Jaami'at StackExchange al-Islamyya

Ansari

12:00 AM

and i believe there is one more

will take a look later tonight inshaAllah

yasar11732

Ok, I am awaiting answers :)

Al Ummat

I suggest that you add opinion to your questions

so it would be what other opinions are there?

yasar11732

I don't have my own opinion on this subject, I am completely clueless :)

and I already quoted what ashes's opinion was.

Al Ummat

no that is not what I meant

let me ask you,

@yasar11732 are you asking for the opinions, or the possible root words, or are you asking for both?

yasar11732

I think other possible root words are the opinions of people. So I guess both.

goldPseudo

12:07 AM

i would reword it a bit to make clear that you're looking for scholarly opinions. i'm suggesting an edit right now.

please review (and accept if it suits you)

yasar11732

Thanks for edit, accepted.

goldPseudo

i don't think there would be much confusion with the question as originally phrased, but it was a bit close to "Hey, everybody, what's your opinion on the root word of Allah?"

this way, it's more clear that you're looking for specific opinions, rather than just any old.

yasar11732

@goldPseudo Yes, we should avoid that :)

@goldPseudo I agree.

goldPseudo

13 questions over 24 hours.

yasar11732

I think it is good?

goldPseudo

12:22 AM

still a pretty good number, considering how early we are in building up a community.

yasar11732

I am about to ask a new one :)

goldPseudo

haven't quite broke 300 visitors per day yet.

God willing, by the time we're up to 1500 visitors per day, we'll have more than enough questions asked.

yasar11732

How long that usually takes?

I mean getting 1500 visit per day.

goldPseudo

no clue. it's very site-dependent.

yasar11732

What do I tag a "is this helal or haram" question with?

fiqh?

goldPseudo

12:27 AM

i'm honestly not sure what we're using for that.

we should really do a meta post on that.

islamic-rules seems to be popular.

yasar11732

Ok, after I ask my question, you can link to that :)

Here is my question (all edits are welcome)

0

Q: Is sport challanges for a reward Halal?

Consider couple of friends gathered and organized a football match where losers would buy drinks for winners. Is this kinds of challanges considered halal? I am confused because it might be like gambling, on the other hand, there is a challange and effort.

halal-haram

goldPseudo

hrm...that needs rewording, but at work, so I can't really fix it right now.

"reward" is the wrong term for the situation described.

Al Ummat

I fixed a couple of typis

yasar11732

@goldPseudo My English is far away from being perfect.

Al Ummat

@yasar11732 oh it is ok, the typis where simple

I make the same mistakes some times :)

yasar11732

12:35 AM

Sure, I edited the title too.

Al Ummat

wow :P I did not notice that one :)

yasar11732

What is correct word for reward?

goldPseudo

it's more of a stake than a reward.

Stake (verb): Gamble (money or something else of value) on the outcome of a game or race.

reward would be more like if you join a tournament, and they give something to the winner.

yasar11732

0

Q: Are sport challanges for a stake considered Halal?

Consider couple of friends gathered and organized a football match where losers would buy drinks for winners. Is this kinds of challenges considered halal? I am confused because it might be like gambling, on the other hand, there is a challenge and effort.

halal-haram

How is it now?

goldPseudo

better.

HaLaBi

12:51 AM

if the games for horses or eagles it is allowed

birds with claws or animals with hoofs

like horse races.. or falcon hunting sports.. they are allowed..

yasar11732

So, no eating and drinking material allowed as stake?

HaLaBi

ok

here is the thing..

goldPseudo

@yasar11732 I reworked the grammar a bit.

yasar11732

@goldPseudo Thanks, accepted.

HaLaBi

the sport has to be one of three types..

animal racing, animals with hoofs.. like horses..

or birds with claws.. like eagles or falcons.. such as sports where people hunt with falcons or eagles..

third type is shooting.. like spears or guns i assume..

sunnah.com/tirmidhi/19#31

"No stake is acceptable except in archery, racing a camel, and racing a horse."

yasar11732

12:59 AM

What if questions wasn't spesific on sports. For example, if I challange my friend to video game contest or who reads faster constest?

is it still apply?

HaLaBi

sorry.. no claws... not the eagle or falcons.. i said it by mistake.

it is not allowed.. haram

lately, they allowed Quran contests

yasar11732

who are "they"?

goldPseudo

one major interpretation i'm aware of is that, as the three exceptions mentioned in the above hadith all have advantages in jihad, then by analogy any event which can have advantages in jihad can be staked.

HaLaBi

if the reward is from a sponsor.. some one else other than the racers.. then it is halal

goldPseudo

yeah, that's why i insisted the question explicitly mention stakes, rather than reward. very different rulings.

HaLaBi

1:04 AM

to make it short.. if the money if from you or your friend.. it is Maysar.. which is Haram..

if you and your friend will race and the winner will be rewarded by me for example.. it is not maysar and it is halal..

yasar11732

@goldPseudo If so, can we say car racing for stake is halal by analogy?

HaLaBi

@goldPseudo Exactly.. but people mix up easily in this..

yasar11732

To sum up, stakes generally haram, reward generally ok_

goldPseudo

depends on the type of race, i would think (personal opinion). there's a lot more practical skill involved with a cross-country race than there would be in a circuit race, for example.

yasar11732

?

HaLaBi

1:05 AM

yup.. there are exceptions of course..

goldPseudo

something like a martial arts competition, i would say applies.

one could argue for football, since it builds physical strength, endurance, and reflexes.

HaLaBi

well, if the reward is from a sponsor.. it is halal...

either it is football or whatever sport..

we used to do something haram when i was a kid.. but didn't know..

we used to collect money from all kids.. and we make football game.. the winner takes the money..

Harammmmmmm

but we didn't know.. god will forgive us inshallah

goldPseudo

there's a bit of a gray area for paying to enter a tournament, where the prize is awarded by sponsor.

yasar11732

Technically, it is same as stake I think.

HaLaBi

don't know

man, mashallah you are a scholar.. how come?

goldPseudo

1:09 AM

i'm hardly a scholar. i just read a lot and actually remember a good chunk of it later.

HaLaBi

well, what if the money to enter is used to arrange the tournament??? like fixing a place for the race ...etc

Mashallah

@goldPseudo r u muslim by birth??? or a convert?

goldPseudo

i accepted Islam when i was in my teens.

HaLaBi

Mashallah

yasar11732

@HaLaBi I guess people call it revert.

7

Q: Why are converts to Islam called reverts?

I have noticed that when a person converts from one religion to Islam it is said that he or she reverted. This is said even when it is the first time he or she embraces Islam as a religion. Why is this?

terminology

HaLaBi

ok, didn't know that..

yasar11732

1:11 AM

Me neither :)

goldPseudo

i don't like that term, personally.

HaLaBi

revert or convert?

goldPseudo

revert.

or convert, really. i didn't "convert" to anything. i learned about Islam, and accepted it.

HaLaBi

mashallah

Al Ummat

sorry to interrupt but can you look at this @goldPseudo forum.islam.com/questions/6037/…

goldPseudo

1:12 AM

nngh. too long. bad formatting.

someone needs to learn how to write legibly.

Al Ummat

Well I am asking for a summery :)

HaLaBi

ok,, i have a new name instead of revert or convert... acceptor

yasar11732

How about Mumin? :)

Al Ummat

@goldPseudo but I was trying to show you the question itself, sorry I should have clarified, but my question is, what should be done if a question like this appears on this site?

I would think it would be flagged as offensive or something

a troll?

goldPseudo

it is not a question. close it.

2

it is proselytizing, pure and simple. not a very good job of it either.

Al Ummat

1:16 AM

ok

goldPseudo

i would delete it myself.

Al Ummat

don't worry your self

ok sorry guys if I interrupted the conversation

goldPseudo

if we got that question here, i would give it the whole trifecta of downvote (for bad writing), close (not-a-real-question), and flag (it-is-spam).

Al Ummat

:)

Stack Exchange

1

Q: Should we close boring/trivial questions?

Quoting from here Close boring, trivial, mindless, uninteresting, etc. questions. It's taken me a long time to get here, but your really need to shut down any question that wastes your top-users time and energy. Flag these questions. Vote to close when you get the privilege. Comment....

discussion

goldPseudo

1:27 AM

Blog - Stack Exchange: Are Some Questions Too Simple?

Jeff Atwood on February 22, 2011

On Podcast #58, Joel and I had a disagreement. Not the first, and certainly won’t be the last:

Joel says that the only bad simple question is a duplicate simple question. I say simple questions are OK as long as they’re actually interesting (in some way) for other users to consider and answer. To prove his point, Joel actually asks the question on Stack Overflow: How do I move the turtle in LOGO? Do you think this question adds value?

We still have this disagreement. Our community is now struggling with the very same issue across multiple network sites: …

Stack Exchange

1:59 AM

Islamic history, on topic? http://meta.islam.stackexchange.com/questions/274/islamic-history-on-topic?atw=1

Tweeted by StackIslam on July 4, 2012 at 1:42 AM

Stack Exchange

8:02 AM

Great answer: What is the purpose of having the concept of fasting in Islam? http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/4/what-is-the-purpose-of-having-the-concept-of-fasting-in-islam/9?atw=1#9 #ibadat

Tweeted by StackIslam on July 4, 2012 at 7:42 AM

Stack Exchange

11:05 AM

Why are the two daylight prayers done silently, and the others out loud? http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/1208/why-are-the-two-daylight-prayers-done-silently-and-the-others-out-loud?atw=1 #prayer

Tweeted by StackIslam on July 4, 2012 at 10:42 AM

HaLaBi

11:48 AM

salam all..

Mr.TAMER

12:01 PM

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatu Allah wa barakatuh

Ah I see @Aarthi is addressing our conversation a few days ago :D

Well, she's right, this isn't the right place. Politics SE might be the right place for such conversations (but in a friendly way, ofcourse :) ).

@Ershad: Are you there?

1

A: Special worship on the night of mid-Sha'ban

Ruling on Celebrating the Mid-Sha’ban Night – Detailed fatwa from Sheikh Ibn Baaz To proceed: Allah (Exalted be He) says: “This day, I have perfected your religion for you, completed My Favour upon you, and have chosen for you Islam as your religion” [al-Maa’idah 5:3] He (Exalted be He...

This answer is too long, people are not expected to read such long answers.

This is why I suggested this:

1

Q: Having a short and a complete part in Answers

I think not everybody is interested (or have just-in-case time) to read the whole answer (which contain Ayas, Hadiths, mental trail, etc...), there are many people who may need to get a quick answer for their questions (maybe because they're in a hurry at the same moment). Well, since the commun...

discussion answers

Gigili

12:21 PM

@MrTAMER Good one.

Salaam.

I couldn't agree more.

But the part about providing a summary of the answer in the beginning is not a good idea.

One still needs to scroll down two or three pages to see other answers.

Well, I'll post an answer then.

Mr.TAMER

Yes, that'll be better than losing ideas in the chat :)

HaLaBi

salam alaykum all

yasar11732

Wa Alaikum Salam

Mr.TAMER

@HaLaBi: Wa Alaikum assalam wa rahmatu Allah wa barakatuh

Gigili

@yasar11732 Salaam. Nice question you asked about gambling.

yasar11732

12:32 PM

@Gigili Wa Alaikum Salam, thanks.

HaLaBi

but the answer to question has a big mistake..

yasar11732

@HaLaBi You seem to be quite knowledged about subject, why won't you answer?

HaLaBi

I have no time.. I will post an answer after work.. I am evening shift today..

and english does not help me sometimes..

@MrTAMER check this: youtube.com/watch?v=MpRF5fBfORc&feature=g-u-u

it is nice... I love that guy alot

Ershad

@MrTAMER Thank you for the opinion, I am also felt it was too long. But, I wanted it to be persuasive to the reader rather than direct yes or no.. answers to islamic questions are different from the other question, where it is either correct or wrong with provable facts.

I have shortened it a bit

1

A: Special worship on the night of mid-Sha'ban

Ruling on Celebrating the Mid-Sha’ban Night – Detailed fatwa from Sheikh Ibn Baaz There are some other narrations regarding the virtue of this night reported from the righteous predecessors of the people of Al-Sham (the Levant) and others. What the majority of Muslim scholars agreed upon is that...

HaLaBi

12:49 PM

Guys, What is Mawlid in english?

Mawlid

same?

yup

0

Q: Is celebrating te "Mawlid day" Halal or Haram?

In my community, we used to celebrate the birth day of Mohammed (PBUH). In the past 30 or so years a lot of people start saying this is haram. Many people stopped doing it for many reasons but mainly not because they said it is haram but because the people who prohibit it are really bothering the...

halal-haram prophet-muhammad

Ershad

Oh..no

HaLaBi

12:56 PM

no what?

Ershad

Nothing

HaLaBi

ok...

Ershad

Mawlid usuallly gets into debates

HaLaBi

thats why I described the way I mean it. not in general.

Mr.TAMER

@HaLaBi @Ershad: Sorry guys, I'm just facing electricity difficulties

Ershad

1:00 PM

You could harvest your own electricity :P

HaLaBi

sorry to hear that tamer..

Ershad

just kidding

power cuts are common in india in summer.. don't you guys get it? why feel sorry for power cuts

HaLaBi

because in Tamer's case it is because of the conflicts..

Ershad

Ah.. okay

HaLaBi

for us here, we stopped having power cuts years ago..

we have connected the electricity network with the surrounding countries.. that helped all of us..

Ershad

1:03 PM

surrounding countries? so you share electricity?

HaLaBi

@Ershad whats the speed of electricity?? light speed??? sound speed?

yup.. our electricity networks are connected together.. for example, we need extra electricity now, we borrow from any network that has extra... some other time they borrow if we have extra...

Ershad

depends on the electromotive force.. that is difference between voltage at two points

HaLaBi

ok..

Ershad

or potential difference

let me given an example.. if water flow from very high pressure to low pressure.. the velocity of water will depend strongly on the pressure difference between them

electricity is similar

instead of pressure we have voltage..

HaLaBi

okkkkkkkkkkkkkk

i get it now...

but of course speeds are much faster than water

Ershad

1:09 PM

yes.. and also it depends on the medium it goes through.. like copper or aluminium... because the property of material is resistance.. which resists the flow of electricity and makes it slow

HaLaBi

ok.. nice to know

goldPseudo

assalaamu 'alaykum

Ershad

@goldPseudo walaikkum assalam

HaLaBi

wa alaykum assalam @goldPseudo

HaLaBi

1:28 PM

gtg guys

see ya later

salam alaykum

Ashu

is this question of mine legit?

3

Q: Boyfriends and girlfriends in Islam

Are we allowed to have boyfriends/ girlfriends in Islam. I mean take the person os the opposite gender out for lunch or dinner, interact with them, etc

relationships

Al Ummat

Asalamu wa alaikum

yasar11732

Wa Alaikum Salam

@Ashu If Robert thought It is not, than probably not. He knows better in this things.

goldPseudo

the question has been reworded since it was closed.

Ashu

ummm yeah (i was just typing that)

goldPseudo

1:40 PM

"boyfriends/girlfriends" is a weak term; it's hard to tell exactly what it means in the context. the question is still a bit too vague to be well-answered.

Ashu

what should it be then?

goldPseudo

i think if you described an actual situtation, it would be better.

rather than a general ruling on everything that could be "boyfriend/girlfriend"

Ashu

well i have no "actual sitaution". i would just like a a general ruling

goldPseudo

even then, asking about an actual situation would get a better answer.

"Would it be permissible for me to go out for lunch or dinner with a person of the opposite gender?"

Ashu

k seems fine

il do that

"Would it be permissible to take a person of the opposite gender out for lunch/dinner to kow more about him/her. I mean if I like his/her ideologies, way-of-life etc I would go on to marry him/her.
Is that permissible?"

Will this do

@goldPseudo

goldPseudo

1:52 PM

good question.

Ashu

thanks

goldPseudo

(a lot of slashes. i may rework the grammar a bit for clarity, but the question is sound.)

i voted to reopen. needs four more votes (or a diamond mod) before it's open.

Ashu

Thanks again :)

Stack Exchange

2:08 PM

Should muslims abide by under any law other than Sharia? http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/1213/should-muslims-abide-by-under-any-law-other-than-sharia?atw=1 #sharia

Tweeted by StackIslam on July 4, 2012 at 1:42 PM

goldPseudo

@ashu, looks like your question is open now.

i may take a stab at answering it when i have time, God willing.

yasar11732

@Ashu You misspelled know (kow) in your question. I can't make 1 char edit, so you may want to edit that :)

Ashu

2:40 PM

@yasar11732 thanks

yasar11732

@Ashu Check you edit :)

yasar11732

3:37 PM

Salamum Alaikum

Al Ummat

@yasar11732 wa alaikum salam

yasar11732

Can you recommend good site with Arabic text and translation of Qur'an ?

I want to ask a question about an ayat.

@Ashu Salamun Alaikum

Al Ummat

@yasar11732 yes

Quran.com

and

Ashu

@yasar11732 salam

Al Ummat

www.quranexplorer.com

there is also tanzil.net, just a bonus site :)

yasar11732

3:42 PM

:)
Thanks.

Al Ummat

your welcome :)

yasar11732

4:01 PM

@AlUmmat What site do you use for searching Hadith?

Al Ummat

sunnah.com I use it to copy the hadiths and paste them since I am online, I do not take the time to write them :)

yasar11732

4:18 PM

I am looking for an Hadith, but can't find it :/

Al Ummat

tell me what it is, I will be glad to help you :)

yasar11732

I know it is from Bukhari, and was something like "eat, drink, give sadaka, and wear, but don't waste"

It is how much I remember

Al Ummat

which book is it in?

do you remember?

yasar11732

No :/

Al Ummat

so do you know what the main idea of the hadith was, aside from what you gave above

?

yasar11732

4:22 PM

wasting is not good

Use whatever Allah gave you, but not in a wastefull way.

It might be in the book about dressing.

In Turkish version, it gives this -> (Buhari, Libas 1; İbnu Mace, Libas 23.) (17:42)

But I don't know what those numbers mean.

Buhari = Bukhari in Turkish.

Al Ummat

wait :) I will get it for you than I will tell you what they mean :)

what is "İbnu Mace"?

yasar11732

I don't know, maybe a scholar like Bukhari?

It means "son of Mace"

Al Ummat

ok

Ansari

he means ibn majah

Al Ummat

@Ansari so Ibnu Mace is Ibn Majah?

Ansari

4:32 PM

yes the turkish c --> j for us

Al Ummat

ok thank you for your help

Ansari

sunnah.com/bukhari/77 - @yasar11732 this is kitab al-libas of sahih al-bukhari

77 hadith - feel free to go through it to find the one you're looking for

yasar11732

This one doesn't have translation

sunnah.com/urn/54310

Ansari

it appears to be a repeat of the hadith 2 above it

Al Ummat

it is not a hadith, one thing to keep in mind is that sunnah.com is still being developed so there might be some errors

yasar11732

4:39 PM

What about this one: sunnah.com/urn/150090

Ansari

@AlUmmat it is definitely a hadith - why do you say it's not? it has a sanad and the matn is as the hadith above it

@yasar11732 it is an appendage to the hadith above it describing something about one of the narrators

Al Ummat

@Ansari I did not mean it is not a hadith, I meant there is no hadith in it right there

Ansari

namely, that one of the narrators saw anas wearing a certain type of yellow clothing

goldPseudo

i don't know about hadith, but quran.com/7/31 might be what you're thinking of. (inre the eat drink but do not waste)

Ansari

@AlUmmat yes there is no explicit matn in the text of that page

Stack Exchange

4:45 PM

Great answer: Is a woman required to have sex with her husband whenever he requests it? http://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/312/is-a-woman-required-to-have-sex-with-her-husband-whenever-he-requests-it/315?atw=1#315 #marriage

Tweeted by StackIslam on July 4, 2012 at 4:42 PM

Al Ummat

@Ansari perhaps the hadith is also in Sunan Ibn Majah, do you know a site that has a full online copy of it in both Arabic and english?

yasar11732

@goldPseudo That ayat sounds like exactly what I am looking for, but, I am reading a Turkish web page, mentions an Hadith giving these reference -> (Buhari, Libas 1; İbnu Mace, Libas 23.)

What is kibr in English. I think it is Arabic, means somethink like feeling mighty and important.

Being proud of ones self.

Al Ummat

in a bad way

the word is arrogance

yasar11732

Yes. How do you translate it into English?

@AlUmmat Oh, thanks.

goldPseudo

pride or arrogance

Al Ummat

4:49 PM

@yasar11732 your welcome

:)

Ansari

the best definition is that given by the Prophet (saws)

al kibr is batlu haqq and ghamtu an-nas

rejecting the truth and looking down on people

@AlUmmat i haven't come across a site that has both Arabic and English for Sunan ibn Majah

kalamullah has a PDF scan of the english translation of ibn majah

Al Ummat

ok thanks :)

Ansari

but if you find your hadith in there, you can look up the hadith number on hadith.al-islam.com or dorar.net or al-eman.com

Ershad

also islam-web.com?

sorry islamweb.net

well, it doesn't have english though

Al Ummat

5:07 PM

thank you :)

1

Q: When is Laylathul Qadr? What is it's importance?

What is Laylathul Qadr? From most of the scholars I've heard that it could be on any of 21st, 23rd, 25th, 27th and 29th of Ramadhan. But why do they orient it toward 27th? Please also quote some references on the importance of this night.

ramadhan

this is a good question

Ershad

when is laylathul Qadr?

yasar11732

No one knows for sure I guess.

Ershad

exactly. Then why?

yasar11732

Why to what?

why no one knows for sure?

Ershad

why ask when no one knows it?

yasar11732

5:11 PM

Hmm, so you say not a real question?

Ershad

i guess the question initially was 'what' ?

yasar11732

It keeps getting edited.

Ershad

No, probably the questioner doesn't know the issue...so it is a real question

Al Ummat

when is laylatul Qadr is a good questions still

there are many opinions with some hadiths to back them up

Ershad

@yasar11732 I guess you were thinking hard for a question...lol

Al Ummat

5:14 PM

on when laylatul Qadr is

Ershad

2

Q: Can a Muslim go for a vacation?

Consider this ayat from Surat Ash-Sharĥ فَإِذَا فَرَغْتَ فَانصَبْ (Qur'an 94:7) According to Sahih International this is translated as, So when you have finished [your duties], then stand up [for worship]. And some other translations translate this ayat as Therefore, when thou art f...

leisure

yasar11732

The ayah came up when I was reading something :)

@Ershad Do you think it is a bad question?

Ershad

Not at all...just funny :D

yasar11732

:D

I was being serious though. Why do you find it funny?

Ershad

It sounded like troll question to be at first.. I remembered a question from few days ago.. when someone asked why is everything forbidden in islam and he gave a list..

yasar11732

5:20 PM

haha :) Is that question still around?

Ershad

deleted i guess.. this guy asked it - islam.stackexchange.com/users/195/…

yasar11732

That guy seem to be asking only trolling questions.

Ershad

yeah.. borderline troll.. we can't close the question.. but something tells us he is troll lol..

Al Ummat

If I remember correctly, is not a troll , the word, referencing to a type of Jinn?

Ershad

okay.. i am going to take a shot at your question..but I need some clarifications

yasar11732

5:26 PM

mine?

Ershad

@yasar11732 yes.. @AlUmmat en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troll_(Internet)

yasar11732

@Ershad What do you need to know?

Ershad

@yasar11732 What do you mean by vacation? do you mean travel in vacation? My school gives me a vacation...i cant deny the vacation.. and say I want to go to school...lol

Al Ummat

@Ershad but doesn't the word have other meanings, away from the internet?

Ershad

@AlUmmat I am not aware of that :(

Al Ummat

5:29 PM

ok thanks :)

yasar11732

@Ershad Let me edit the question.

Ershad

good.. that'll help

yasar11732

@Ershad I did my edit.

Ershad

okay.. that clarifies it :)

Ershad

5:47 PM

@AlUmmat Did you see the edit on the Laylatul Qadr question?

Al Ummat

@Ershad I just saw it now

yasar11732

I just got a feeling that someone, someday will ask if trolling is haraam :)

Al Ummat

can someone tell me if my answer fits the current question

Ershad

lol.. yeah..too much haraam halaal questions

Al Ummat

1

Q: Why is Laylathul Qadr oriented toward 27th night of Ramadhan?

From most of the scholars I've heard that Laylathul Qadr could be on any of 21st, 23rd, 25th, 27th and 29th of Ramadhan. But why do they orient it toward 27th?

ramadhan

Ershad

5:52 PM

But, is it true that most scholars orient it towards 27th?

or is it people?

Al Ummat

both,

arn't scholars people too :P

yasar11732

Good point :D

Ershad

by people I mean common folk

Al Ummat

both, but it sometimes might depend in their knowledge

ok I split up my answer as requested f me

0

Q: Importance of Laylathul Qadr?

Why is Laylathul Qadr an Important night for Muslims? Please quote from the Qur'an or Hadith.

ramadhan laylathul-qadr

@Ershad from what you have asked me, I feel that there is something that you want to say, is that true?

Ershad

Yeah, basically what I meant is some people single out 27th for worshipping in Laylathul Qadr which is not proper... because the majority opinion is that it is last ten days (from 40 or so hadiths) and more specifically last seven days...

Transcript for