« first day (2378 days earlier)      last day (1271 days later) » 
00:00 - 17:0017:00 - 23:00

12:00 AM
No, I know it's nope, just wanted you to see it anyway. :-)
 
@GarethMcCaughan hm, I didn't have a picture on my front cover. I feel like I should redo it.
 
@bobble :D
 
@msh210 Yours was in knot theory or something of the sort, right? Should totally have had a picture on the front.
 
I love how half of them are doodles and the other half are kittens and puppies
 
12:01 AM
and statue parks
 
and two texts from bae
 
@GarethMcCaughan well, laminations. Related to knot theory but not quite it
 
Ah, OK. I was misremembering a bit.
 
Just a bit, really. And my avatar is deceptive.
 
It looks like it's on 3-manifolds in particular, so really quite close in spirit to knot theory.
 
12:05 AM
Yeah.
Sorry, I shoulda specified: laminations of 3-manifolds
 
internal panic at all these terrifying math words
 
expected value of a random walk on a metric space homeomorphic to an R-order tree with a probability measure
 
aiiiieeeee
 
LOL just messing with you
 
HTM
Man, and I thought category theory was crazy enough
 
12:12 AM
(that last message of mine was just gibberish. I mean <valley girl scoff> metric spaces with measures don't even have values)
 
Avi
@msh210 chokes
this is why I should've never taken random algorithms :/
 
@msh210 what does that mean
 
@matt nothing much
 
Avi
expected value = expected value, random walk = random walk, metric space = metric space, homeomorphic = homeomorphic, R-order tree = tree of order R, probability measure = meaningless?
 
th-that doesn't help /s
 
12:18 AM
@Avi no, probability measure is a measure such that the whole space has measure 1 (and I think there may be some additional criterion)
 
I bet an R-order tree (assuming such a thing exists) doesn't mean "tree of order R".
 
@Avi R-order tree is a specific type of topological space, not a tree of order R. Also, I mistyped it, it's really a $\mathbb R$-order tree
I don't have that character on my phone's "keyboards".
 
66
Q: Any chance of MathJax in chat?

MajenkoIt would be really nice to be able to use MathJaX (math formulas) in chat. Not specially for formulae, but for things like $V_{CC}$ in electronics chat would be very useful.

 
This is too much for my brain, arghhh
 
just keep doodling, just keep doodling
 
12:21 AM
doodles are nice, doodles have no math in them
 
@Sciborg mine do
(sometimes)
 
Everything has some math behind it
 
yeah, no mathematics at all in mere children's drawings
In mathematics, a dessin d'enfant is a type of graph embedding used to study Riemann surfaces and to provide combinatorial invariants for the action of the absolute Galois group of the rational numbers. The name of these embeddings is French for a "child's drawing"; its plural is either dessins d'enfant, "child's drawings", or dessins d'enfants, "children's drawings". A dessin d'enfant is a graph, with its vertices colored alternately black and white, embedded in an oriented surface that, in many cases, is simply a plane. For the coloring to exist, the graph must be bipartite. The faces of the...
 
eeeeeeek
 
HTM
@msh210 I searched it up, looks like a probability measure must also be additive
 
12:23 AM
@HTM makes sense, thanks
 
HTM
and, of course, it can only return values between 0 and 1
 
I want Deus to see Deus Vader :D
 
I hope he likes it :p
 
or else...
 
just saw it - it's pretty funny
 
12:31 AM
yay!
 
Glad you approve
 
<leaving to concentrate on schoolwork>
cause y'all are distracting
 
Sorry :P
 
I haven't seen that meme in years
 
12:44 AM
Any ideas on the C4?
 
Avi
def is probably "very stable"
either that or trump is being inserted into the rest of the wp
 
or "very"
or "on vacation"
 
Avi
Very stable genius eats odd plant (7) - TRUMP E_T_
but unfortunately there's not many 10 letter words that contain "trump", so that's probably not the WP
 
@Deusovi Or just "vacation"
it cxould be all that +ON
 
true - "on" could just be the word ON
 
12:55 AM
I initially didn't think so, but a lot of synonyms for vacation surprising end in -ON
 
I'm tempted to think the def is "state's on vacation," maybe something like ADJOURNING, and that the wordplay is "very stable genius" inside a word for "former communist."
 
Oooooh
That's actually really celever
Except adjourning isn't in the proper tense
 
Yeah, it wouldn't be that. Just an idea
"former communist state" could also be literally referring to a former communist state like Latvia, Moldova, Estonia, etc.
 
maybe something like SUSPENSION? Does that fit tense?
 
Ooh, that fits
SU = Soviet Union?
 
1:04 AM
Ooh, actually this might be going somewhere?
 
I'm not sure of the wordplay though, unless PENSION = vacation somehow?
 
But SUspension is in the beginning
 
1
Q: Hetero-F(our|ive)-Cells

BubblerThis is a hybrid of Four Cells and Five Cells (uses pentominoes instead of tetrominoes), with a global no-repeated-piece rule. Rules: The grid is to be divided along the grid lines into areas containing exactly four or five cells. A number in a cell indicates how many of its four sides are segme...

 
The "very stable genius" is what trips me up, because if it's not Trump, I have no idea what that is cluing.
 
I was referring more to if the tense of SUSPENSION fits
@Sciborg ?
I can't tell if you're being serious or not :P
 
1:06 AM
I mean... yes, I'm serious :p what else could it clue
 
It could be VERY STABLE+US{genius}SR
 
Ahh, true
 
USSR just being the marker place for "former communist state"
Isn't there a chemical word for something that's really stable?
 
I can't think of a fancy science-y word for it, it's just "stable"
maybe "covalent" or "ionic"?
 
"non-reactive"?
All too long though
 
1:09 AM
"bonded"?
 
"adamantine" for very stable?
 
@Sciborg it's very possible that there's intended to be a split in the parsing somewhere in the middle of that (either wp-def split or just two parts of wordplay)
that's the exact type of misleading that cryptic clue writers absolutely love
"very stable" could also clue something like ROCK-SOLID (except, y'know, 10 letters long and not hyphenated)
 
Definitely possible, I'll have to think of more words that can mean "stable"
 
Maybe FIRM+?
 
Oooooh
Or HARD, although that's not as good a fit
 
1:18 AM
Genius could also be in former
 
True!
"former" can mean a lot of things, too - "first", "old", "shaper"...
 
Yeah. I don't think it could be an indicator though, I'm not sure it works grammatically
@Deusovi Thoughts?
 
Probably not an indicator
 
i don't think it does
 
I like SOLIDARITY maybe, if "very stable" is the wordplay and means SOLID.
 
1:24 AM
what was the answer to the former C4?
 
@Sciborg But what's the def?
 
No idea :p
I've just been looking at ten-letter words that start with SOLID, HARD or FIRM
 
never mind, backread and found it
 
@oAlt CONS+TRICT
 
yup
 
1:27 AM
Probably my favorite clue I've clued
 
It was super clever!
 
also i abandoned bubbler's f(our|ive) cells because i couldn't see any other elegant deductions yet :'(
 
wait... hold on
 
ooh, "wait hold on" means a solution is incoming
 
SU+(s)+PEN (meaning stable) sion?
 
1:30 AM
argh, someone posted an answer based on "integer linear programming" to the question I bountied asking for an answer based on logical deduction.
 
suspen = stable?
 
READ THE BOUNTY REASON, PEOPLE
 
stable like barn stable
Idk where the S and SION would be though
 
@bobble yeah i saw that too D:
 
@PrinceNorthLæraðr ohhh, nice!
@bobble yes, I saw that as well :/
 
1:30 AM
Idk about the s or sion though
well it ends in ON
 
I gave up going for the bounty after filling in only 12 cells with LOTS of backtracking
 
The SU+(s) would have to come from "very" and I don't know how you would get there
 
I thought the SU might be Soviet Union, but idk
Idk how you would flop the order
 
The logic is either really ingenious or simply absent
 
yeah, there would have to be a flipping indicator or something
 
1:32 AM
I really want it to be ingenious, and I figured that bounty-ing would be the best way to find out.
 
hehe, can SSI (Social Security) be "communist" :P
 
bold political statements you're making there, North :p
 
I was trying to see if SSI could somehow stand for a former communist state
sospension
"SO" is very :P
Obvious, genius is = s, because um a genius is a Super thinker
 
oooh
 
@oAlt yeah, i'm playing around with it now and it's certainly not easy - i'm having trouble figuring out how global stuff will lead to more local deductions
 
1:35 AM
SI is Soviet Iceland, a former, non-existent communist state
 
@Deusovi yeah
 
But SO+ actually does seem possible
 
Small hint for the f(...) cells: there's something to figure out before you start solving the grid
 
yes, that's what i meant by "global stuff"
 
hmmmm
 
1:39 AM
i see two options
and i'm not immediately sure how to disambiguate which of the two it is
 
I think I know what options these are
 
@bobble @Sciborg Oooh, it's transgender awareness week this week
 
:D
Didn't even know that, actually
 
ack, identity issues again
(still not sure how I identify)
 
@Sciborg Well it had a little blurb at the bottom of my google home page
 
1:42 AM
@bobble Doesn't matter, we take everyone :)
 
where do you take them?
 
far far away just around the block or something
 
Huh, RED can be communist
 
yeah
 
I had another wild C4 idea, what if "vacation" doesn't mean like a literal vacation but instead means "the act of vacating the premises"?
 
1:43 AM
ey anko
 
@Sciborg I don't think that works, does it?
 
But if it's cluing, like, EXIT or something...?
 
SO+PEN+FOR{genius}MER+RED is another parsing I'm thinking
 
@Sciborg please take me to a galaxy far far away. Or to Hogwarts. Or to the Triskelion. Or to any of my fandoms' worlds, really :D
 
@Sciborg hm, possibly
 
1:44 AM
@Sciborg "state's on vacation" could also be S_E or S_S
"on vacation" as in "when vacated"
 
Ooohh
 
... I wish you brought that up earlier!
 
I really love "when vacated" being the parsing
 
it's a device that i've seen once or twice and it trips me up every time -- and i believe it was mentioned in here not too long ago
 
1:45 AM
@Deusovi is SE or SS more likely, grammatically?
 
it's a very fun one
 
That's super fun and I hope it is intended here
 
@PrinceNorthLæraðr uh i'd say SS
 
2 hours ago, by msh210
I want the C4 to be CONSUMMATE = "very" (as in "the very gall!"). The wordplay would have to be CON = "former communist" (already a stretch but okay, being a communist used to land you in jail in the U.S. in the fifties), SE = "state's on vacation" (vacating, i.e. emptying, "state"), and then… UMMAT = "stable genius"?? Not seeing it.
 
i remember gareth saying it's his least favorite cluing too(???)
 
1:46 AM
@Deusovi Hehe, TRIP
 
is this were you saw it mentioned?
 
May 6 at 13:44, by Gareth McCaughan
The most annoying "remove the insides" indicator I've seen is "on vacation". Annoying not because it's wrong or unreasonable, but because my brain never wants to interpret it correctly. I think I've now seen it often enough to remember consciously what it's likely to mean, though.
 
^
 
I love it
 
not "least favorite" but it is very good at hiding
 
1:47 AM
mm
 
so, this could be either gareth using that device, or gareth intentionally making us think he's using that device. i give it 50:50 odds
 
you have to say that in a more mathy way
 
heh
 
Mathy way: heads and tails of a fair coin
 
@bobble "an approximate model of whether gareth is using that device can be simulated using the bernoulli distribution with parameter p=½"
 
1:52 AM
much better :)
 
ey matt
 
ey oAlt
 
@Deusovi What in the world
 
"bernoulli distribution" is a fancy way of saying "what you get when you flip a (possibly biased) coin"
@Bubbler does the intended path through your puzzle involve bifurcation? i've found a way to a solution, but i have to go pretty deep before i get a contradiction
 
2:17 AM
No, it doesn't need such deep backtracking
 
alright, will try to find a nicer way through
 
Also, there must be only one option before start (at least in my intended way of options)
 
...huh? seems to me that there are two
oh wait
yep i did the math wrong. only one!
 
3:10 AM
@Avi i now share the same sentiment with you-- i don't know how to count
when i initially started solving the four/five cells i extended the zero outward but thought the zero only got four cells
i didn't count the square the 0 itself was in ;_;
 
That's too bad :P
 
>_< hehe
 
3:28 AM
I forgot the 0 existed D:
 
oh I forgot to mention
I knew beforehand there was going to be some deductions relating to counting up the cells
But for some fricking reason I did "8 x 8 = 80" -_-
 
3:46 AM
Ey, join me in my "Why the hell did I do that" club!
 
i somehow subtracted 20 from 64 and got a multiple of 5
 
Oct 27 at 14:57, by Deusovi
second only to "basic arithmetic on single-digit numbers" and "remembering to actually read the puzzle text"
3
 
@bobble So relatable
 
Oct 27 at 15:02, by bobble
If you make a cryptic that requires "counting", "basic arithmetic on single-digit numbers", or "remembering to actually read the puzzle text", then maybe Deus won't solve it as fast :)
 
wahahah
 
4:04 AM
2
Q: Why is computer science hard?

Daniel R. CollinsData pretty regularly shows that computer science programs have among the highest failure and dropout rates of any college program. A number of sources all echo the finding that roughly one-third of incoming CS majors do not progress to a second year, higher than most other majors. Computer scie...

 
huh?
 
that... isn't relavent to this chatroom
 
for those who like a challenge, it is :-)
 
This is not the place to fish for answers to your non-Puzzling.SE question
 
no, it's really not relevant
 
4:06 AM
Why are puzzles hard?
 
it depends on what particular type of puzzle you're talking about - that question seems pretty vague to me
 
Not to an educational psychologist
 
The "hard" part of puzzles depends on the puzzle. Again, not the right chatroom for this conversation.
 
puzzles can be hard for many different reasons - difficulty of making deductions, prerequisite knowledge, needing you to make specific inferences, or just being "guess what the author is thinking"
 
It's just "food for thought,"
 
4:09 AM
Is there a particular reason you came this chatroom for this particular conversation?
 
"crashed" seems a bit hostile
i do think the link is pretty unrelated though
 
Like I said, for those who like a challenge of explaining why somethings are "hard"
 
this is a fine place for talking about why puzzles are hard (and other aspects of puzzle design), but a question that broad will likely not get you any useful answers. there are lots of different types of puzzles that require/test very different skill sets
 
Opinions are welcome :-)
 
Hm, really confused about what's going on with the sequence puzzle
The one with lots of square roots
Oh dear. I believe I made a mistake. I thought I knew what the following term was, but I am no longer sure, and so I can no longer state that your guess is wrong. Please forget about that part. I'm pretty certain your guess is wrong but my calculation of the next term was also wrong so I cannot prove it. — Conor Henry 22 mins ago
 
4:15 AM
oh dear
 
yeah, that seems... strange
 
Would asking about a puzzle tag be off-topic on meta?
 
it wouldn't be off-topic but would likely be shot down
 
Yeah, I figured.
 
puzzle should be tagged based on what type of puzzles they are, not where they came from
1
Q: Tag for IQ-test-like questions

deep thoughtI looked around meta, and it seems this came up before. It seems there used to be such a tag, but it was removed for various reasons: One reason is that it is 'meta' and describes the 'origin' of the puzzle rather than the content. One reason is that low-quality/off-topic questions should be fl...

 
4:23 AM
Thanks :-)
sorry for being such a noob
 
5:13 AM
0
Q: A night out at Luigi's

Prince DeepthinkerHi Puzzling SE at the moment I am at a romantic night out in a fancy restaurant. Tonight the owner, Luigi, who is also a riddle fanatic has decided to put a little riddle on the menu. It was stated that whoever could solve it would get whatever free 3 course meal and bottle of wine for himself/he...

 
5:37 AM
@Deusovi I am laughing so hard at this
like how does that happen
you must clearly have been using base 9, in which 44 (base 9) = 40 (base 10)
 
yes, clearly
 
6:00 AM
as mud
 
6:25 AM
heh
jafe!
 
hey
hah, brilliant c4 surface
 
 
2 hours later…
8:21 AM
0
Q: Proposal: define "pattern-spotting questions from other sources" as off-topic

BubblerRecently we've been getting multiple questions asking for answers to pattern-spotting questions from external sources. Many of them are in the form of a simple number-sequence (e.g. given some numbers, predict the next number) or progressive-matrix (e.g. given a matrix of pictures with one pictur...

 
@PuzzlingMeta Maybe a bit drastic, but this was the best logical argument I could make (defining "low-quality" is really really subjective)
 
8:58 AM
(on another note, your f(our|ive) cells is on HNQ list :0 )
 
9:21 AM
0
Q: Does it exist a way to get the next term in a table sequence of digits without guessing?

Chris Steinbeck BellThe problem is as follows: The figure from below shows a sequence of numbers ordered in a tabular form. Find the next term labeled $x$. The alternatives given in my book are as follows: 11 9 3 5 8 This peculiar problem I found it in my puzzles book Reason and logic from 2000's. From the look...

 
10:10 AM
3
Q: Yin-Yang: All-White

athinHere is a standard Yin-Yang puzzle. Rules of Yin-Yang: Fill each empty cell with either a black circle or a white circle. All white circles should be orthogonally connected, so do all black circles. There may not be any 2x2 cell region consisting of the same circle color.

 
10:34 AM
@jafe Thanks! I like it too.
 
@Sphinx interesting
im trying it out but i don't know how to make any more good deductions after the first ones
 
10:47 AM
i got stuck early on too
 
11:00 AM
0
Q: You see my everywhere

Prim3numbahYou see me everywhere. Many times you don't even think about me but I'm still there. Sometimes I can be present in relationships, both physical and non-physical. Lately, I've become very important. What am I?

 
11:22 AM
athin has realized it heheheh
 
11:56 AM
yup still not getting anywhere :P
 
12:25 PM
LOL
 
 
1 hour later…
1:37 PM
Ooh, two answers
 
 
1 hour later…
2:57 PM
-3
Q: You see me everywhere

Prim3numbahYou see me everywhere. Many times you don't even think about me but I'm still there. Sometimes I can be present in relationships, both physical and non-physical. Lately, I've become very important. What am I?

Y'all that one answer down there
I think this should lead to an immediate delete of the answer? Correct me if I'm wrong
Never mind, it says that "this post was deleted" before I reloaded it (I'm on mobile)-- does that mean a mod intervention or self-delete or does it convey no specific info?
Anyway that was an outstandingly gross answer-- even the question itself beats it
Oh and I flagged another one of the answerer's answers in another question as "not an answer" (although "rude and abusive" comes second to it). Hopefully that gets taken care of as well
Equally outstandingly gross
 
handled
@oAlt it could be mod intervention or an automatic deletion after enough rude/abusive flags
(the linked answer was auto-deletion, the other one was me)
 
ah I see
also thanks
 
3:17 PM
@oAlt I flagged it for "rude and abusive"
That was uh not cool
 
agreed
65
Q: I see my dog run

HTM My dog chooses not to go after the highest bets. What is my dog's name? Bonus: What is my name?

@HTM is it just me or was the bonus never really answered at all
 
3:33 PM
0
Q: Examples of Cheat-Proof trivia questions?

ParseltongueI'm planning on running a Zoom trivia tournament with monetary prizes and am trying to avoid any concern about cheating to preserve competitive integrity. What are some types of questions that are more-or-less "cheat-proof?" (that is, they can't trivially be Googled within the time-limit... about...

 
3:45 PM
@Sphinx seems a little off-topic? Also seems to be asking for a "big list", which is generally discouraged across Stack Exchange.
 
I'm not sure what to think of it
It is about puzzle making, but seems a bit... speculative? Is that the right word?
 
It's just saying "give me some ideas"
 
3:59 PM
you're right that it's a bit vague and can't really be meaningfully definitively answered
 
Yeah
I'm going to vote to close it then
 
What close reason?
 
Probably "opinion-based" is what I'm thinking
Or no sorry
Speculative
 
also, i answered the meta post with what i think are more definitive arguments
0
A: Proposal: define "pattern-spotting questions from other sources" as off-topic

DeusoviI'm not sure that the possibility of multiple equally likely answers is enough to declare a question definitively off-topic. There are sometimes answers that are very clearly correct -- in questions that do satisfy this, there's no reason to declare them off-topic a priori. But... I do see some p...

thoughts?
 
@PrinceNorthLæraðr what's the difference?
 
4:01 PM
"Opinion-based
This question is likely to be answered with opinions rather than facts and citations. It should be updated so it will lead to fact-based answers."
Speculative is more community-specific
It's unlikely the answers will be opinions per se (it might be valid) but it's speculative in its validity
It's also closer to the "vagueness" Deus was talking about
Bobble maybe you can put a comment on why the question is being closed? I can't think of a good comment
 
I'll think of one, currently halfway through Deus's meta answer
@Deusovi I agree, but what would you propose we do with the old IQ test questions?
 
not sure just yet - i'd be in favor of closing them, but right now i'm just focusing on what we should do for future questions
 
I know some have a bunch of views, but that's likely because of their terrible titles - "Mensa Question Help", people google for that and get directed there, and I'm fairly certain only a tiny tiny percent actually need help with that specific question
... someone posted an answer to the "cheat-proof" question
 
yeah
also, that seems to be as good of an answer as any - i'm not 100% sure that the question should be closed, in any case? we've had weirder questions before that still get useful answers
 
I'm also not sure, but then it's still very vauge
 
4:10 PM
agreed, definitely vague
vague is not the same as off-topic though
 
Avi
cackles
^ off-topic cackle
 
Avi
@PrinceNorthLæraðr it is what it is
 
Nov 9 at 0:57, by bobble
Avi is in general weird
 
4:13 PM
Mith!
> This question seems to be fairly vague and ill-defined - simply fishing for a "big list" of possible ideas. No answer could possibly be the definitive answer. "Not Googleable" is subjective, as some people may be more adept at Googling than others.
draft of comment
 
Okay, looks good to me
 
I'd remove the 'Not Google-able' bit
It's subjective, but it's a reasonable criteria
 
That was added in because someone's going to counter-comment and say "The question is perfectly defined! They asked for stuff that isn't trivially Googleable!"
 
As in you can produce example that are objectively non Google-able
@bobble Yes, but that doesn't counter the big-list complaint
 
> This question seems to be fairly vague - simply fishing for a "big list" of possible ideas. No answer could possibly be the definitive answer.
modified comment draft
 
4:19 PM
Just my thoughts, anyway, up to you
@bobble looks good to me
 
unrelated: can anyone think of a better title for this?
Seems like the title should incorporate the actual puzzle, and not be so vague
The definitive answer will be the one that gets the most amount of votes after one week. — Parseltongue 12 secs ago
That's not how Stack Exchange works!
(can anyone think of a better way to say "that's now how Stack Exchange works"?)
 
"connect 3 black dots and 3 red dots"?
(also not off the top of my head)
(i used up most of my "phrasing things non-terribly" energy on that meta post)
 
Heh
 
"Why is it impossible to connect each of 3 black dots to each of 3 red dots?"
to be more specific about what connections must be made
 
A bit too wordy ig
 
4:29 PM
ig = "I guess"?
 
But it's definitely an improvement over what it is now
Yes, sorry about that
 
"Why is it impossible to connect 3 black dots to 3 red dots?"
> @Parseltongue, if you're looking for which answer gets the most votes, then that's a popularity contest, not a question fit for our Q&A system.
thoughts? anyone?
I'll just be posting the comment and making the title edit if no one raises an objection
 
Sounds reasonable, I guess
 
4:50 PM
Today's econ tangent: a rant about the "draconian" attendance-taking requirements and how adversity is good for you
 
@bobble That is indeed not how SE generally works, but note that this is a bit of an unusual case. It's a question about puzzles rather than a puzzle (perfectly on-topic on PSE, but not what most PSE questions are). In such cases there isn't quite the same presumption that there's a single optimal answer.
 
@bobble Would be fun if network dies midway
 
Stack Exchange does tend to have a strong preference for questions with definite answers that can be right or wrong, but I think it's clear that the question isn't unreasonable here.
 
28 mins ago, by bobble
The definitive answer will be the one that gets the most amount of votes after one week. — Parseltongue 12 secs ago
 
So then the issue is: is it OK for the poster to commit to accepting whatever answer is highest-voted?
Generally that's not a good idea. But the general principle is that when there are multiple valid answers the poster is entitled to award that coveted green checkmark however they like.
 
4:53 PM
Is there a downside of them doing so?
 
So if they'd said "I'll give the tick to my favourite answer after a week", that would be perfectly fine.
In this case, they're saying that they'll defer to the community. Personally I can't see anything wrong with that -- not least because they could have done exactly that without saying in advance that they would, and no one would have been any the wiser.
 
Popularity contest on CGCC went out of favor, so presumably that's not the scoring criterion PSE wants either?
 
@GarethMcCaughan I still disagree, but I can't concentrate on the chat enough to write a response since I have to pay attention to econ
 
That said, I have seen interesting questions with useful answers closed on SE sites because they didn't fit into the "question with single definitive answer" mould. The only potentially-good justification I can see for closing them is that if we don't stamp on them then the site will be overwhelmed with such questions, and the more-clear-cut sort is more valuable and more suited for SE sites and we don't want those crowded out. On PSE especially, I think there is basically [...continues]
... zero danger of that.
Anyway, I'll shut up now so you can concentrate on learning economics.
 
How do other sites handle big-list questions?
I'm guessing they have to draw the line somewhere, allowing all big-list questions by default is a terrible idea
 
00:00 - 17:0017:00 - 23:00

« first day (2378 days earlier)      last day (1271 days later) »