TRPG General Chat

« first day (4209 days earlier) ← previous day next day → last day (1050 days later) »

AncientSwordRage

00:11

@TheDragonOfFlame I'll look tomorrow

GcL

01:08

@TheDragonOfFlame First feedback: neat. Second feedback: why?

Second wind for a superiority die seems rather OP at first glance. That's d8+bonus so, 12 points of healing in a 3 round combat. Actually, maybe not that much since they do have to forego some damage or versatility for that.

Retreating attack is definitely OP. Disadvantage on all visible incoming attacks is already pretty nice. Getting a nearly free attack out of that makes for a very nasty combination. I would like to see some fighter with GWF use that to compensate for the lack of shield. Just throwing hail mary big swings.

Flaming shot is cool. I like that. Definitely something that would have to be prepared ahead of time and I would drop the splash down to 5' adjacent to a hit target. Might actually make the splash a static 1 damage to avoid a lot of extra rolling.

Yeah. potentially 8 damage sum total to all surrounding foes from the target. Enough to make opponents thing twice about clumping, but not enough to be abused for silly amounts of damage with a short bow.

Each shot at 10' splash could hit 25 enemies in the best case. That could do 275 dmg if they all failed to save. So max extra damage is ~ 650 at +3 prof with 2 attacks/round.

Nearly free fireballs for a fighter is nuts.

TheDragonOfFlame

01:25

@GcL the ‘why’ is that a) nobody I knows plays fighters, I’ve literally played with one fighter ever (barbarians, paladins, and rangers are just ‘cooler’). b) inspiration struck?

@GcL superiority die is a d6 to begin with

GcL

@TheDragonOfFlame L5 is usually where I start considering how a class plays.

TheDragonOfFlame

And you only get 1 at first level

@GcL fair

GcL

L1 doesn't last past the first session if you even start at L1. Many tables don't like to.

BESW

@TheDragonOfFlame The d6 is the superior dice, I agree.

TheDragonOfFlame

@BESW lol

GcL

01:28

I've got a GWF + GWM fighter at my current table, and they coordinate exceedingly well with the rest of the party to optimize advantage and take down huge amounts of HP. That reroll 1's and 2's with the bonus damage is a bit nuts. I'm very much a fan.

TheDragonOfFlame

@GcL fair. Should I change it to disengage or would that still be broken?

BESW

Although I admit to curiosity about Kismet's "run entire pre-made D&D adventures with nothing but a single d20" premise.

TheDragonOfFlame

@GcL with my revised fighting style, it adds on average 2 points of damage, being roughly even with Dueling.

GcL

@TheDragonOfFlame Probably not nearly as much on just disengage. Especially if you spell out they don't get multi-attack. Just a single swing as they move away is probably fine.

TheDragonOfFlame

(Oh I see you were talking about the d6, not the fighting style)

GcL

01:32

Honed body is interesting for certain campaigns. Functionally, halving the full rest time is useless in a party where you're still waiting for the casters. Also, 1/2 duration short rests lead to shenanigans.

Maybe substitute a resistance to poison.

BESW

01:58

Crowdfunding: Improv for Gamers Second Edition by Evil Hat Productions. Want to add more to your tabletop roleplaying, game mastering, or live-action gaming skills? Improv for Gamers is for you!

momatoes wrote a twitter thread "to show favorite spreads of the #ARCdoom adventures."

VioletRiotGames wrote a tweet asking people "to consider volunteering your time (if you have any at all) to a local youth organization. Kids love games, they would like to play. They would like to learn. You can help them by just showing up and playing."

Roll for Clues by World Champ Game Co. One page Conspiracy horror Ttrpg combining Cobwebs with Roll For Clues

Nevyn wrote a twitter thread about Justicar and "What's it mean to be a GM-less crime procedural? A fully co-op mystery creation & solving game?"

Shalvenay

@BESW that actually sounds rather interesting

BESW

Gontijo shared on twitter the first draft of "a ttrpg icon set."

momatoes asked on twitter "do folks differentiate between #system-neutral and system-agnostic? What would you say are the main differences if any?"

9 hours later…

Hot RPG Questions

10:40

Q: What stat would involve willpower for a Jekyll and Hyde type dnd character

So for my upcoming dnd campaign I was planning on jekyll and Hyde type of character and I want the dm to just look at me whenever and tell me to roll for whatever stat involves willpower to switch personality or not I just want to know what stat would involve willpower.