« first day (1750 days earlier)      last day (3359 days later) » 

14:59
What should we do when the source of a claim misrepresents its attribution.
In the question about black scientists, Vice says that "Scalia contends..." Which if you read the transcript you can see he doesnt
He says those things but in the context of a hypothetical or at least simply assuming the position of one of the briefs
He says maybe... Maybe... And that it "doesn't stand to reason that..."
15:26
Okay. Tried to fix things up!
Seems more careful in attribution now
 
2 hours later…
17:20
FYI, these are the three amicus briefs that put forward the argument relating to how the lowering of academic admission standards in order to admit more minority candidates could result in a counter-intuitive effect... an increasing mismatch across all-tiers of schools between the academic capability of the minority admissions and the mean academic capability at the school
The typical claim is:
> In “competition mismatch”, students receiving
large preferences are at a competitive
disadvantage, tend to receive lower grades,
and become academically discouraged, which
can lead to switching to a less competitive field
of study or dropping out of school. A common
example of “competition mismatch” occurs in
the sciences at selective schools.19 Students
with an interest in science who are admitted
to a very competitive school via a large
preference tend to drop out of the sciences at a
much higher rate than do otherwise similar
The reason this comes up in this argument is because for any racial admission preference to be constitutional there needs to be a compelling interest. U of Texas argues that the compelling interest is increased diversity, but these briefs argue that this method of increasing diversity can ultimately have negative effects.
18:03
I'm not quite sure what the legal point is to that though...
0
Q: Can implied allegations be referenced without direct notability?

dsollenThere are a number of very common implications I hear often that I may want to ask a question on, but which are just indirect enough to be a little harder to find quotes for. I'm wondering at what point are they common enough to not need to provide notability for. To give examples, since I don'...


« first day (1750 days earlier)      last day (3359 days later) »