« first day (2262 days earlier)      last day (2216 days later) » 

2:58 AM
This user asks a lot of PSQs, and one wonders about the avatar...
 
 
3 hours later…
Did
6:18 AM
@XanderHenderson Same here.
 
 
4 hours later…
10:12 AM
@Did @XanderHenderson @amWhy @ZacharySelk: I think you all would be thoroughly amused by this article by Underwood Dudley.
2
> One trisector in Ohio refused to send me his construction because he thought that the trisection was worth money and he was afraid that I would steal it. For revenge, I put him in tough with a trisector in Texas, but as revenge it was not successful: they corresponded and each concluded that the other was not making sense.
 
10:26 AM
Accordingly, there was a trisector that had a testimonial from a professor of mathematics at a real university stating to have carefully checked and found no fallacy. And another, who also claimed to be able to duplicate a cube and prove Euclid's fifth postulate, was a president at an otherwise respectable university. This is totally astounding.
 
Did
10:50 AM
@user21820 The article is excellent. (Unfortunately, I knew it already, but thanks anyway.)
 
@Did Crankology is a relatively new field to me. =P
 
Did
@user21820 If you happen to be a member of the Editorial board of any reputable journal of mathematics, you are bound to see such examples regularly pass by you... Rule number 1 is to never engage them about the content of their "paper": they have vastly more time and energy to spend on the matter than you. And any answer they receive, however damning, is seen as a badge of honor: "See, my work is discussed by established mathematicians..."
 
Hahaha!
I suddenly wondered whether it would be amusing to regularly publish a tiny article in a reputable mathematics journal along the lines of "In the past X months, Y cranks have sent in their futile attempts to trisect an angle. The least bad attempt has an error of Z degrees when tested." (And of course, never mention any of their names or attempts.)
 
 
4 hours later…
2:35 PM
On the topic of cranks, there is also the famous Baez Crackpot Index.
 
@Did @amWhy @ZacharySelk @XanderHenderson: This is not an answer.
 
@user21820 No, no it isn't. But the answer right below that cites my academic uncle, so I get to upvote that :)
 
@XanderHenderson Academic uncle is a new one.
 
A collaborator of my advisor's?
Maybe "uncle" is too close...
Uncle should more precisely be a student of my advisor's advisor, I guess
This borders on a link-only answer; it isn't quite, but I can't parse it (even with the addition of paragraph breaks)
 
 
1 hour later…
3:54 PM
@XanderHenderson This is an interesting crank. Not only is the poster linking to his own 'paper', it seems useless, and his twitter account makes him look at bit like mathematicsaminphysics.
 
 
2 hours later…
user131753
5:55 PM
@user21820 I think you overuse the word "crank".
 
This PSQ needs to be closed. Ditto for this PSQ from same user.
 
6:22 PM
Just in case others haven't yet noticed Robert Frost's user-name change, they are now aptly named Producer of BS
 
Sigh...
 
@user170039 And I think you're overly critical of @user21820.
3
 
6:44 PM
How does this answer have two upvotes 10 seconds after posting?!
 
It starts with hint:, so it must be gr8, innit?
 
Of course.
 
Several PSQs by a new user, including this one math.stackexchange.com/questions/2705237/…
 
@XanderHenderson, @Did, @user21820, @ZacharySelk In relation to Xander's last link, the same author authored this and this, same pattern: equation + "I can't do it", are open for closure.
 
They are closed
and now open for deletion
 
6:59 PM
[ SmokeDetector | MS ] Offensive answer detected: Problem with construction by arrals on math.SE
 
@XanderHenderson Yes, I should have written "open for deletion".
 
@CarlMummert Thanks for the link...
 
Hrm... I just got two randomly downvoted answers :\
 
@XanderHenderson: it's always surprising to me the number of people who think that the vote on an answer somehow reflects on the answerer rather than just on the specific answer
Or the number who think one person can significant affect someone else's rep by voting
 
7:12 PM
They are both answers to pretty marginal questions, so I'm not really that worried about it.
Though there is a downvote that I got a couple of days ago that makes me kind of sad. :'(
I think that this is a pretty good answer. ;)
 
@XanderHenderson I've been getting anywhere from 1 - 3 downvotes a day, lately. Flag them. Or ask @quid in the mod's chat.
 
it doesn't look like a pattern yet; but if it continues I'll likely ping a mod
I'm just griping for the sake of griping
also: it is possible to flag a vote?!
 
There have been quite a few repeat offenders, come back with new accounts. @quid is trying to look for patterns. In any case, @Xander, keep it in mind. Yes, it is possible to flag a vote, by flagging the answer which was downvoted.
 
huh; I didn't think of doing that
thanks
PSQ, needs one more vote to close
 
7:29 PM
Already cast mine, @XanderHenderson
 
@XanderHenderson it can be helpful to do this. But needless to say please do not flag each and every vote. The one on the highly voted one looks odd though, I agree. That said, we cannot do much about a single vote. But if a pattern emerges action can be taken.
 
As I said, I have no plans of causing a ruckus unless it starts looking like a pattern. I was just griping.
Thanks, @quid
 
8:05 PM
[ SmokeDetector | MS ] Blacklisted user: Continuity of rational functions by arrals on math.SE
 
9:04 PM
Hi, Robert Frost!
 
PSQ up for closure; note the rep this OP has acquired asking simply PSQs
 
9:58 PM
A moderator answered the question, then, when it was pointed out that it is a competition question, modified their answer, but seems to have done nothing further to deal with the question. :\
2
 
@XanderHenderson: indeed, but there are things that other people could do, like vote down and vote to close.
 
I downvoted and flagged :/
so, hopefully, it will ultimately get dealt with
oh, my flagging doesn't count as a vote to close; derp
 
I suspect you can still just vote to close, like I did. Actually it is worth looking through the other questions by that account, I think there are several PSQ questions there.
 

« first day (2262 days earlier)      last day (2216 days later) »