« first day (22 days earlier)      last day (5313 days later) » 

06:12
I'm bahack!
06:35
The Pokemon your Pokemon could battle like.
awesome :D
07:27
our close votes were reverted?
were they? at least we got less
that's what I meant, sorry
the increase we got was reverted
yeah I have a feeling one of the mods didn't agree with our closing spree
yup, as I expected, I just hope that they'll start a meta discussion about it, if they disagree
 
4 hours later…
11:21
0
Q: Good multiplayer games for PS3

ozkeHi, My friends and I are talking about buying the same couple of games to play online. Any recommendation on the best ones out there for that purpose? A part from Call of Duty saga and Little Big Planet. Thanks in advance :)

 
1 hour later…
12:42
Morning @JuanManuel
Downvoter
Good morning
morning
didn't think we needed our 20 close votes anymore? ;-)
Downvoter
lol
Or erm, should be allowed :P
Downvoter
12:43
the need was no longer there IMO
Downvoter
it was unbalanced with the rest of the sites
you're probably right, since we can now let you do it for us :P
Downvoter
sure, we didn't have mods when we requested it
indeed
not too many complaints about our closing spree so far ^^
Downvoter
nope
Downvoter
12:45
it's kinda sad to look at the highest voted questions list and see them closed, but so be it :)
well I would even go as far as to delete them if there comes no further discussion, just so they don't even stick around as a legacy
plus you can always undelete it
Downvoter
perhaps it's better to let them undeleted and point to them when new users complain about their question getting close
Downvoter
and perhaps close new ones as duplicate of some of those
well they're often not a dupe, you can freely say: close as off-topic/not a real question
and point that we do not want to encourage them any more
I agree though that it might be useful to use them as an example
12
Q: Popularity Contest

FarseekerYes, I know it's too late to get in for the prizes ('sif this would win anything anyway) but hey, for the betterment of the community :) Screenshot / Code Snippet About I've (and others) been bugging about getting some stats so we can track our Stack Exchange sites against the others, so I m...

interesting graphs :)
Downvoter
nice
Downvoter
12:56
why haven't you closed this one yet?
Downvoter
0
Q: Good multiplayer games for PS3

ozkeHi, My friends and I are talking about buying the same couple of games to play online. Any recommendation on the best ones out there for that purpose? A part from Call of Duty saga and Little Big Planet. Thanks in advance :)

Downvoter
:)
because now it only needs one more vote
I wasn't sure at first
ok I didn't vote to close this new one
but he does need to edit it, else I will vote to close it
Downvoter
13:02
yes, it's not an inappropriate question, but it's poorly defined
Downvoter
Let's try to be a little less trigger happy! :P
heej I commented with suggestions!
Downvoter
I saw, that's great
plus you robbed me of my overflow votes anyway ;-) hehe
Downvoter
are you out already?
13:04
no no! but I save them for the really bad ones
and I actually think it's a legitimate topic, but the quality needs to improve (of the answers as well!)
13:17
sigh why do so many questions need a comment to make them explain themselves more
most people aren't good at asking questions honestly
they're not organized in their thoughts
13:45
25
Q: Good websites for Game Reviews

Mehper C. PalavuzlarWhich site should I have in my bookmarks to read game reviews before buying a game? 1 site per answer, please.

What's going on with this one? It's about as subjective as anything else we've closed.
I already said yesterday: I'd say close it
just put my vote down
I won't have rep left if they delete it though ^^
oh wait its CW
kill it!
14:23
1
Q: Are there plugins/addons for dwarf fortress graphics?

Mechko Possible Duplicate: Dwarf Fortress Character and Graphics Sets Call me a pansy, but I can't deal with ascii graphics for too long. This means that my dwarf fortress playing time is limited. Is there any way to change the output to be more colorful and less ascii?

dupe
omg 3 vote to close votes in 5 mins :P
that's what I use ze chat for :D
hehe well people seem to want to keep the review question then
though I agree, by my guidelines I assume it shouldn't be around
yeah, I don't agree with closing it, if we wanted to we should've closed it a long time ago imo
14:25
it would be useful to have at least one answer point to gametrailers.com though ;-)
you have, right? :P
well we waited way too long getting our act together @ArdaXi so I don't think that time should matter for closing it or not
only just noticed the new meta link, nice
25
Q: Good websites for Game Reviews

Mehper C. PalavuzlarWhich site should I have in my bookmarks to read game reviews before buying a game? 1 site per answer, please.

I agree, but we should factor in the amount of upvotes/favs in closing
14:27
check the first one @ArdaXi :P
hell no, people will just upvote/fav any question so we won't close it
I prefer Metacritic over Gametrailers
maybe, but this is a pretty good question
I don't care about other people's opinion, I want to see it myself
you want reviews, you want someone else's opinion :P
I prefer not to have to read millions of reviews to get an average, which is why I like meta
Starcraft 2's rating dropped because a couple of sites just don't like having something do SCI better
check the bottom one's on metacritic
it has a score of 94
14:30
which isn't 10
aye
so?
the amount of reviews they use makes one or two bad reviews not matter so much
besides, the lowest grade is 75
wow, thats 7.5 times 10!
it's almost over 9000!
did you think it deserved a 10 then?
I've only played the beta :P
kept me from anything useful for a lot of nights
10/100 is a pretty crappy score
I don't generally like over-hyped games
14:34
you can ignore the hype, just go play other games
I don't actually play a lot of games anymore
I mostly answer questions about them :)
sounds awfully familiar
now I'm off to drop some stuff, so later everyone :)
later
 
1 hour later…
Downvoter
15:43
Is linking to this sites a problem? (I ask because I don't know):
Yeah, it is
oh no
scratch that
they seem to not link to NDS roms because of legal issues
but they link to NES roms
both answers to that question are illegal, and don't answer the question
Downvoter
So they should be deleted? I claim ignorance... could you flag them for mod attention and explain it?
Downvoter
why are roms illegal?
because they're copyrighted material
under US law you're not allowed to host them
15:47
Roms are only legal if you yourself own the game, I think
Then again, I'm no law student
and even then, you have to make the backups yourself
you can't download them
explains it pretty well: "Therefore, whether you have an authentic game or not, or whether you have possession of a Nintendo ROM for a limited amount of time, i.e. 24 hours, it is illegal to download and play a Nintendo ROM from the Internet."
Downvoter
great
Downvoter
thanks
that doesn't devalue the question by the way
does a company telling you something is illegal make it illegal?
15:50
making these backup copies yourself and not distributing them is legal
I doubt Nintendo is lying, @antonytrupe
I can cite the DMCA regulations if you wish, but Nintendo's language is more clear
or is it their interpretation of the law?
not saying nintendo is wrong, just that it may not carry _that_ much weight
no need, just playing devil's advocate
Downvoter
I deleted them preemptively, they can be undeleted if necessary (after discussion in meta)
as far as I understand the law (IANAL and I am not American) what Nintendo says is accurate
@JuanManuel Consensus on legal matters is that we just shouldn't bother with questions directly about emulators
added a clarifying comment to the question
I love the email address Nintendo uses: [email protected]
Good Morning
Downvoter
We have 1337 questions
Downvoter
15:57
nobody ask anything!
don't worry, we've a couple questions up for deletion anyway ;-)
someone screenshot it!
16:29
beautiful
maybe that should be our site name ... 1337answers
2
apparently the chat engine doesn't recognise images without the proper extension
that makes sense
PS3 question off topic?
maybe
it's not really about games, other than that the PS3 is a gaming console
oooh, big nasty list
14
Q: Gaming quotes and memes that have made their way into the real world?

MechkoI know the quote "The Cake is a lie" has made its way into the real world because I've heard non-gamers say it in an attempt to be cryptic. Are there any other quotes or memes like that which have come into common parlance after being coined in the gaming world? EDIT: I would suggest the word ...

17:29
dum de dum
hey
it's funny how most of the questions on StackExchange's hot list are questions we'd summarily close :D
We'd probably kill this one with fire :P
that's true for SO too
60
Q: What is your most-used web application?

nevsterWhat is your most-used web application? Fairly straightforward question. It shouldn't be too hard to guess what will come out on top, but I'm interested to see what else gets high votes. ONE entry per post and NO duplicates. The following applications have already been listed. Gmail Google Rea...

17:36
HELLISH FIRE
I think they can be more tolerant of that kind of stuff because they have a more specialized audiance
we have the problem in that, everyone plays games, but few people are experts
they have a smaller pool to draw from, but a higher average expertise
yeah, nobody uses Facebook or GMail...
Although most of SO's top ones are locked. (Closed + no votes/comments) stackoverflow.com/questions?sort=votes
although I'm quite happy about our facebook games throughput
or lack thereof
Oh, they killed it with fire too :P
"locked by phwd♦ 4 hours ago"
17:45
Don't use Battle.net voice chat!
Problem solved!
the betas confuse me, I keep thinking 'any random beta' is Gaming
I don't know why they're all 'B'
I guess it'd get problematic quick to have site-specific favicons
Gm / GD / WA / ... then what about GIS? blech.
1
Q: Will there be a re-skinning of this stackexchange site when it comes out of beta?

joeThe design of gaming.stackexchange.com seems to be more like a schoolwork or homework type design. What does this have to do with gaming? Is this just temporary?

what , seriously?
I'd be waiting for a site with the acronym FU :P
Answered :P
Ha! Feedbot is late :P
@Macha you can link to this also
9
A: Will all Stack Exchange sites look the same?

Robert CartainoThat is the "Sketchy" beta theme for all beta sites. When a site makes it out of beta, they will choose their own logo and design. So, before anyone asks... sorry, no. You can't keep the Sketchy design for your site after launch <grin>.

17:57
@Noctrine Added
18:11
this question confuses me
seems obvious to me
1
Q: What differentiates a "Game Design/Development" question from a question that belongs on this site?

Grace NoteGame design and development questions are considered off-topic, and should be asked on the corresponding Stack Exchange sister site. But what defines a question as being about game development? How do I know where to ask my questions about consoles and mechanics?

bye
Oak
18:34
Boo
boo who?
is <kb> not the correct html for keys?
I thought it was
Oak
<kbd>
kbd maybe
Oak
18:37
Let's see if it works here... <kbd>F5</kbd>
Oak
Well, it works in the actual sites.
yeah
its kbd
for some reason I thought it was kb
I guess they pre-prevented abuse of kbd here :p
how could it be abused more here then on the SE sites?
Oak
I'm not sure how it can be abused at all
18:46
I kind of wanted to do abuse but I didn't think about it until just now. Lemme find it.
any idea why it doesn't work here by the way?
3
A: Map a key to switch between my favorite weapons for each class?

Arda XiBy default Q should switch between your last used weapons. So if you first use your flame-thrower and then your axe Q should first switch back to the flame-thrower and then back to the axe again.

Jeff called my kbd usage abuse a few weeks ago
it has since been corrected
24
Q: <kbd> elements are way intrusive

Paul Fisher<kbd> is a great way to mark up text to be entered. But when you use it on StackOverflow-family sites, it's really difficult. For instance, if I say I typed this sentence by starting with a Shift+F, then used o, followed by r, then space, you can see that it quickly becomes an unreadable me...

ah, a typo
@noctrine that's an awesome set of answers
Oak
18:53
Aww man my question was closed :(
Oak
*blush*
which was that?
5
Q: Tower defense games where you build a maze

OakMy favorite tower defense game I know is Desktop Tower Defense. Yes, it's a flash game. Yes, it has a (less-balanced) facebook version. But it's simple, fun, and is one of the few tower defense games where you really get to build your own maze, rather than just place towers around a pre-built maz...

right
Oak
Yep
18:54
now I want that geodefence game
Oak
In my eyes it was specific enough - but I guess I was wrong
Oak
Oh well
Downvoter
We should ban the ones that closed your question @Oak
Downvoter
is 1 year enough for you?
Oak
I don't know, what's the maximum value on that slider?
18:58
can you ban diamond mods?
Oak
Only one way to find out ;-)
Downvoter
what are you doi--
I'm bahack
Downvoter
[disconnected]
Oak
19:00
It would have been more impressive if your avatar on the top-right would burst in flame or something
Oak
We should ask for that feature on meta.
sorry, I don't use old spice @Oak
Oak
I... don't know what that means
"The mod is now Diamond!"
19:03
hehe
@badp I suggested to have closed questions removed from the StackExchange list, since we shouldn't advertise those
Oak
@Ivo 100% agree
@Ivo I'll add it to metaa
4
A: Suggest a domain name for this site

C. Ross1337Answers.com Not taken (whois). To be pronounced "Leet Answers"

I'm only voting for it as long as it's not the highest voted answer
19:15
so, any good close targets?
Downvoter
+1 to the domain name
very few of these say gaming QA to me....
I love it
they don't have to @tzenes
I dunno, SuperUser is a good one, because its not only a level of access control but it also implies that this is a site for power users, people who really push their computers
Stackoverflow actually has a story behind it, they wanted people searching for the term "stackoverflow" to find it because those are programmers and usually ones who need expert help
we will pop up with Google because of our content
19:28
I imagine Serverfault was designed similairly
I agree
I have super user questions popping up when searching for answers too
but none of that is the point
SO was the first which is why the name is unique in that way
I think SU is an example of a good name
I'd suggest ProGammers, if it didn't connote discussion about becoming a professional gamer
which isn't what the site is about
too bad GameFAQs is taken, that's a good one
what do you think of:
7
Q: What are good sources for Starcraft 2 replays?

Łukasz LewThere are so many replay sites, and so many of them are useless. So many replays and replay packs are on megaupload-like sites and submitted only to some forums. What is the best way of searching for replays of good players? Edit: 1. If you want to post a replay site, make one post per site. 2....

what's the problem he wants an answer to?
I'm not sure ... it's listy ...
oeh a killing spree! :D
voted to close
19:44
5
Q: Suitable kid and family games for PS3?

SimI have just got a PS3 as part of a Sony TV promotion and am looking for some suitable kid friendly game recommendations for an 8 year-old boy and a 10 year old girl. I have got them Lego Star Wars and Indiana Jones and Little Big Planet but I'm interested in others or recommendations on places t...

1
Q: Where can I find good deals for games?

JeffreyWhere can I find good deals on games, either PC or console? Regular retail stores seem to charge so much!

good catch @antony
6
Q: Good typing games

146I'm looking for the best games in which typing is the core game mechanic. Flash, console, etc., the key component I'm looking for is mainly just amusement, and not necessarily educational. For example, Mario Teaches Typing could be one example, but is not the most fun in the world to play.

kill it dead! we're not here for shopping advices
hehe kill that one too, then I can't vote anymore :P
start asking a question with the title "what are some good games" and look for unclosed questions
really?
http://gaming.stackexchange.com/questions/2651/good-shops-for-game-soundtracks
is the vote to close cap a sliding window?
4
Q: How to find the better games on xbox live arcade?

dryeWith so many games on xbox live arcade, how can I identify the better games or more popular games from the duds?

what's the number under the icons on the left mean?
19:54
what do you mean with a sliding window?
what icon on the left? I see a 4, which means the number of upvotes
in chat
maybe he means meta rep?
I've got 273
meta rep
c.ross has 2743
19:55
someta
mine sucks
when do you get more close-votes?
when they reset, approximately 4 hours from now
you don't get more than 12 @antonytrupe
19:57
I thought I remember having 20 last night
20 on gaming b/c of special request and our "hunts"
11
Q: We need more close votes

Juan ManuelNow that we're trying to course correct the site to Q&A, we need to close many subjective and offtopic questions, which makes the 12 close votes not enough. Could we have more until we have moderators at least? It can be done for > 1K rep users only, and I'd be ok for it to be temporary (ag...

to be more precise
4
A: We need more close votes

Grace NoteThis has now been implemented, announced earlier today in chat. Those with the ability to close can now cast 20 votes per day. edit: due to request, this has been reverted to 12.


« first day (22 days earlier)      last day (5313 days later) »