« first day (2347 days earlier)      last day (2585 days later) » 

12:02 AM
@0celouvsky Hm? "ahoi" is more kind of a seafarer's gretting for me
 
@ACuriousMind Idk if you saw above, but my thesis is going to relate to cobordisms of constant curvature manifolds.
My first goal is to learn about pseudodifferential operators and the index theorem.
So it looks like I'll be needing that heat equation after all
 
Sounds nice
 
@ACuriousMind It means I'll have to confront my Spin(n) phobia.
Not looking forward to that bit.
 
You'll be fine as long as the word 'Majorana' doesn't make an appearance ;)
 
haha
What does your advisor think about that situation?
 
12:12 AM
I actually didn't ask him yet since it's rather tangential to what I'm doing and we usually have enough more directly relevant stuff to discuss
 
@ACuriousMind Majoranas are not relevant to all of SUSY?
 
@0celouvsky Oh, they are, but the actual supersymmetry plays a rather minor role compared to the truckloads of algebraic and complex geometry that appear in the construction I'm looking at
 
12:29 AM
I asked a question. If anyone is interested please contribute an answer
 
@ACuriousMind I'm reading the book on heat flow/Atiyah Singer by Gilkey. The guy's a madman. Complete proofs of Plancherel's theorem, Sobolev embedding, and Rellich embedding in the first eight pages...
I looked at this book two years ago and decided it was something I'd never read...
 
hey
 
@Slereah what's up
 
just woke up
bit early again
 
jesus
you're the anti @ACuriousMind
 
12:36 AM
I tried taking a nap to get back on normal hours, but when it came time to wake up, I was like "Eh fuck it"
 
Hello
 
hello mister physics
I wonder if that thing with static spacetime applies generally
If a spacetime is translation symmetric, are there null homotopic spacelike loops
Wait, didn't we prove or at least motivate spacelike loops whenever $n \geq 3$
yeah I don't think the proof works, probably due to the multiple spatial dimensions
same reason ultrahyperbolic spacetimes always have ctcs
though I guess that's why it works in 2 dimensions
Since there's only one timelike dimension
 
1:08 AM
I don't know what you are saying. However, is it possible you could take a look at the question I asked on the site?
 
lol
 
Stop begging for answers
That works poorly
 
"begging"
I don't beg! Even when I was down I did not beg.
If someone could even tell me what theory had said properties, or definitions of what such things meant, I would derive the rest, just as I have been doing for the past 5 years
I just don't know the language they are using
lol
Anyways I asked a question on the site. I am not "begging" for answers. If you feel capable and willing to contribute an answer, the link is physics.stackexchange.com/questions/324167/… , otherwise save the primal tendencies for the real world.
 
1:25 AM
Wait a moment
Is the fact that QFT path integrals are mostly done on vacuum states because of that Schroedinger wavefunctional formula $\int \mathscr D \phi e^{iS} \Psi_1^* \Psi_2$
And that $\Psi = 1$ for the vacuum
 
I am not sure what you are asking, but let me make a few general remarks concerning words you have mentioned. Then we can try to rephrase the question together.
Firstly as far as I know. Feynman path integrals according to how I have come to understand them, are generalizations ; or perhaps extensions of ideas of probability theory. They are infinite dimensional integrals as you know with an action S playing the central role. The dimension and whether or not the integral is easy to solve plays a big role.
The vacuum state is the sate of lowest energy or no particles
What you are asking me is if the path integrals are done on . . . . .?
 
@Slereah Yes
 
@ACuriousMind what was he asking?
ok I guess I am stupid
What do you mean psi = 1 for vacuum?
@Slereah was the question addressed to me?
 
1:42 AM
It was not.
 
ok
 
2:16 AM
I'm trying to define some simple 2D motion such that an object moves very quickly then suddenly exhibits a lot of friction and has a fairly long period of settling. I usually play around with a basic critically-damped spring equation, but it's not quite the motion I want.
Even playing with mass and stiffness (the spring system I work with has such parameters), I feel like there may be a different kind or characteristic of motion that I can look into to get the feel I want.
I don't know a ton about physics, so I may be asking for something that isn't really found in actual physics. :)
 
2:52 AM
Reichenbach spends a long time talking about congruence
 
3:49 AM
@Slereah here's a question
Is any set in a manifold that's contractible homeomorphic to a subset of Rn?
 
I suspect it is
 
Someone has to actually make a bar called the h bar
and theme it around theoretical physics
that would be awesome
 
There is one, yes
I think it's at one of the big universities
 
Oh I just searched, yeah at uwashington there is one
nice!
 
@Slereah it's an interesting problem to think about
I don't know the answer
 
4:02 AM
I looked for a related thing for my proof but it's hard to google
might have to ask MSE
 
I don't know much about topology, but if it's contractible, then isn't it simply connected? And if it's simply connected, isn't the entire manifold homeomorphic to a n-sphere in Rn?
by the Poincare conjecture
 
@Slereah ask me and I'll take a look when I get up
I'm off, bye
 
4:55 AM
Cya
 
5:26 AM
Next time I am going to ask questions one by one. I am NOT going to allow your subconscious anymore freedom of choice to answer randomly just one of them
-> Freewill is indeed an intriguing topic
 
@Kaumudi morning :-)
 
-> Therefore, we argued that perhaps there really is freewill, but it is not from our consciousness
 
user228700
Morning! :-)
 
user228700
Look at this hipster-ish jar I bought yesterday for storing notes of gratitude:
 
user228700
 
user228700
5:30 AM
Got it for £1 !
 
user228700
(Yes, I am excited about having bought a jar :-P)
 
Wow, that's a great laptop. But what's that thing in the way? :-)
BTW did you find dust getting into the keyboard is a big problem. I remember you were worried about it, but the laptop still looks very clean.
@Kaumudi.H That is nice. Presumably anything you want to keep to remember you roll up and post though the hole at the top. So in effect it becomes a jar of memories.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie I instinctively knew that u were just about to ask about that :-) Yes, it's been quite useful; I have obtained many mushroom-clouds of dust from the fan area. As for the screen and keyboard, oh my, I have to clean it once a day; Chennai is a dusty place.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Hehe yes, those were my thoughts exactly. That hole was built for a straw but I'm going to use it for this!
 
In the UK it's more fluff that builds up on the fan. I guess it's fibres from people's clothes or whatever generally goes into forming dust bunnies.
Dust isn't usually a big problem.
 
user228700
5:41 AM
Riight. It is a big problem over here so I'm glad I invested that money in the blower :-)
 
The company I work part time for has a customer who runs a stone quarry.
Quarrying stone produces huge amounts of dust, and their computers are so choked with dust it's amazing they work at all.
We'd open up PCs and there would be so much dust inside that you literally couldn't see the circuit board.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Eeeek! :-o
 
I don't get involved with computer repair these days, so I don't know if they still have that problem.
 
user228700
Ah, OK.
 
user228700
Hmm, how have you been? You haven't bought another laptop for a while now, are u OK? (:-P)
 
5:49 AM
I keep an eye out for laptops, but even I currently have enough :-)
Reluctant though I am to admit it.
I need to give some of them away so I can buy some more :-)
 
user228700
:-) I see. Have u managed to find anybody who hasn't "run away screaming" yet?
 
It's in almost perfect condition and no-one has bid on it. But ... well I already have one exactly like that.
 
user228700
Man, people just keep on selling Dell laptops on eBay! Near to perfect ones at that!
 
I know. Right now would be a great time for students to get a cheap laptop. And these are really good laptops. That one would be as fast as yours though the screen is a lot smaller.
Do any of your sisters want a laptop? :-)
 
user228700
:-) No, not yet; they're only 10.5 and I wouldn't trust them with a laptop of their own just yet.
 
5:54 AM
I can't remember what age my niece was when she got her first laptop. About 11 I think.
 
Don't let them use it on their own?
 
user228700
I suppose it depends on the set of conditions under which they're allowed to use it.
 
Exactly
 
@skillpatrol I warned her to be careful about chatting to people on the Internet. Apart from that I left her to it.
She's a sensible girl.
 
user228700
I wouldn't want either of them fumbling around on the internet using a laptop of their own just yet. When they're a little older perhaps...
 
5:56 AM
I think the dangers are exaggerated.
 
user228700
I don't. It's extremely easy, for instance, to run into soft porn as a child. I once saw a graphic advertisement on the side of a game I'd been playing!
 
With proper supervison it'll be fine.
 
user228700
And children are so curious.
 
True dat
 
Children are going to see porn on the Internet whatever you do. I'm not that fussed about it - with a bit of luck they'll grow up wondering why their parents are so hung up about it.
 
user228700
5:59 AM
Sigh. Perhaps I'm in denial about that but as a child, I didn't have the best of experiences meandering the internet on my own so I'm going to wait for a bit before trusting them with this stuff.
 
The only reason the porn industry exists is because we make such a big deal of taking our clothes off. If it were normal then the porn industry wouldn't exist and that would probably be a good thing.
Dammit, I hate this keyboard.
 
user228700
It's probably never going to be "normal" though; at least not until we've learned to control our brains.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Hmm? Are u not using ur normal keyboard?
 
14 hours ago, by John Rennie
Frakking, frakking, fraketty, francking frak! I've just spilt a pint of beer over my desk, keyboard, mouse, lap, and so on. Ballcocks! :-(
 
user228700
OH NO! :'-(
 
6:03 AM
I'm using an old keyboard I had spare, and it has a different feel so I keep missing keys.
 
user228700
14 hours ago, by Bernardo Meurer
You of all people?
 
user228700
^ My thoughts exactly.
 
@Kaumudi.H no great harm done. The spilt beer missed my laptop and phone so it just made a hell of a mess. But it wrote off the keyboard. Not that it matters as keyboards are cheap. I'll just search ebay for another.
@Kaumudi.H I think Bernardo was more conerned about the waste of beer :-)
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Oh, phew, OK. Were u able to save the mouse?
 
Yes, it was only the keyboard that has gone to the great IT recycling scheme in the sky.
Damn, damn, damn!
 
user228700
6:06 AM
> The great IT recycling scheme in the sky.
 
user228700
I love this! x'D
 
user228700
I kid you not, I will buy your book if u write it first.
 
The problem is I can't order a new keyboard now because I'm going to my Mum's for Easter next week so I'll be away. It will have to wait until I'm back in a fortnight's time. Oh well, until then I just have to take extra care typing.
 
user228700
Ah, OK :-(
 
user228700
Is Easter another holiday centered around chocolate?
 
6:09 AM
Anyway, though I'm not buying laptops at the moment I'm still looking for bargain tablets. I have just bought this and it should be arriving this morning.
@Kaumudi.H I guess so, though I don't eat much chocolate these days. I prefer sweet/sticky cakes.
 
user228700
I dunno what you keep editing your messages for; I see literally no difference because I probably didn't spot the typo in the first place which means that IT IS OK U CAN STOP EDITING THE SMALL TYPOS AWAY.
 
No, no, these things matter :-)
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Why does this look like a form of meat?
 
Hmm, yes, it's not a great picture.
It's dough formed into a strip and then looped around to form a knot. Then baked and iced.
 
user228700
Ooh, nice!
 
user228700
6:14 AM
I'm having chocolate cake today!
 
Mmm, chocolate cake :-)
It's Saturday, so I should be making a biiiiiiiig meal, but at the moment I don't feel that hungry.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Suuuure.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie No plans either?
 
@Kaumudi.H I honestly don't have any ideas for what I want to eat today. I'll probably end up wandering around the shops looking to see if anything catches my attention.
I might just have a light meal and then make an extra special meal tomorrow. There's no point in forcing myself to eat a big meal if i don't feel like it.
 
user228700
True :-)
 
user228700
6:20 AM
BTW, I'll be needing those book recommendations in about a month's time!
 
user228700
Gosh, I've missed the library so so much.
 
A month - the end is in sight then? :-)
 
user228700
YES! :-)
 
What on Earth will you do when normal life is resumed? You'll have forgotten how to live a normal life :-)
 
user228700
It's true. Sometimes, I look at other people on the streets etc. and wonder what it would be like to live a normal life in which crap doesn't hit the fan every other day, which is the way that it's been for close to 3 years now.
 
6:22 AM
Are you definitely going to be doing an engineering degree?
 
user228700
Most certainly, yes.
 
I remember you were saying you did want to do physics at one time.
 
user228700
Yes, that as well. I have a few more exams to go and how I do on them will decide that for me.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie I will celebrate this by sleeping for hours.
 
23 hours ago, by John Rennie
Actually I have a vague recollection that I was so wasted after five days of exams that I just went to bed and slept for 12 hours :-)
 
user228700
6:25 AM
:-) I haven't ever slept for any more than 10 hours at a time. I wonder what it would be like to go to bed at 5 AM and sleep through the day.
 
When I was an undergraduate I used to love lying in bed reading. On Sunday morning I would lie in bed and read until well after lunchtime.
 
user228700
Man, that sounds wonderful.
 
user228700
Read what? SF or Physics?
 
SF
It was relaxation time so I wouldn't have been reading textbooks.
 
user228700
What were ur dorms at Cambridge like?
 
6:30 AM
It's strange, but in some ways I'm more interested in physics now than i was then. When I was an undergrad I didn't do any work outside of set coursework. I guess there were too many other fun things to do.
@Kaumudi.H Very good. I had my own room and the rooms were nice. I spent my last year living in the college in buildings that were 500 years old :-)
 
user228700
No, that's only understandable :-) I don't think I'm going to be spending all my time in college at the library (studying) either.
 
My brother went to university in London, and some of the places he lived were absolutely dreadful. Even the rats had left!
 
user228700
Jeez!
 
user228700
@JohnRennie I've only ever seen this one:
 
user228700
 
user228700
6:33 AM
(Theory of Everything)
 
My room in college didn't have wood panelled walls, and it was bigger than that. I wouldn't say that is typical of the rooms I and my friends lived in.
Sadly, I don't have any pictures from that time.
 
user228700
Ohh, OK. That room looks very nice though, overlooking a square/lawn and all.
 
user228700
I Googled it and this came up:
 
user228700
6:36 AM
And wtf, that looks like a hotel room, not a dorm room! :-o
 
That's one of the more modern rooms, but in terms of size and facilities that's fairly typical.
I guess the rooms were more like hotel rooms than something from Harry Potter.
 
user228700
> something from Harry Potter
 
user228700
That's what I was hoping to find :-P
 
What was special about the college was the feeling of age and permanence. All the buildings around you were hundreds of years old. It wasn't so much the room you lived in as all the buildings around you.
 
user228700
I can completely understand that :-) It certainly looks...quaint and beautiful.
 
user228700
6:41 AM
How often have u gone back to visit the campus?
 
user228700
What the heck, that does look a little like The Great Hall! :-o
 
I think the scenery in HP, the books and the film, were based a bit on Oxford and Cambridge.
@Kaumudi.H I've only been back once. I was visiting Cambridge with some friends and I took them to my college to show them round.
But it felt strange. I think the thing you remember most is your friends, and without them the college just felt like some place i once lived in a long time ago.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Hmm, yes, I can see that :-)
 
user228700
I hope I'm able to visit England (anywhere in England) someday.
 
6:48 AM
You have many decades ahead of you (many more than me anyway :-) so there's plenty of time to visit anywhere you want.
Bearing in mind that the UK is currently desperate to seduce India so it has someone to trade with after Brexit, I'd guess there will be lots of opportunities to visit the UK in the coming years.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Yeah, that's the hope :-)
 
Modi (bless him) has made it very clear that trade deals with the UK will depend on the UK allowing access for Indians. And on this topic I agree with him.
 
user228700
And I know nothing about our relations with other countries that are being established by him so I am not the person to have this conversation with :-P
 
7:35 AM
@JohnRennie good morning to you. You had the chance to read my message?
 
@Sebastiano I thought your question was a reasonable one, and I'm not sure why it has attracted downvotes. I can't answer it because I don't know the answer. Electrodynamics isn't one of the areas I know a lot about.
 
7:51 AM
@JohnRennie Thank you so much for your kind reply. I contacted you because you are a person courteous, but even if it's not your field the subject of electrodynamics I would understand if my question is clear or not, as the comments on the question phrased badly. For me it is clear. If on this site there is someone who feels a genius write it, so I remember.
 
I say let's tar and feather him
 
::crickets::
 
8:24 AM
@Sebastiano The question looks fine to me and I don't think it deserves two downvotes.
@Bernardo I did say I would post that FBD. Does this make sense or should I clarify it?
When you substitute for $F$ and F$_d$ you get $$-mg\ell\sin\theta -C\ell v = +I\ddot\theta$$ and that gives all the correct signs.
 
8:45 AM
@JohnRennie Dayum, that's no FBD that's a work of art!
Bet you made it on proprietary malware though
 
@BernardoMeurer Google Draw
 
Called it :P
 
That's at least quasi-ideallogically sound isn't it?
 
I'll give it a 6/10
Could be Pinta
But yes, the FBD makes sense
 
While I'm, remember:
17 hours ago, by John Rennie
Frakking, frakking, fraketty, francking frak! I've just spilt a pint of beer over my desk, keyboard, mouse, lap, and so on. Ballcocks! :-(
Well:
 
8:48 AM
Hahahaha
lol
 
Nice one
My last keyboard was so crusty you could have a full meal just by licking it
4
 
user228700
Ewwwwwww.
 
^^^^^^^^^
 
The old keyboard I'm using at the moment is pretty dirty. But at least it's my dirt :-)
@BernardoMeurer is Pinta vector graphics?
 
8:53 AM
@JohnRennie Nope, if you want vectors you can try Inkscape
 
@BernardoMeurer I have looked at Inkscape but it's overcomplicated for drawing simple diagrams like that FBD. Google Draw is actually spot on in terms of features vs ease of use.
 
@JohnRennie That is something I can agree with, and it's not a Free Software issue, Vector Graphics tools are darn complicated! I wish there was a vector paint or something
^ I bet people love me
 
user228700
Has anybody wasted time at panpingo.com before?
 
Back in the day I wrote a simple vector graphics app in Vax assembler to run on Tektronix 4010 graphics terminals. It was pretty full featured too.
 
user228700
8:59 AM
It's an online multi-player game in which one person is assigned a word and they're supposed to draw it. The others should guess and the turn to draw keeps rotating.
 
@JohnRennie You're such a badass lol
 
I tried to make a 3D engine for GR once
It's quite hard
 
I went to the bathroom all by myself today
 
Mostly because you're not guaranteed that geodesics will go to the light source
Well, some geodesic will, but you don't know which one
Unless the geodesic equation is perfectly solved
 
You do it in reverse don't you?
 
9:01 AM
So doing it it for an arbitrary metric by numerical simulation is hard
Well the problem is the same if you do it in reverse
Because the problem is that you have a point on a surface
That point must be connected to two things
1) a pixel on the camera
2) a light source
doing camera to surface is easy enough
Doint surface to light source is the hard part
I guess you could just cast all geodesics coming from the light source, but that would be fairly wasteful since most of them won't hit the camera
Of course you could just work on the assumption of even lighting
 
Ballcocks!
 
That simplifies the problem but it's a bit flat
 
I bought a Nexus 9 on eBay. It was listed as spares and repair, so no guarantee, but it seemed to be working fine so I took a risk and bought it.
It turns out it's locked by the google device protection so it is basically an expensive paperweight.
 
Did you just buy a stolen phone?
 
Oh well. You win some and you lose some.
@Slereah Nexus 9 is a tablet not a phone. As to whether it's stolen - I have no idea. It was a reputable ebay vendor not bought in a back sgtreet.
 
9:08 AM
Reputable means he ships his items, not that he's above board :p
 
user228700
@JohnRennie Google device protection?
 
can't you just go to the shop to unlock it
 
user228700
Crap. Isn't there a way to contact the seller?
 
No. The device protection is in the firmware and can't be hacked. To be fair the device protection is a good thing as it deters theft. It means no-one can use your tablet if it's stolen.
@Kaumudi.H I've mailed the seller, but unless it was his own personal tablet I doubt he knows the account details.
 
user228700
9:12 AM
@JohnRennie Why dyou think it might not be his own?
 
But like I say he did advertise the tablet as spares/repair so I can't complain.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie How did he suppose other people were going to be able to use it, then?
 
@JohnRennie Is that a challenge?
 
@Kaumudi.H Most of the well known eBay vendors get stuff from bulk buys like clearances then sell it on as individual items. Kind of the way I get old laptops from my company. The vendor will have no idea who the original owner was.
@Kaumudi.H Apart from the protection the tablet is in good condition, so it could be used for spare parts e.g. to repair a tablet with a broken screen. Actually I could look for a Nexus 9 with a broken screen and use this tablet to repair it.
 
here is an important lesson @JohnRennie
 
user228700
9:15 AM
Hmm, OK...
 
you can always complain
 
@BernardoMeurer well, it obviously can be hacked if you're prepared to spend enough time and money on it. But you need to be able to hack the firmware e.g. desolder the ROM and reprogram it. Not economically feasible.
 
@JohnRennie I was thinking more in the lines of fooling the firmware
 
@Slereah yes, you can always complain but it isn't always justified. In this case I have no justification for a complaint. I could leave negative feedback on the vendor but tat seems a bit childish and vindictive.
@BernardoMeurer I'll put some effort into Googling it, but I suspect I'm on a loser here. Oh well.
At least it has a working charger, though that makes it quite an expensive charger :-)
 
@JohnRennie I think you should be able to crack it specially if it's an older device
 
user228700
9:33 AM
@JohnR: Say, Kodaline?
 
user228700
(I fear I've asked this before though)
 
The band?
 
user228700
Jan 17 at 7:22, by Kaumudi. H
@JohnR: Kodaline?
 
user228700
OK, yeah, no, I've asked before :-P Never mind, then.
 
user228700
@JohnR: BTW, this sounds strangely similar (to me) to Lazarus (in places) and perhaps you'd like it even though it's performed by a "pop band":
 
user228700
 
user228700
And maybe this is a popular song so you already know of it but still...
 
rsync is the proof there is a god
Backing up my music
So ez
 
cool
 
@Kaumudi.H Yes, I've heard the song. Keane were quite big a few years back and their songs were played a lot on the radio. I wouldn't have said it was that similar to Lazarus though. Well, they're both quite melodic but that's as far as it goes.
 
user228700
Hmm, OK. It sounded a bit similar to me in places.
 
9:53 AM
@0celouvsky Thanks, but I'd rather not read GR right now.
it's a nice story nonetheless
 
Have you done any SR?
 
No. I don't plan to right now.
 
@Kaumudi.H With individual songs you get some similarities. But overall Porcupine Tree are very, very different to Keane. I quite like Keane (though not enough to buy any of their albums) but they are basically a but superficial while PT are into the deep and meaningful vibe.
 
SR isn't too interesting but it has all those fun paradoxes you can use to quizz yourself :p
 
user228700
Yes, I do agree that overall, PT are completely different.
 
I suppose this isn't the "cool Lazarus" we are talking of? :P
 
user228700
@JohnRennie I've looked it up before and every interpretation of it involves Christianity. Is that the way u interpret it as well?
 
SR can be covered in high school.
At least the basics.
 
@Kaumudi.H I doubt it. I suspect Steven Wilson fell asleep on the train and had a dream, and the song is about that dream.
As far as I know Steven Wilson isn't a Christian.
 
user228700
"My David don't you worry, this cold world is not for you. So rest your head upon me, I have the strength to carry you" ...
 
10:11 AM
@Kaumudi.H It's easy to come with ideas for interpretations, but only Steven Wilson knows for sure and he isn't telling. I agree that Lazarus is an obvious biblical reference, but it's used so commonly that it doesn't necessarily have religious connotations.
But the first few lines make it obvious the narrator is ona train, leaning against the window and watching the world go by.
 
user228700
Hmm, wokay. Then again, I'm of the opinion that to a certian extent, authorial intent is sort of overrated so I'mma interpret it in whatever way I'd like to; I sort of think both--the train and the Jesus thing.
 
user228700
(If you're wondering, I'm sort of deleting a lot of old songs that I never listen to anymore from my playlist, which is why I keep bringing up songs)
 
user228700
After all this deleting, I'm afraid the number will fall from close to 350 to about 250 .__.
 
I'm sure Steven Wilson's view would be that if his songs have a personal meaning for you then that's great.
 
user228700
 
user228700
10:18 AM
Oh God... (And I'm not even done yet)
 
@Kaumudi.H though as a way of avoiding doing any real work it is excellent :-)
 
user228700
@JohnRennie :-P No no, this is real work, I promise :-P
 
Yes, yes :-)
 
 
1 hour later…
11:36 AM
@RobertFrost: sorry it has taken me so long to get back to you. A beer on desk spill intervened! Anyhow, Gödel wasn't arguing that time doesn't exist, he was arguing that the flow of time doesn't exist.
 
HQ question, I suggest a reopen vote after edit:
2
Q: Localization and supersymmetry explanation

qm-arvI'm confused about section 9.3 of the book Mirror Symmetry. In particular, I'm confused about the derivation carried out in equations (9.32) to (9.35) where they claim that the partition function is zero if $h'$ has no zeroes. Specifically, consider a 0-dimensional QFT with fermionic and bosonic...

 
@RobertFrost This is basically the idea of eternalism, also known as the block universe.
@RobertFrost the problem with this is that there is no way it can be proved from physical principles, which is why I said it was philosophy not physics. The argument is that the human perception of the flow of time is an artefact of the way our brains work - well how would you prove that?
@RobertFrost In fact I suspect most physicists agree with Gödel that time doesn't really flow. That is certainly how I see it. But it's important to remember that there can be no physical proof of the idea.
 
@JohnRennie I suspect most physicists rather think that the question of whether "time" "flows" is a weird question better left to philosophers ;)
 
:-) Those pesky philosophers!
But having gone to the trouble of rereading Yourgrau's book (which is very dull) to check, I thought I'd make the point just for the record.
 
11:55 AM
Deep questions.
 
@skillpatrol Pointless questions :-)
 
Pointlessly deep?
or
Deeply pointless?
:-/
 

« first day (2347 days earlier)      last day (2585 days later) »