind you.
(if the bearing closes towards 12 o'clock, traffic will pass in front: If the bearing opens up towards 3 or 9 o'clock, traffic will pass behind)
It works great in relatively slow moving boats. it is a little harder to determine when planes are moving quickly, but the principle is the same: Is the bearing staying constant while the distance decreases? DANGER.
 
2 hours later…
19:37
it's also easier to find a "transit" to line up on in a boat's cockpit or wheelhouse than in an aircraft cockpit where everything is close to you.
20:19
It's probably easier to miss traffic vertically than horizontally. The only problem there is you both make the same maneuver. There maybe should be some kind of rule of thumb that directly oncoming traffic on eastbound headings should climb and westbound should descend. And comverging traffic to the right climb and left descend.
Yeah, there should.
Here's a good rule of thumb: if the traffic is a glider, climb. :D
@TomMcW nah, because the traffic might be climbing or descending into your path, and might not have seen you
you still have the same kind of conflict "the traffic is approaching me from below, but the rule says I should descend to avoid"
also, you are supposed to avoid passing above or below an aircraft you're supposed to give way to, unless passing well clear
@DanHulme I'm thinking about how TCAS does it. TCAS only gives vertical avoidance measures.
I think the rules depend on whether the traffic is also participating in TCAS
(it might not be if it only has ADS-B Out)

« first day (1804 days earlier)      last day (2277 days later) »