« first day (3196 days earlier)      last day (758 days later) » 

Martin Sleziak
Martin Sleziak
4:01 AM
The first link above goes to: Top journals in mathematical analysis It was posted a few days ago and relatively quickly closed: mathoverflow.net/posts/418852/timeline mathoverflow.net/posts/418852/revisions
At the moment it is in the reopen review queue: mathoverflow.net/review/reopen/161706 (And there are now three reopen votes.)
5
Q: Top journals in mathematical analysis

jgallHow would you (broadly) rank the journals that specialize in mathematical analysis and related areas such as PDEs? As far as I know, GAFA looks like it is the top one. But apart from that, how can I compare other "good" analysis journals? I'm more than happy with partial answers! Some of them: G...

real-analysis ap.analysis-of-pdes journals
Some of the comments posted under the question.
Close as "opinion-based"? — Gerry Myerson 2 days ago
@GerryMyerson It is certainly opinion-based; on the other hand, a very similar MO question has not been closed. — Timothy Chow 2 days ago
I wonder whether there is a variation of this question that would be accepted by this community (or another adequate community where I can ask this). I think the question is interesting for many people (see how many people has bookmarked the linked question) and it's hard to find an answer without insider knowledge, so I'd be happy to repurpose it. — jgall yesterday
As for the last comment: I don't know what kind of questions would be acceptable. Maybe you could raise a question in meta.mathoverflow.net to ask this — of course, questions of this sort are of interest to mathematicians, but it is unclear what platform is better (MO is more QA, and this might be considered better suited for forums.) — Z. M yesterday
The linked question is: Top specialized journals. One of the answers is about PDEs.
105
Q: Top specialized journals

Andy PutmanIn geometry/topology, there are (at least) three specialized journals that end up publishing a large fraction of the best papers in the subject -- Geometry and Topology, JDG, and GAFA. What journals play a similar role in other subjects? Let me be more specific. Suppose that I'm an analyst (...

journals big-list soft-question
5
A: Top specialized journals

Benoît KloecknerIn PDE and related analysis, there are a lot of good journal, among which the recent Analysis and PDE (by MSP, the publishers of Geometry & Topology) and the much older Archive for Rational mechanics and Analysis seem to stand on top. Also noticeable are Annales de l'IHP - analyse non linéaire, C...

If you look at the timeline, you can see that the older question had some close votes in the past - it was in the close votes review queue three times: mathoverflow.net/posts/3512/timeline
@jgall This is a reasonable place to ask about this - in the sense that such inquiry is certainly on-topic here. But since MO users visit this room rather seldom, I am not sure how likely is to get some response here.
Your question currently has three reopen votes and in it in the review queue for reopen votes: mathoverflow.net/review/reopen/161706
That means the the users who have sufficient reputation to cast close/reopen votes and who visit that review queue will see the question there - and they will decide either to vote to reopen or they choose the option to leave closed. (Or neither of those two options - like I did, this is not really something I am able to judge.)
If the question gets 5 reopen votes, it gets reopened.
My advice would be to wait first until the reopen review is finished: mathoverflow.net/review/reopen/161706
I will add also SEDE queries with the reviews - although I think it is easier to access them through the timeline: data.stackexchange.com/mathoverflow/query/1086014/… data.stackexchange.com/mathoverflow/query/1086014/… (Moreover, the data in SEDE is only updated once a week.)
The advice to ask on meta seems reasonable to me:
As for the last comment: I don't know what kind of questions would be acceptable. Maybe you could raise a question in meta.mathoverflow.net to ask this — of course, questions of this sort are of interest to mathematicians, but it is unclear what platform is better (MO is more QA, and this might be considered better suited for forums.) — Z. M yesterday
The question is whether to wait until the review queue is finished or not.
The advantage of posting on meta now (rather than waiting) would be that more people could have a look - and maybe some of them would cast a reopen vote.
And possibly you could get there also some advice whether the question can be improved in some way.
 
 
1 hour later…
uhoh
uhoh
5:35 AM
0
Q: What is 12-fold Stampfli-inflation tiling and where/how can I recognize it in this analysis of dodecagonal 30° twisted bilayer graphene?

uhohDodecagonal 30° twisted bilayer graphene is just two graphene honeycomb nets with an exact 30° rotation with respect to the other. If you treat it as a 2D pattern rather than a 3D stacked structure, it would have 12-fold rotational symmetry and apparently some quasicrystal properties, including: ...

tiling
asked in Math SE
9
Q: Proposing a 2D quasicrystal; what are the necessary and sufficient conditions? (If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, or...?)

uhohQuasicrystals show repeating motifs or patterns but are not periodic. And yet their Fourier transforms invariably demonstrate a pattern of sharp peaks revealing that there is still an underlying... something. Generally if one works hard one can show that a quasicrystal proper of $n$ dimensions is...

crystallography symmetry terminology quasicrystals
in Matter Modeling SE
 
 
3 hours later…
Martin Sleziak
Martin Sleziak
8:58 AM
MO users have an interesting habit of engaging with spammers - rather than flagging.
Religiion is spread by lunatics and charlatans. Which are you? — Ben McKay 3 mins ago
I will add the usual reminder: What should I do when I see a spam post on MO?
The post was caught by SD:
in Charcoal HQ, 7 mins ago, by SmokeDetector
[ SmokeDetector | MS ] Potentially bad ns for domain in body, potentially bad keyword in body (2): what is umrah? muslims from all over the world, including pakistan, go to the holy land of saudi arabia to perform umrah‭ by sstravelpk‭ on mathoverflow.net
 

« first day (3196 days earlier)      last day (758 days later) »