@JyrkiLahtonen Not sure if you noticed, but I personally count context no matter whether it is in the question or in the comments, for new askers. Long-time askers should learn to put context into the question, and should only be penalized if they refuse to do so. Also,
that question was rightly closed as "needs details or clarity". This is different from closure for "no-effort", and such posts when clarified mostly get reopened readily.