« first day (2658 days earlier)      last day (1255 days later) » 

5:31 PM
Hi I had a question closed in the math SE site that had been recieved well up till now, and it is about something I thought was of interest and on topic,will you be explicitly informed that the question is closed because it is more appropriate in another community? I feel arrogant thinking this sure because I'm not exactly a research level mathematician or anything for that matter but I also cannot understand why it needs to be closed all of a sudden
 
@AdamL To be honest, I am a bit unsure what you're actually trying to ask here. In any case, the main chatroom might be more suitable - as this room is specifically intended for issue related to editing, tags and related topics.
I should add a caveat that the MO chatroom is frequented only by very few people.
 
ok thanks well i suppose i can just copy paste there, but to clarify, a question i asked in the general math community was closed 12 days ago, if I was going to guess why, it's because it would be better suited here, but in having said that if just posted the question as it is, it's not as well asked as some of the things I've seen on MO, I guess I need guidance with going about bringing it tto he standard here
which may very well be the explicit notice that Adam we think it's rubbish and it belongs nowhere, I don't know I have no way of knowing for sure as to why it was closed nor whom
 
6:02 PM
@AdamL I'd guess that you might be speaking about this question: Factorization inequality proof
If you look at the related chat messages, they might give some indication why the close voters decided to vote to close that particular question.
in CURED, Nov 15 at 22:51, by amWhy
@XanderHenderson No actual question. You are not missing anything. I used my last close vote for the day on that post.
 
6:15 PM
ok thanks anyway well I have edited it to clarify there is a question being asked I mean I understand where he is coming from and he is not out of place making mention of the ambiguity that was there, improving myself in that regard is still a working progress which can lose momentum as why even bother pretty quickly for someone in my situation
 
in CURED, 1 min ago, by Martin Sleziak
@XanderHenderson The OP has edited that question a bit. He says: "I have edited it to clarify there is a question being asked".
in CURED, 1 min ago, by Martin Sleziak
This was mentioned in another chatroom. Since the question was pointed out by you, I thought it might be reasonable to let you know - in case you have something to add to that.
Since Xander Henderson was the first user to mention that question in the CURED chatroom, I though it might be reasonable to point out your edit. (I hope it is ok.)
 

« first day (2658 days earlier)      last day (1255 days later) »