Veger

bye bye

lol, me too (going to sleep)

@Mysticial I'll flag a moderator! :P

Currently the faq is more extensive than the extensive answer... :D

In the new faq (we just created) there are more than 3 items to describe good questions... I guess one that is going to improve the answer should take those items to start with

Also tag the question that was mentioned in the meta question with this new tag

@LoganM I'll call the SE police!

lol

nice

@Mysticial agree

If all possible answers are given, it should be locked. (No changes will occur in the future on this topic as anime is not changing) This prevents the accumulation of new (similar) answers

Can't we turn into a FAQ/Wiki kind of question?

I tend to go with not allowed (when looking at rules and quality), but I really do like the question... :(

@LoganM True, at least keep the question until the site is approved :P

The answers go two directions: anime and cartoon are the same and they are different. Isn't this 'non constructive'? There does not seem to be one straightforward answer

And afterwards it needs to (stay) locked

The tag is incorrect

If the verdict is to keep the question, it needs to be cleaned

It is at least a goof FAQ question to show (new) people what anime incorporates (when it is unclear)

Maybe change to 'More information about list questions is available in this post'?

"This post will help you understand which list questions are acceptable and which are not." is a bit descriptive/long (maybe too bold?)

yep

@Mysticial Assuming the reason is known... Otherwise it will become a debate

@Mysticial Especially as these questions tend to become outdated (fast)

@LoganM Other (non-gameplay) questions about Anime-related games are allowed? I would think that any game question is off-topic?

@MadaraUchiha Questions about obtaining (illegal) anime/manga or when they air

@MadaraUchiha - Questions about cosplay, anime conferences, etc.

@Mysticial I would say not allowed (instead of 'slippery slopes'), they either are referring to illegal versions or are shopping lists

@Krazer I suppose that falls under "not allowed"

@MadaraUchiha we should exclude cosplay and conference questions, I suppose

@Krazer yes, we had some of these questions and they got closed

the others (1 & 4) not so much

number 2 and 3 of the SF&F faq seems applicable to me

next is "not allowed" list?

ok, fine by me

@MadaraUchiha It is only a bullet list and a 'tag link', easier to recreate than to ask for... Unless you want to say hi to our neighbors :)

(maybe rephrase a little)

When reading the SF&F faq, the allowed list is good enough for us I suppose. Or is it missing something?

@Mysticial He started borrowing (stealing) already ;)

@kuwaly yes we are, it was an addition to the list of allowed questions :)

@Mysticial 3. Identify the name of the anime/manga that has X, Y and Z

@Mysticial Something like that indeed, but anime -> anime and manga

Other sites have a list describing a broad range of topics showing what the site is about

@Mysticial Example questions are quite specific and such a list needs to be kept up-to-date.

@Sathya Hm... you are right, it more about server security or the framework itself (depending what provided the entry point of the hacker). I'll try to be more careful, thanks for pointing out!

@Sathya I am sorry if I made a mistake, could you provide a link to the question at issue? (so I can learn from my mistake)