Bransdein Joachain problem 11.1 along with the introductory part of the chapter asserts that the photon density per unit time is quite high for most cases so we can treat EM field as classical...The assumption in the problem I think was to treat the detector as a part of a spherical surface and the source to be a point source...
But what if the surface of the detector was flat, then at large angles from the normal to the surface, photon density is quite small...
Do we need to consider quantization of EM field in such cases?It seems(to me)we don't have to, but Bransden's argument doesn't h…