« first day (2091 days earlier)      last day (2250 days later) » 

4:15 AM
The question is older than 14 days, so it is no longer shown in community bulletin and thus probably there will be not much further input to the discussion.
It is top voted answer and it basically says to leave the current status. So probably it is reasonable to consider that as the consensus which came out of the discussion.
I am not sure whether mods should also remove the proposed synonym $\to$ and change the master tag in the synonym for to . (The other alternative would be to leave this to voting of users.)
My downvote just moved the (group-hommomorphism) syn to score -1. (Although I cast the downvote more because it's better to suggest synonym only after the issue was sufficiently discussed on meta and less because I have clear preference one way or the other in this matter.)
Maybe if there is another mod that takes interest in tag-related issues you could ask also them. (arjafi was quite active in tag related stuff, but he resigned some time ago.)
@quid See above. I hope it answers your question.
 
 
1 hour later…
5:28 AM
It was done by the same user who created . This tag was synonymized with (modular-form) by Alexander Gruber and on meta Jyrki posted answer wearing a "dictator outfit".
I am not saying that some action from moderators is needed. But since these two mods interacted by the previous tag created by the same user, maybe it might be worth at least letting them know.
in Math Mods' Office, 14 secs ago, by Martin Sleziak
@AlexanderGruber and @JyrkiLahtonen Since you have previously interacted with a tag created by this user, I thought it might be worth letting you know that they created another (somewhat similar) tag - details can be seen in the tagging chatroom.
And also the opinion of some number theorist on usefulness of separate tag for and/or would be useful. I suppose that from people who are around, this is question for @quid.
Sorry for the typo, it was siegel-modular-forms. I managed to edit the last message but it is too late to change the previous occurrence.
In mathematics, a modular form is a (complex) analytic function on the upper half-plane satisfying a certain kind of functional equation with respect to the group action of the modular group, and also satisfying a growth condition. The theory of modular forms therefore belongs to complex analysis but the main importance of the theory has traditionally been in its connections with number theory. Modular forms appear in other areas, such as algebraic topology, sphere packing, and string theory. A modular function is a function that, like a modular form, is invariant with respect to the modular group...
In mathematics, Siegel modular forms are a major type of automorphic form. These stand in relation to the conventional elliptic modular forms as abelian varieties do in relation to elliptic curves; the complex manifolds constructed as in the theory are basic models for what a moduli space for abelian varieties (with some extra level structure) should be, as quotients of the Siegel upper half-space rather than the upper half-plane by discrete groups. The modular forms of the theory are holomorphic functions on the set of symmetric n × n matrices with positive definite imaginary part; the forms must...
Looking at those Wikipedia articles, it's overwhelming how much mathematics is out there that I do not have a clue about. (Considering that I still hope to have some kind of career in academia.)
 
 
1 hour later…
6:53 AM
Hi @JyrkiLahtonen - thanks for taking your time to visit the room.
I will just repeat that I am not sure whether some mod action is needed. (Many users create tags without clearing them first on meta - so this users is by no means something exceptional.)
But since both you (by posting the answer on meta) and Alexander Gruber (by creating the synonym) interacted in some way with the previous tag created by this user, I notified you. (Maybe you already noticed that even without my message.)
The above ping was mainly because I saw that you are present in this room - but I see that your gravatar disappeared almost immediately after my ping. So I suppose that you were not in fact here. (I have noticed that this happens in chat quite a lot - a user is displayed as being in the room even after they left.)
 
 
6 hours later…
12:29 PM
@MartinSleziak my intent was to do so, I do not think it's reasonable to leave this lingering around. At some point it might kick in and no one might noticed. There is no urgency. I'll leave it for a bit, but likely I'll just remove them in a while.
Re the ring-morphism, I'll just removed that too.
It does no harm but it is also mostly useless as statistics show. I prefer a relatively clean list of tags/syns thus I tend to remove things that I feel are not useful anymore.
Such as singular-plural syns that became basically obsolete with more rigid checks on tag creation.
@MartinSleziak likely there are separate traditions to that but to me (I am not working on this but I have some vague idea, maybe) a modular form mostly means elliptic modular form. Now a Siegel modular form is a higher dimensional version of this. And all of them are
This is mostly in line with WIkipedia too.
Thus, elliptic modular forms seems not really needed to me; one could make it a syn but why bother. Siegel modular forms could work as a tag. The issue was that it was used incorrectly. I do not think we need it though; and should suffice. (Maybe just one of those would suffice.)
That said "Siegel modular forms" should not be a syn of "modular forms". It made sense to merge, but only because the tag was used wrongly. It could be a syn of automorphic-forms.
I removed it.
A related problem It is ambiguous.
Used for entirely different things, no tag description.
 

« first day (2091 days earlier)      last day (2250 days later) »