Hinduism

12:50 AM

0

Which s it better the reading of the multitude of scriptures from different schools of Hindu thought whose aim is to show you the way to self realization Moksha, Brahman, or direct communication with Lord Krishna?

TheLittleNaruto

6:01 AM

@NogShine lol

Nog Shine

@TheLittleNaruto Enough sarcasm.. there is a limit.

Hinduism bot

-1

Q: Does doing Pithru Tharpana in Kasi and Rameswaram reduces evil effects to the doer?

Legend says that doing pithru tharpana in kasi and from there directly going to Rameswaram and performing the pithru tharpana is good and it reduces evil effects to the doer. Any substantiative evidence for this??

pithru kasi rameswaram

0

Q: Is the Divine Body of Krishna beyond Nirguna and Sarguna ?

The phenomenal and celestial realms are are filled with the constant ebb and flow of the gunas sattva, rajas and tamas. Is the Divine Body of Krishna made from gunas or is he in these realms but not of these realms ?

krishna gunas

TheLittleNaruto

@Hinduismbot Good! Finally you started learning how to ask a question.

Nog Shine

6:27 AM

@TheLittleNaruto You should read the question properly before changing title and body. Don't use short forms

@Pandya I voted to close. OP haven't improved after asking to modify.

SwiftPushkar

6:41 AM

@Pandya - Namaste , Yes ,even i wasn't much aware about him or read his commentary before ,but i think he was associated with arya samaj ,he originally is from kokan (coastal) region of Maharashtra.And he also has written bhashya on Atharva-Veda .He is much talked about here.

@Pandya en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shripad_Damodar_Satwalekar

@Pandya -Also commentary on Mahabharata.😯

archive.org/details/…

archive.org/…;

@Pandya - Mahabharata - archive.org/details/…

@Pandya - Yes sayana commentary will be more interesting to read , lot's of hidden gems will be there. H.H. Wilson translation is also based on sayana Bhashya , so do check that before.👍👍

archive.org/details/RigVedaSanhitaByHHWilsonVol6

7 volumes.

@Pandya - BTW welcome to 10k club , but there is nothing much interesting here as you are enjoying much more previlages than members. You are the head of 10k club 😀

baby welcome @NogShine

Baby Be'el

7:01 AM

@@NogShine Welcome to the Hinduism chatroom!If you have a question, just post it, and if anyone's free and interested they'll help. If you want to report an abusive user or a problem in this room, ping TheLittleNaruto.

SwiftPushkar

@NogShine Hiii

Nog Shine

@SwiftPushkar hello

SwiftPushkar

@NogShine Yup , just wait..pls.

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer I started typing the comment after 6 minutes you have posted so that the grace period ends. I didn't see the edit till then. After I posted, it changed. It is better to post a new one after 5 minutes grace period.

The Destroyer

@NogShine Should i post you screenshot?

I edited immediately. No one would post Bhavan it's typo

Nog Shine

7:14 AM

@TheDestroyer Why would i say Bhavan if I saw Bhagavan?

You first posted Bhavan and then might have edited immediately.

The Destroyer

Now

see time differences

Nog Shine

28 secs ago, by Nog Shine

You first posted Bhavan and then might have edited immediately.

The Destroyer

Probably you missed edit

And i edited within 2minutes

@TheDestroyer I didn't say Bhavan. "Namaste Astu Bhavagaha" doesn't exist. Bhagavah is not correct. It should be Bhagavan afaik. Can you post complete mantra you are saying? I am saying about this. Aren't you saying the same? Bhagavan is used to denote the supreme Brahman and not translated in the above verses.Bhagavan. Many (irrespective of sect) use Bhagavan to call god or supreme brahman and not just fortunate one. — Sarvabhouma 18 mins ago

This comment is obsolete

And i didn't misuse edit privileges

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer Using editing privilege like cases like this makes the next comment obsolete or confusing to the readers. It's better to post a new comment. I waited for the grace period to end and posted the comment. You first posted bhavan and then changed to Bhagavan. — Sarvabhouma 15 mins ago

@TheDestroyer That is what I said.

The Destroyer

All other comments are obsolete.

@NogShine It's not privilege. It is within grace period.

See time differences

see above pics

Nog Shine

7:20 AM

@TheDestroyer Editing too much will make the next comments obsolete or confusing. Not complete comment is obsolete. I am not saying to target you. I started typing the comment after 6 minutes only.

The comment is still showing "Bhavagaha" after edits.. you missed that one.

The Destroyer

@NogShine Come on man! Can't you see time gap? I edited within 2 minutes and you said you started after 6 minutes then you should have seen again

@NogShine I didn't edit that. Kept it as bhagavaha

Edited within 2 min

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer I didn't see the changes because I'm on same page. I thought of taking screenshot but didn't.

The Destroyer

@NogShine then how's that my mistake? what would you do if some other user does that?

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer You missed that while editing. It is still showing bhavagah.

The Destroyer

@NogShine See, what's you point? What do you want to prove? This is always problem while discussing with you. why do you prolong conversation when it is clear?

Nog Shine

7:26 AM

@TheDestroyer What other user? No other user can't edit comments after 5 minutes... As I said, I waited for grace period to end. The history didn't load after your revisions. It is due to cache.

The Destroyer

@NogShine Did i edit after 5 minutes?

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer Remove the prejudice and wait for others to reply. Don't post your version and leave like that in the middle of conversation. Listen what others have to say. You don't understand what I mean to say. You didn't edit the typo "Bhavagah" to "Bhagavah" even after the edits. You said comments are obsolete, I am saying it's not. Do you understand now?

The Destroyer

Can't see time gap 25 24 23

see screenshot again

Just prolong conversation for sake of discussing.

I have cleared it with screenshots. I think there's no need of any further explanations.

There's 9 minute gap or even 3 minutes gap when you started comment. So, you didn't see my edited comment which was edited withing grace period.

Nog Shine

Do you see typo "Bhavagah" in the comment? I am trying to say that you have made typo in the comment. Why do you think I am prolonging discussion and see other meanings which I don't intend?

The Destroyer

@NogShine Where didn't i edit? Comment is obsolete. ha to h..that's it. Rest or 99% comment is obsolete.

SwiftPushkar

7:31 AM

@TheDestroyer - BTW, i just yesterday found one good (OCR) text scanner app , probably you already Knowing about this one , but in case.. Its a good app , play.google.com/store/apps/…

Nog Shine

> but Namaste Astu Bhavagaha in middle of Samhita

The Destroyer

@SwiftPushkar Ok. Will check later.

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer There's still a typo and I was trying to correct it in the comment and clarifying that usage of Bhagavan is not a sect dependent. Hence, it is not obsolete.

The Destroyer

@NogShine Still then don't you think most of comment is obslote.

@NogShine Then why you blame me for using edit privileges.

SwiftPushkar

@TheDestroyer -not good for sanskrit though , but it can extract text from images fairly accurately , also having Telugu language support.

The Destroyer

7:33 AM

@NogShine It's better you post new comment because your comment has other mantra

@NogShine No prejudice. Most of the comment is obsolete (one line is relevant).

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer I already said that I was on the same page and waited for 6 minutes aftr your comment was posted. The edits didn't load and the edits loaded after I posted the comment. How does it look like to a user without editing privileges? I only said it once and you are repeating I'm blaming you again and again.

The Destroyer

Or let me edit it now and you can remove whole comment

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer No, let it be.

It doesn't matter now.

The Destroyer

Anyhow i should edit it. It's not correct

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer you can remove "Bhagavah is not correct. It should be Bhagavan afaik. Can you post complete mantra you are saying? I am saying about this." this part. It's unnecessary now.

The Destroyer

7:37 AM

@NogShine The same edit can be done by normal user not Mod alone. That's my point. You said in comment as if i wantonly made your comment obsolete by using my edit privilges.

Nog Shine

@TheDestroyer A comment doesn't change for 6 minutes and changes after 9 minutes.. who can edit like that? A normal user can't. It is the side effect of your diamond.

The Destroyer

In any case, i corrected my comment. Just leave it now. it's petty to discuss much on this.

Nog Shine

Yeah. It's just a comment....

→ 1 message moved to Trash Can

Pandya

@SwiftPushkar wow! 10k !

So, now I am having moderator access tools.

Nog Shine

@Pandya Congratulations..

Pandya

7:45 AM

Even if I am not elected in the mod election process after the graduation, I'll have mod access tools! (which is threshold at 10k for graduated sites). @SwiftPushkar @NogShine @TheLittleNaruto :)

Nog Shine

Did you get notifications for 5k tools in the achievement box? @Pandya

Pandya

@SwiftPushkar the privileges I currently have are temporary. But 10k will be eternal!

@NogShine Thanks.

I used to be a mod having <10k

Nog Shine

@Pandya Like glorfindel. He is a mod on Apple but his rep is less than 1900 when he was elected

moderation and reputation are mutually exclusive. High rep user may not know moderation all the time

Pandya

@NogShine No, mods get all the achievement of privileges simultaneously upto 20k when diamond is added after his name.

Nog Shine

@Pandya Oh! I always had this doubt and also thought of asking this question on meta

Nog Shine

8:04 AM

@Pandya Your chances are good for the election.

Pandya

@NogShine Yes, it is pointed out in:

8

Q: Users should make use of their privileges

The issue with this website is that we have merely 25 users with reputation > 200. Still as the site is in public beta, users get access to important privileges with less reputation compared to sites which are graduated. The reason am saying this is, that new users will register who will probab...

discussion post-quality privileges

I also mentioned similar thing long ago:

10

A: Help us out to make this site better!

If our site generates low quality posts every time, that day won't be far when we get a mail saying that SE is shutting down our website. Above point bothered me! and if it is so, we should surly pay attention to it. OK; I'll regularly review the low quality questions. Everyone are request...

> Everyone are requested to use their moderation privileges. I think reviewing & flagging are the important activity to moderate the site.

Nog Shine

@Pandya Yeah, that is the reason why I said moderation activity is important than Q&A.

Users don't normally cast delete votes.

Pandya

@SwiftPushkar Thanks

@SwiftPushkar ok. I will check it.

SwiftPushkar

@Pandya - haha that reminds me of post of Indra😀 but after 25k we will merge with Brahman .

Nog Shine

@SwiftPushkar lol

SwiftPushkar

8:13 AM

@NogShine - 😀

Pandya

What do you think mods get Samipya, Salokya or Sayujya? Haha

SwiftPushkar

8:48 AM

@Pandya Let's ask Keshav he knows that very well ,he is mod & reached beyond 25k ( barrier to retain last remaining previlag aft.grd.) 😀

TheLittleNaruto

9:08 AM

@Pandya So if site graduates, reelection will happen ? And current mods will be removed ?

Nog Shine

@TriyugiNarayanMani Hello.. why so silent?

Triyugi Narayan Mani

@NogShine Hello :)

How are you?

@NogShine Not really. I am always present in reviews

Nog Shine

@TriyugiNarayanMani I'm good. How are you doing?

It's been a while you have talked. So asking..

Triyugi Narayan Mani

@NogShine yes

@NogShine doing good

@NogShine I was not getting much time but now its better.

Nog Shine

@SwiftPushkar @TriyugiNarayanMani delete votes needed on a closed off-topic question hinduism.stackexchange.com/q/17540/5212

Triyugi Narayan Mani

9:16 AM

@NogShine done

Nog Shine

A downvote will delete automatically.. but delete vote will do it quicker. :)

SwiftPushkar

@TheLittleNaruto - Yeah , just like first election of independent country. Anyone can stand ( but no parties) here , each one will contest as independent candidate and to prove his ability before all by submitting a paper😀. Users will vote and CM will decide no. of Mods.

Triyugi Narayan Mani

@NogShine ok

Nog Shine

@SwiftPushkar most of the times, the slots available are 3.

SwiftPushkar

@NogShine - hmm , at least 3 are required , considering growing no. of post.

Nog Shine

9:32 AM

@SwiftPushkar You are right. New question about Garuda purana is a dupe.

Hinduism bot

0

Q: Garuda purana Is it a myth to create fear in humans?

There are 28 types of punishments mentioned in Garuda purana.If seen in detail all are cruel. Hope these are told because humans will not do any bad things during their lifetime. In other words to create a fear among humans if you do this you will face the punishment mentioned in Garuda purana. ...

mythology puranas

Nog Shine

@TriyugiNarayanMani so, how are things going? Are you writing new questions and answers?

Triyugi Narayan Mani

9:49 AM

@NogShine Not getting much to write these days :)

Nog Shine

@TriyugiNarayanMani ask questions and write answers to them. 😎 :)

Triyugi Narayan Mani

@NogShine :) ha ha

good idea though

TheLittleNaruto

@SwiftPushkar Nice! So are you planning to contest for mod if site graduates ? :-)

SwiftPushkar

10:09 AM

@TheLittleNaruto - HAHA 🤗 No. I will prefer the post of researcher and answerer.

@TheLittleNaruto - In one or other way we all are MODS. Just we need to realize the fact that"Tat Tvam Asi , तत्त्वमसि - Thou art that 😀

TheLittleNaruto

10:38 AM

@SwiftPushkar Such a beautiful thought you have. :)

baby welcome Swift

Baby Be'el

@Swift Welcome to the Hinduism chatroom!If you have a question, just post it, and if anyone's free and interested they'll help. If you want to report an abusive user or a problem in this room, ping TheLittleNaruto.

SwiftPushkar

@TheLittleNaruto - Thank You 💐 👍👍

TheLittleNaruto

@SwiftPushkar :)

Hinduism bot

1:15 PM

0

Q: what is the difference between mukthi and moksha

Already I requested in my earlier question if the jeeva athma didn't stay more than 5 days either in moksha and naraga. However what's the difference between mukthi and moksha. Do you someone have any scriptures or any other references? Note: I know that some of my forefathers said that mukthi ...

moksha mukthi

Transcript for