CURED - 2023-09-19

« first day (4268 days earlier) ← previous day next day → last day (525 days later) »

Bill Dubuque

01:31

Dv incomprehensible very long brute-force computer-generated proof

^^^ another answer there also deserves DVs (see the comment) since it is very far from a proof (makes only a trivial inference, in a roundabout way). Both already have 5 DVs. They deserve more.

3 hours later…

Bill Dubuque

05:05

^^^ sadly the above 243 line computer proof (vs < 10 line human proofs there) has passed review. It is hard to imagine how that answer could be useful to any (human) reader.

5 hours later…

ryang

10:26

pls close math.stackexchange.com/q/4770814/21813 as a dupe of math.stackexchange.com/q/4771523/21813. (The OP had meant to edit the former, but instead ended up creating a new post.)

1 hour later…

Peter

11:29

@BillDubuque received seven upvotes (!) Do the people even read what they upvote/accept ?

Martin R

11:42

→ 1 message moved to Trash

@amWhy I have taken the liberty to move that message to the Trash, so that it can not cause more confusion here.

3 hours later…

KReiser

14:55

dv + delete: this does not answer the question, and it keeps getting bumped because it's of score 0.

Xander Henderson

15:26

cv-pls probability This didn't get closed during the strike, and just got an answer. It probably should have been closed. In MTG Arena Jump In! Events, How do I maximize my long term rare/mythic rewards?‭ - MathDummy‭ 2023-06-29 22:17:39Z

3 hours later…

José Carlos Santos

18:43

@Peter @BillDubuque Believe it or not, it got an eighth upvote.

2 hours later…

Peter

20:34

@JoséCarlosSantos Also consider the comments , as I said , we need much more helpers to be able to change anything.

2 hours later…

Bill Dubuque

22:09

@JoséCarlosSantos Likely the new comments explain the upvote (compare my reply). I don't think we should allow such incomprehensible answers merely to satisfy curiosity about computer generated proofs. Such answers should be judged by the same standard as human proofs - which are required to be comprehensible by humans.