« first day (2281 days earlier)      last day (2667 days later) » 

02:49
1
Q: Why the rubbish in Samuel Beckett's play Breath?

Hello WorldSamuel Beckett's play Breath is thirty-five seconds long and consists of two cries. The script is online here: http://www.samuel-beckett.net/breath.htm Why does the script specify that: Faint light on stage littered with miscellaneous rubbish. Hold for about five seconds. and R...

 
3 hours later…
05:53
Wrote a teeny little article for @tordotcom about Watership Down, yo. Check it: https://www.tor.com/2017/11/06/the-book-that-first-spoke-my-feral-language-richard-adams-watership-down/
 
1 hour later…
07:23
Tonight I’m @Ri_Science for the launch of @ZachWeiner & @FuSchmu’s great new sci book, Soonish 😀
 
3 hours later…
10:01
Best typo 2017
@doppelspooker o_O
Professor Binns style? :P
 
1 hour later…
11:33
0
Q: Retelling of Odysseus story with humour and anachronisms (audiobook)

Rand al'ThorI heard this in audio form, probably on a cassette or maybe CD, in the early noughties (2001-2006); I don't know how old it was, or whether or not it was an audio adaptation of a published novel. Essentially it was a version of the Iliad (I don't think it also included the Odyssey, but I'm not ce...

@Mithrandir It's an attempt to answer, just a bad one. "Why did Shakespeare write in iambic pentameter?" "To emphasize or stress certain words [and to give] a rhythm and cadence to the sonnet making the words sound like they flow together."
11:59
@Randal'Thor uuuhhhh, yeah
I'm tempted to retroactively reject that now, but I don't know if that's worth it.
Oh, you can do that?
 
1 hour later…
13:03
hmmm. Maybe I'm missing something, but I'm not sure why these two questions are treated differently
0
Q: Why the breathing in Snowgoons Get Off the Ground

Hello WorldAt around 3:10 in Snowgoons Get Off the Ground (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yih_bMc5B7o), Ruste Juxx starts rapping. Why is his portion accompanied by heavy breathing? Here are the associated lyrics (taken from genius: https://genius.com/Snowgoons-get-off-the-ground-lyrics) Machine gun s...

that gets downvoted and closevotes because it...
I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it's about the performance of a piece of music, and not about literature (including song lyrics) as such. — Rand al'Thor Nov 1 at 12:06
meanwhile, this question
5
Q: Why the rubbish in Samuel Beckett's play Breath?

Hello WorldSamuel Beckett's play Breath is thirty-five seconds long and consists of two cries. The script is online here: http://www.samuel-beckett.net/breath.htm Why does the script specify that: Faint light on stage littered with miscellaneous rubbish. Hold for about five seconds. and R...

gets upvoted, despite also being about details about the performance of a work of literature
it's almost as if this whole this site is not a place for questions about performance doesn't make sense?
(FTR, I didn't downvote that first one)
Good question though. Perhaps it's because the (written) script of a play is generally recognised as being on-topic?
@Randal'Thor but both got decent answers
Answerability is orthogonal to on-topicness though.
A question can get a brilliant answer and still need to be closed.
i get the sense that this whole performance is off-topic thing isn't really based on any actual understanding of literature
@Randal'Thor Let's say it's 50-50 whether they should be closed. Why not use "can this community answer these questions" as a way to decide?
@Hamlet There's a "slippery slope" argument to be made here. Are we going to become a site about all arts subjects, because there's no clear place to draw a line between "literature" and "not literature"?
2
13:09
@Randal'Thor IDK.
But if the site ends up going that way, what is the problem with that? You make that sound like it's some sort of bad thing.
I think it was @Zyera who said that our scope doesn't necessarily have to be defined by "what is literature", so much as "what do we want this site to contain".
@Randal'Thor and I want it to contain questions about performance. And I think other people do to.
I.e. we could declare something off-topic even if there's an argument to be made that it should count as a kind of literature.
0
Q: Expand scope of tag 'the-art-of-war'

Christophe StrobbeWe currently have a tag the-art-of-war with the following tag wiki excerpt: For questions about The Art of War, the book by Sun Tzu. Use in conjunction with [sun-tzu]. While Sun Zi's The Art of War is certainly the most famous military treatise by this title, it is by no means the only one,...

@Randal'Thor yes you could.
But should you make questions about performance off-topic?
I have yet to hear any coherent, non-contradictory, persuasive argument for the should
I hear slippery slope (but no real explanation why the thing at the bottom of the slope is bad), I hear performance is only OK for certain types of literature (no explanation why), etc.
13:16
When you are a very tiny mouse living in an old used book store.
Children's fable about an indie bookstore mouse who has to battle gentrification when they threaten to replace her home with a chain
 
4 hours later…
17:35
2
Q: Why doesn't Hamlet like improvisation?

No Fear ShakespeareIn Shakespeare's play Hamlet, Hamlet has a famous monologue about how to properly perform a play. During one portion of the monologue, he has some harsh words for people who improvise: O, reform it altogether. And let those that play your clowns speak no more than is set down for them; ...

17:54
2
Q: What changes when you adapt Dickinson's "I'm Nobody" to an acoustic rock song?

HamletI've been listening to recordings of Emily Dickinson's poem "I'm Nobody! Who are you?" on Youtube. And most of the recordings that I've found seem to render the poem in a flat, dry voice. An extreme example of this is this reading by the website "Pearls of Wisdom", which was read in a way that on...

hmmm. According to meta consensus, questions about film adoptations are on-topic
8
Q: Are novelizations of films (or television) on topic?

SkoobaQuite simply asked, novelizations are literature, but they started as "screen" works. Should they be considered on-topic?

14
Q: Should we accept questions asking to compare a book and its adaptation?

Tim E. LordThere are a few question on Sci-Fi and Fantasy SE asking for a comparison of a book and its adaptation. Off hand, I could find a question about The Martian, and question about Harry Potter with an epic answer. The corresponding tag is adaptation-comparison. Given all that, what is our opinion o...

Don't really see why a film adoptation question would be on-topic, but a question about the adaptation of song lyrics into a recorded song wouldn't
0
Q: Why is Richard a hunchback in Kevin Spacey's portrayal of Richard III

HamletI'm trying to learn more about performance, and I stumbled across Kevin Spacey's production of Shakespeare's Richard III. Here's a link to a youtube video with some highlights. One of the production decisions that I don't really understand is the decision of make Kevin Spacey's character, Richar...

@Bookworm good question!
18:52
0
Q: Why would Image Comics publish "Sunstone", after it was released as a webcomic?

Tim E. LordStjepan Sejic's Sunstone was first published as a webcomic on his DeviantArt account (and is still available there), as was his Death Vigil. Linda Sejic's Blood Stain is published on her DeviantArt first, before being published by Image Comics. Question is - why? Why would Image Comics publish s...

@Bookworm this seems like a question that @Hamlet should be able to answer :P
 
1 hour later…
19:57
I have another question, but I'll wait until tomorrow
I hope DVK will see it
20:45
1
Q: 'worth so many beeves' proverb

Batuhan TasCan somebody please explain the proverb 'worth so many beeves' in Oscar Wilde's The Rise of Historical Criticism? Here is the context: The origin of the common proverb ‘worth so many beeves,’ in which we discern the unconscious survival of a purely pastoral state of society before the use of ...

20:58
1
Q: What evidence do scholars offer on both sides as to the authorship of The Dark Tower?

EJoshuaSThe Dark Tower is an incomplete manuscript posthumously attributed to C. S. Lewis. There has been widespread controversy about whether it was actually written by C. S. Lewis. What evidence do scholars offer for and against it being written by C. S. Lewis?

 
2 hours later…
22:50
0
Q: Why is Richard portrayed without a hunchback in

HamletIf we go by the text of Shakespeare's Richard III, Richard has a hunchback. In Act I, scene 3, line 246, Queen Margaret describes Richard as a "poisonous bunch-back'd toad." And in act IV, scene 4, line 81 Queen Elizabeth also describes Richard as "that foul bunch-back'd toad." However, in the 1...

23:03
Work related question, friends: I'm looking for examples of authors who "do social media well." Any recommendations?
@BESW John Scalzi.
I don't know of one who's better.
@Shokhet that is... not what I expected clicking a link from you.
@Mithrandir Yeeeah, that needs a NSFW note.
@BESW This is a super dumb question but how do you see that view where it shows you the replies?
@Catija Click the date in the chat one-box.
23:11
... apparently by clicking on the timestamp... is it stupid that I expect clicking on the "replies" on twitter would show you the replies?
@BESW I mean on Twitter itself.
Ah, yeah. Same answer, though: timestamp.
If I click on the number of replies, I want to see the replies not write one myself :/
Sorry... Twitter and I don't get along well.
No apologies necessary. It's not a super intuitive interface.
And apparently now we all get more characters.
[eyeroll]
23:15
Who is that lady?
Who?
The one in the tweet... why did you share it?
How did you even find it?
Ah. I found it because an author I follow re-tweeted it.
I shared it because I thought the replies might be fun/useful for people in this chat to connect with authors' social media presences that they'd find beneficial but might not have encountered otherwise.
BESW is actually secretly a Twitter feed who posts tweets that may be relevant to the room ;)
I follow a limited number of people on Twitter, but I choose them partly because they re-tweet a wide range of material I'm interested in.
23:17
@Mithrandir A very verbose and well-spoken feed, then.
2
That is one freaky image ._.
[grin] Manuscript illustrations are trippy.
Woah... what era is that from?
What document is it from?
23:19
Hmm. I'll have to track that down.
Psalter
yeah, the Luttrell Psalter‌​, 1276-1345.
It's no naked TARDIS party, though. (NSFW: naked TARDIS party)
@BESW Oh, wow, that's awesome!
Marginalia is fun!
Writing master John Smith didn’t hold anything back in this wonderfully saturated specimen sheet from 1684. [Wing oversize ZW 645 .S652]
23:37
0
Q: In "Fuck Blocher", why does Bligg say he speaks for the swiss youth and secondos?

HamletStress, Greis, and Bligg's "Fuck Blocher" is a rap that protests a right wing Swiss politician. The lyrics can be found online; the song can be listened to on youtube. There's a particular line I want to focus on in this question: Red d'Sprach vo de Schwizerjugend und Secondos. The line ro...


« first day (2281 days earlier)      last day (2667 days later) »