2:50 AM
@Davïd It's really not my field. It'd be like asking you about..... diachronic Hebrew phonology.... OK, fine:
I'm not a fan of either conspiracy theories or easy polarizations, with both of which that (longer) article is replete. And some stuff is just wrong. (Sugar is not, for the most part "turned into fat" in the liver. What it does do is induce insulin secretion and up-regulate series of enzymes that ultimately increase serum triglycerides, but that's saying something different.
And the shocking statement about the idiot US doctors who believe that dietary cholesterol raises serum cholesterol is just there because every such article needs a statement about how doctors are idiots. (Dietary cholesterol raises serum cholesterol, though it's certainly less important than saturated fat in that regard. The more important weakness in the dietary x to serum cholesterol argument is that the latter is itself only a surrogate endpoint.))
I'm sure the shift away from vilifying fat as the cause of cardiovascular disease is justified, but these remain really difficult studies to do well. (They describe the need for randomization which is at least conceivable, but neither control nor blinding are feasible in the long term in this area AFAIK.) The strongest association is with obesity, and how people become obese is a lot more complicated than dietary macronutrient distribution. But it's really not my field...
3:27 AM
3 hours later…
6:46 AM
@PaulVargas Check out this issue. There are some links to data in there as well as background for the reversify plugin from our very own @curiousdannii. I don't know what I did with the list I had years ago, but the work we've done for Stack Verse Mapper has brought this issue up several times. (cc @Susan @Davïd)
9 hours later…
3:23 PM
2 hours later…
4 hours later…
9:38 PM
0
Not only does Paul, in his own epistles, never mention having learnt at the feet of Gamaliel, he never quote any of his teachings even when he faces challenges to his Jewish orthodoxy. Vincent P. Branick (Understanding Paul and His Letters, page 27) notes this and adds that Paul's initial zeal to...
Acts 22:2-3 says: 2 ...Then he [Paul] said [to a bunch of Jews in order to defend himself against challenges to his Jewish orthodoxy (Acts 21:28)]: 3 “I am indeed a Jew, born in Tarsus of Cilicia, but brought up in this city [Jerusalem] at the feet of Gamaliel, taught according to the strictness of our fathers’ law, and was zealous toward God as you all are today." Are you saying these are not Paul's own words and that the author of Acts essentially made that up? – Brian Weigand
@BrianWeigand I am citing respected scholars on this. Since at least the late 20th century, many scholars have expressed doubts about some things in Acts. – Dick Harfield
Are you saying Acts 22:2-3 are not Paul's own words and that the author of Acts essentially made that up? Yes / No. – Brian Weigand
« first day (1759 days earlier) ← previous day next day → last day (2836 days later) »
Transcript for
Jul28
Jul '1629
Jul30
The Library
General discussion for hermeneutics.stackexchange.com