last day (15 days later) » 

14:18
0
Q: Floor Function Limit Confusion

DamI want to examine $$\lim_{x \to a} \left\lfloor x\right\rfloor $$ using the $\epsilon - \delta$ definition. I examine two cases where $a$ is an integer and then is not an integer. When $a$ is an integer this is simple because I do the left and right hand limits where in both cases $|f(x)-l|=0$ so...

MPW
MPW
Away from integers, $f(x)=\lfloor x\rfloor$ is locally constant. In the vicinity of an integer, the function is constant on each side of the integer, but the constants on each side are different.
@MPW I agree, but how does this help me with the question I asked?
"I do the left and right hand limits where in both cases $|f(x)−l|=0$" are you sure about that? What does it happen to the left limit when $a$ is an integer?
@Marco The right hand limit is $a$ so $|a-a|=0$ is that correct? The left hand limit is $a-1$, so it would be $|(a-1)-(a-1)|=0$?.
I have no idea what "I do the left and right hand limits" means.
14:18
@DanAsimov I am comfortable when $a$ is an integer. My question is how to solve when $a$ is not an integer.
If left and right limit does not coincide the limit does not exists. Your calculation is correct, but the conclusion is not
@DanAsimov it means to calculate the limit in $(-\infty, a)$ (left limit) and $(a, \infty)$ (right limit)
@Marco I know that? $a$ is not equal to $a-1$ so the limit doesn't exist when $a$ is an integer. And it was correct to choose any value of $\delta$ like $1$ right? Can you help me when $a$ is not an integer looking at my opening post please?
It is not correct to choose any valiue of $\delta$, as the limit does not exists. For the not integer part. The function is constant outside the integer points. Do you know how to find $\lim_{x \to a} g(x)$ when $g(x)=n$ is the constant function?
@Marco The left hand side limit exists and so does the right hand side. I am choosing $\delta$ values for them separately. I choose $1$ for both.
In the ε-δ definition of a limit, the number ε plays an important role. Yet ε is not mentioned anywhere in your reasoning.
14:18
@DanAsimov I wasn't giving a full formal explanation as I know how to do that and wanted to be quick. My question is how to compute the limit for when $a$ is not an integer. What have I done wrong / right ?
You need to give a fuller explanation of your reasoning, since it makes no sense at all to discuss the ε-δ definition of a limit without any mention of ε.
@DanAsimov For each $\epsilon > 0$, there must exist a $\delta > 0$ such that if $0 < |x-a| < \delta$, then $|f(x)-l|<\epsilon$. Happy? This is for when $a$ is not an integer as otherwise the definition is different for the one-sided limits.
@DanAsimov To be fair, as the floor function is locally constant you can choose $\delta$ fully independent by $\epsilon$
@Marco Can you please check the method I used when $a$ is not an integer in my opening post?
@Dam there is an answer to this question and three dupes questions linked to it. The answer posted here is correct. As your notes. You can't use arbitrary $\delta$. e.g. $\delta=10$ does not work
14:18
@Marco So what I wrote in my opening post with $\delta = 1$ is incorrect? I set $n = \left\lfloor a\right\rfloor $ and get $n < a < n+1$. Whenever $0 < |x-a| < \delta $, $|f(x)-l|=|f(x)-n| = 0 < \epsilon$ where $\epsilon > 0$. Can you explain why as I don't understand?
Assume $a=2.3$ and $\delta=1$. If $x=3.1$ , $|x-a|<\delta$, but $|f(x)-2|=1>\epsilon$ for each $\epsilon<1$, so $\delta=1$ does not work
@Marco Thanks. Silly question but why is |$f(x)-2|=1$? Nevermind I saw the edit makes sense.

last day (15 days later) »