As you may have seen, @Undo has implemented a feed to post suspected spam or other undesirable posts to chat. It was my suggestion, so please don't shoot him. Hopefully the posts will get dealt with even more quickly and spammers can be deterred even more.
I usually commute earlier, but they are fixing some street somewhere, so the buses are somehow chock-full of students for some reason.
So the last three times or so I spent like 40 to 60 minutes outside in the rain waiting for a bus that would (a) actually stop and (b) have any room left.
Today I'm trying to sit it out instead. Let's see how it works out.
No, what does vegetable mean? Suppose a carrot is a vegetable. It is a plant which is not a fruit. A tomato is a plant but it is a fruit; it is a vegetable? A mushroom is neither plant nor animal. Honey is not a plant, not an animal, and not a fungus. What does vegetable mean??? — tchrist27 secs ago
“Animal, vegetable, or mineral” leaves a lot of shit out, and is confusing besides. “Vegetable” has no useful definition.
Sorry, but I have to chime in after all this time. The answers given here, while accurate, convey none of the most critical distinctions, nor of how modes sound to the ear in a way different from scales. And how things sound is what music is all about. Otherwise you may as well describe the diffe...
Hmm, this just got a down vote. I wonder what their problem with the answer is.
@JasperLoy Yeah, it's been a while. I only came in to see if I could drum up support for getting this meta question closed, but it doesn't seem to have worked. I do feel for poor Yoichi though.
@JasperLoy Flavour of the month for me is Joseph M Williams Style: Towards Clarity and Grace, but that's a more general approach more concerned with vocabulary and word order than punctuation. Comma use is somewhat declining overall, so a more recent guide might be better than an older one.
@JasperLoy Long before I came to ELU I'd convinced myself that relatively speaking, written English (and the attendant punctuation) is an almost irrelevant poor relation of real (spoken) English. My interactions with John Lawler here have simply confirmed me in that position.
@Mr.ShinyandNew安宇 I suppose if I called you out on that, you'd be able to produce an example where the spoken form is less "accurate" than the written form, but to a first approximation it's always the other way around.
Just consider the growing use of "air quotes", when people are speaking.
@FumbleFingers Yes, I believe there would be, unless they were very careful.
I'll agree with you that language originates in speaking. The evidence is clear, when people can't remember if they should write their or there or they're, yet they're otherwise 100% correct and fluent.
They are writing the sound, in that case.
But writing provides other tools that speaking does not have.
@FumbleFingers There is a difference between saying 'I went to the store' and 'I went to the "store"'.
(that is, if you air-quote it)
Otherwise, you have to... what? 'I went to the quote-unquote store', 'I went to the so-called store', etc.
Punctuation and text style are tools that can convey information. Just like speaking has intonation which cannot be conveyed in writing, so too writing has punctuation which cannot be conveyed in speaking.
@Mr.ShinyandNew安宇 Absent context, I've absolutely no idea what "non-standard" sense of store you might have in mind. But in speech I could still either simply place more stress on the word, or dra....www it out to an obviously unnatural length.
@FumbleFingers Maybe it's not a shop that sells goods, but rather a church positioned to try to recruit people, with a veneer of products for sale.
The point is that quoting something has meaning: it distances the writer/speaker from the word. It's not my word for that thing, they call themselves a store, I call them a cult.
You can easily punctuate it and then that distancing is clear.
Drawing it out doesn't do the same. It just shows that you have some emphasis, but what? Why are you saying it like that?
My parents have an "outhouse" they use as an "overspill larder". They and all close family call it "the shop" with no particular emphasis (because we all know what we mean anyway). If there's someone else around, we mostly emphasise the word to alert non-cognoscenti to an unusual usage.
@FumbleFingers yes. You are alerting them to something. But that's not the same as putting quotes on it. Air quotes serve a purpose, and they are an example of punctuation going from print to speech.
Also, aside from punctuation, I'm sure there are lots of other examples of linguistic innovation that occurs in writing. words like pwned, for example.
Here it is "The Google Talent Development team announces The Language Tip Of The Week. The tip will help us better communicate with our client and making the environment error free"...
@MattЭллен, @KitFox, @AndrewLeach, @RegDwigнt, @every mod - would one of you just post an answer that this behavior is fine, ok, not optimal but not abusive, something you're mulling over and haven't decided, something that probably should be frowned upon, or whatever so I can accept the answer and we can all move on? Jeeze.
The only reason there's so much drama about it is that it involves an 81 yr. old venerated user who doesn't like it when his questions are closed. OK. Tell me no biggie, we can accept this, can't we, he's a great user*, or whatever excuse or belief you have.
That seems a relatively innocuous request; I'm not sure I understand your not taking a stand on this one way or another, anything coming from our mod(s) would be accepted.
Ah, @JasperLoy - I shall continue to get younger before your very eyes. For $5 I will sell you my secret!
@MattЭллен, @KitFox, @AndrewLeach, @RegDwigнt, etc. The mods here know the hub-bub that occurred last time. I have **no desire** to bring it up. It was apologized for and I feel it's resolved. The issue, though, is pending. I might have anticipated that it might come to that, but I never thought it would. Your silence is puzzling. Maybe you want the community to decide?
Well... that's fine, too, I guess, but things are beginning to get messy, no small thanks to you, @FumbleFingers, with all your rhetoric about public disembowelment, which you then disingenously call "joking".
@IceBoy Yes, but will this not remain as a ping for one of them?
@IceBoy - am I misunderstanding, that if I @them, they will be notified eventually and will see the request?
@JasperLoy Hmm, do you think that's all there is to it? I would love it if it were that simple, or if they left a comment to that effect, or something.
@medica I have a question to ask you. If one day you had to do something you feel is morally right but is also legally wrong, how would you decide whether to do it or not?
@medica Hmm, but would you say that it matters what the consequences are? If you go to jail for a long time or have to pay a heavy fine for doing something that helps others only minimally, it may not be worth it?
@medica Suppose you want to tell people in a certain country about Jesus Christ, but for doing so, you will be arrested and executed. What will you do?
No, Jasper, I'm not very courageous. Bit I would want to be. Maybe I would be given the courage to share the Gospel. On the other hand, I don't believe in forcing it down anybody's throat.
I went to Africa decades ago (I owe you a coke!) with World Medical Missions (now Samaritan's Purse) which is also doing Ebola work there. Maybe I should apply there.
If it torments you, really, then bite the bullet and make a decision. If it's not the one you wish you were brave enough to make, just accept it and forgive yourself.
Obama and others have made a big deal of quarantines on the basis that it might decrease the US' responders. I responded not two weeks ago, and I was told they were not accepting doctors to go to Ebola-striken areas anymore, that they had enough docs n the ground (this was MSF/DWB). So I'm a bit puzzled.
@medica hard to judge. different group, non-governmental, one of many. Individual hospitals are probably gearing up to send people, etc, etc. But yes, that sounds weird.
Anyone here knows the IB and A level exams well enough? I am trying to compare which is harder in whatever sense, not that I need to take either of them.
@medica Among all the disciplines excluding ID, I would think that would be the next most qualified. Especially since I bet half of everybody coming to the hospital there now has something flu-like but not the E thing.
@JasperLoy SAT or ACT is what everyone takes. But those interested in placing out of 1st year calculus take the Calculus AP exam.
@JasperLoy good question, because the answer is no. There's only one Math AP (Advanced Placement) and that's Calculus, because if you can do that then and only then is interesting math opened up to you. (where 'interesting' means having little to nothing to do with Calculus)
@Mitch - what do you think I should do about my question in meta? Should I wait and hope for a mod to chime in, close it, or accept JR's answer or @Mr.ShinyandNew安宇 or something?
well, delete it
@Mitch - I'm asking you because you're a pretty level headed guy, and you understand the issue. You also know the background, and that the apology has been accepted.
I'd love for a mod to say, naw, we shouldn't do this, but it's not a crime, but that doesn't seem to be forthcoming.
@IceBoy not ironic. I don't think it is terrible, the high school math curriculum has to serve engineers (the whole range), the sciences, (future doctors), not just academic math.
@medica the qn about a mod reopening their own qn? It should go to meta.SE and not mention names. But separately a mod here should slap the person who did it.
@JasperLoy If they care, they should come to a conclusion. If they don't care, then the meta post stands as evidence that they didn't think it was important. Later on, either this will get worse, and they can't say they weren't warned, or it will stay the same (arguably not a problem ATM), or it will get better.
@Mr.ShinyandNew安宇 If they care, they should come to a conclusion. Because maybe they care about the matter but it is a grey area and hard to come to a definitive answer.
@JasperLoy I don't care if it's hard. IF they care, THEN they SHOULD come to a conclusion. Maybe they CAN'T, that doesn't mean that they are absolved from the responsibility of trying.
Thanks again, all. If anyone comes up with further nuggets of wisdom, please do feel free to share. I think I'll clean up my edit and be silent from now on. Whatever happens, happens, and as you said (thank you) the issue was raised. It's done.
@JasperLoy Anyway it's the mods' jobs to deal with problem behaviour. If someone raises a question about problem behaviour they should at least address it. They either have to act, or not act, but not acting is a kind of action, in that it allows the behaviour to continue. Maybe the mods can't come up with a hard-and-fast rule, but they should be able to address specific instances of behaviour.
@medica I have a feeling the moderators don't want to pass judgement on one of their number. A moderator acts with the authority he [she!] was elected to hold. The comment that a moderator acts rather than votes is telling.
Occasionally a mod may make an error of judgement; occasionally he may simply make a mistake and not realise a "vote" is actually an act.
Occasionally what might appear to be an error of judgement or a mistake is in fact neither and is perfectly justified and correct.
No, God doesn't make mistakes. Please don't interrupt when I'm thinking. Now, where was I...?
Oh yes.
I know I've been extremely busy over the last couple of weeks and haven't really been involved here much at all. So I haven't seen the question in question.
I'd be inclined to wait for a Community Manager to chime in, since it's actually quite awkward for moderators. Or, you could raise a general question on Meta.SE as has been suggested.