« first day (1565 days earlier)      last day (1971 days later) » 

AIQ
AIQ
18:55
Hi all, there is a question that seemed to me as "off-topic" as it could be easily answered by a google search. But now it has 14 upvotes and the accepted answer has 35 upvotes. I am not complaining about the question or the answers. If it has that much positive feedback, then may be I was wrong to have thought it was off-topic. Here is the link: ell.stackexchange.com/questions/226370/what-does-ikea-like-mean
My issue with the question is that OP did not google what IKEA is. If they had they would know (the first link in google shows what IKEA is). Rather they might have thought it was a verb or something and went on to find definitions. I don't know how to elaborate. OP's question is "I found the text below in a website and I'm trying to understand the meaning of IKEA in the context" and their title was "What does IKEA mean?" (before being edited by another user).
So clearly OP was not asking about what the whole thing meant, just what IKEA was. I thought this had nothing to do with learning English language. Can someone tell me what is wrong with my reasoning?
AIQ
AIQ
19:20
I am certain I will get lambasted for this. The highest voted answer (the accepted answer) that has 35 votes wrote the following: IKEA is just the brand name, or business name, of a global business; it's a name just like "Apple" or "Google" or "John's Grocery Store".
... continued A person who founds a business can give it any name they want (so long as no-one else legally controls that name). The founder of IKEA was a Swedish businessman called Ingvar Kamprad. He made up the name by using his own initials (i.e. the initial letters of his first and last name) and then adding on the first letter of the farm where he grew up (Elmtaryd) and then the first letter of his home town (Agunnaryd). Hence, the made-up name is "I-K-E-A".
That seems more like a "history" lesson than solving an English Language problem. I am really, really confused. Can someone please tell me why I am wrong to say this is off-topic?
 
3 hours later…
Anonymous
21:59
@AIQ First of all, you shouldn't have to worry about being "lambasted". It's true that not everyone might agree with you, but it's perfectly fine for different users to hold and express different opinions. You're perfectly welcome to express ideas like this.
Anonymous
That said, I'm not sure I really agree that it's off-topic.
Anonymous
They did look up what IKEA means, it seems:
Anonymous
> I found these two definitions for it:

> IKEA Ingvar Kamprad Elmtaryd Agunnaryd (Swedish home furnishings retailer; derived from founder's initials and hometown)
Anonymous
But they failed to mentally connect the dots:
Anonymous
> ...but none of them seems to make any sense to me.
Anonymous
22:01
Now, arguably the OP should be able to put in a little more mental work and find a way from point A to point B, but the fact of the matter is they didn't quite get there on their own, so they decided to ask what the phrase meant.
Anonymous
It might seem easy to make the connection for you or me, but it might be harder for them. It depends on the learner. When you're struggling to understand a second language, sometimes everything can seem a little overwhelming and it can be harder because you're cognitively overloaded.
Anonymous
They could have researched IKEA further and found out they're famous for their IKEA-style manuals, which come with parts you have to assemble into furniture yourself, and then they would have understood what "IKEA-like" meant in that context.
Anonymous
So I grant they could have done more research effort.
Anonymous
But at its core, it's a question about language. They want to know what a word ("IKEA-like") means in a given context, and whether you could expect them to be able to solve it on their own or not, the fact is that they're having trouble with it, and this is a place you can ask when you have that sort of problem.
Anonymous
So I don't believe it should be closed as off-topic.

« first day (1565 days earlier)      last day (1971 days later) »