« first day (2261 days earlier)      last day (2333 days later) » 

2:59 AM
0
Q: How likely was it that the Allies won both WWI and WWII?

TheEnvironmentalistAs a student of the 21st century, I've learned that freedom and democracy won both World Wars. And yet, it would seem, given the incredible threat posed by the Central and later Axis powers, this was largely just chance. It's hard to remember that history is written by the victors, but even so, h...

 
3:30 AM
0
Q: In a feudal system, when did a king grant land to someone new?

BobTheAverageFrom wikipedia: A fief (/fiːf/; Latin: feudum) was the central element of feudalism and consisted of heritable property or rights granted by an overlord to a vassal who held it in fealty (or "in fee") in return for a form of feudal allegiance and service, usually given by the personal ceremon...

 
4:02 AM
0
Q: How much impact did the discovery that the Milkyway was not the entire Universe have?

JeffI don't know if this is the right forum for this question, but it seems to me that it was one of the easiest to understand and yet one of the most significant discoveries in the history of science. But I could see the average person not following such discoveries or grasping its significance. I a...

 
 
2 hours later…
6:23 AM
0
Q: Which English ship was in Kamchatka in 1793?

Aaron BrickIn 1795, Alaskan colonial supremo A.A. Baranov sent a letter to his bosses in Irkutsk. The text in Tikhmenev's History, Volume II, Documents, says: An English ship wintered in Kamchatka in 1793.... The English were well-armed.... If Baranov was correct, what ship was this, and where did it ...

 
 
3 hours later…
9:51 AM
0
Q: Who lived on Golden Square in London in the 18th century?

rachkoutiIs there a database or an archive where I could find London Golden Square's inhabitants in the 18th century. I know that a famous musician of that time was living on that square, and I'm trying to find in which house exactly and what time he was there (I know he was in London from 1729 and dies ...

 
 
1 hour later…
11:10 AM
0
Q: When Israel won the Six Day War, was expelling all arabs from acquired territories considered?

JeffDid Israel consider doing this and if so, would that have been in violation of international law?

 
11:21 AM
@TheHistorian 'Arabs', or 'Muslims', or 'Druze', or what?
@Semaphore I'd advise against posting that answer as a comment
Relevant:
35
Q: Please don't write answers in comments

Arwen UndómielI've been noticing a trend lately of people writing answers in the comment section. What does this mean? When you write an attempt to solve the OPs question - whether it's a fully fleshed out idea or not - and dump it in the comment box. This is not good. Answers is comments are detrimental to ...

It's also covered in @sempaiscuba's answer, so it's also redundantly repeating information
 
11:53 AM
@Mithrandir sempaiscuba's answer hadn't been posted yet when I started commenting.
 
@Semaphore true, but I'd still heavily discourage posting answers as comments at all
 
@Mithrandir I don't think it's an answer though. Of course ethnic cleansing is illegal, but that doesn't answer whether it was considered.
 
True - but it still answers the second half of the question, and it's better not to set the precedent for behavior that's discouraged across the network.
 
I think that precedent set sail years ago...
e.g. history.stackexchange.com/questions/42401/… H.SE never had a meta conversation against partial answers in comments, I believe. Then again, we get a lot of multipart questions which lend itself to this kind of commenting.
 
Well, time to turn the tide, I suppose ;)
But that shiny diamond also adds extra weight to setting that precedent.
 
12:31 PM
@Mithrandir Perhaps we need a similar post on the History:SE meta site? Particularly if we are looking to change established behaviours.
 
@sempaiscuba I could try to write one, if you want.
 
I think that would be good. I'd rather any change was driven by the community.
 
OK. I'll try to write something later today.
 
 
2 hours later…
2:15 PM
On 20 December 1917 the first Soviet secret police force, Cheka, was founded. It was led by the Polish aristocrat-turned-communist, Felix Dzerzhinsky.
 
 
1 hour later…
3:18 PM
I have a personal rule that once I start wanting things like BBCode formatting and paragraphs, and start bumping up against the comment length limit, its really time to make it an answer. Admittedly, that runs me afoul of "not an answer" comments sometimes.
That being said, I can't help but notice the comment in question contains both italics and boldface. Seems like the full edit tools available in our answer posting tools would have made the author's task of emphasizing certain points much easier there... ;-)
There's really no shame in converting a comment to an answer once it outgrows its container. (Or perhaps just deleting it because someone made the same point in an actual decent answer).
...rereading it though, I am kinda with Sem that it isn't an answer to the question. As he said, the main question was if it was considered, and he didn't have any info on that.
 
3:49 PM
Personally, my rule is comments instead of answers when it's only a wiki link, or a quote. If something is answerable by a wikilink it usually gets closed for being trivial anyway. Or it should be.
Though in this case, I just wanted to lay down the international law in case people start spinning justifications for ethnic cleansing.
 
:-) I have noticed that. "A short answer" linked to Wikipedia in a comment is Semaphore for "This should be closed as trivial". Most often works too.
 
>:)
 
4:35 PM
0
Q: What happened to peoples houses during the Soviets reign?

Anton KeslovReally, what happened to them? Did the Soviet union destroy them, house troops with in them? What happened? Where did the people go when communism was adapted? Did they stay in their residencies or move to communal apartments? This is a question I have been asking for a while.

 
 
2 hours later…
7:00 PM
@Semaphore That's why I posted the answer.
 
 
1 hour later…
8:23 PM
0
Q: In 1700s, 1800s, as cash crops in South became more profitable, how did plantation owners do all the work?

LiAngelTalking about cash crops such as Rice in 18th and 19th centuries in Southern States. As cash crops became more profitable, how did plantation owners do all the work?

 
@TheHistorian * blink *
 
Um.
 
@Semaphore There you go again... :-)
 
9:10 PM
0
Q: Autonomy of Transylvania within Hungary before 1526

cipricusOn 29 August 1526, the Ottoman Empire inflicted a decisive defeat on the Hungarian forces at Mohács. The occupation of main Hungary by the Turks has created the conditions for autonomy, confirmed by the Treaty of Speyer (1570). In 1711 the the princes of Transylvania were replaced with Habsburg g...

 
9:41 PM
0
Q: Typology and the cause of difference between European medieval kingship?

cipricusWestern Medieval Catholic kings and nobility in Britain, France, Spain and Portugal, Italy, Germany and Austria share certain distinctive common features that can be summed under the term of vassalage that are less present in Hungary and Poland, possibly also in Scandinavia. I am referring to the...

 
10:03 PM
That's blurry, and I'm having trouble reading it :/
 
Let us know what it says.
 
> בהמשך לשיחת ראש-הממשלה עם שר האוצר בנוכחות שנינו, אנא דאג להקציב מיד סך 100.000 ל"י לחודש, בדיעבד מראשית שנה התקציב הנוכחות וסמכות להגדיל את ההקבה עד 200 אלף ל"י עבור עדוד הגירה מרצועת עזה לבצוע ל?י הנחיות גב' עדה סירני, בהתאם להצעת התקציב, שהיה הגי?ה לעיון ראש הממשלה ושר האוצר.
I'm thinking that the first ? is a מ and the second is a ש but I'm not sure.
 
So just a funding authorisation?
 
10:19 PM
The vocabulary is a bit out of my depth...
 
Not much of an evidence for anything.
tbh I find it bemusing that scholarly sources and international committees are attacked as biased, while no such objection get raised against ostensibly Israeli government documents.
 
Well, that's just the main body of the text.
hmm
The 'subject' is 'encouraging immigration from the Gaza strip'
 
10:45 PM
0
Q: Should History.SE be deleting answers posted as comments?

MithrandirPrompted by a chat discussion. Sometimes, users post answers in the comment section. They do this for several reasons - some common ones include that they don't have time to write a full answer, that they are only addressing part of the question, that the answer they wanted to post doesn't have ...

 

« first day (2261 days earlier)      last day (2333 days later) »