The warlock's Pact of the Tome option for the Pact Boon feature says:
When you gain this feature, choose three cantrips from any class's spell list. While the book is on your person, you can cast those cantrips at will.
Are these cantrips considered warlock spells for the purposes of determ...
I want to create a celestial warlock and I want to have Shillelagh as one of my Pact of the Tome cantrips.
I also wanted wooden staff as an arcane focus so I can use melee and free up my other hand.
Are the Pact of the Tome cantrips treated as warlock cantrips, which would let me use my arcan...
Pact of the Tome gives Warlocks access to any 3 cantrips. The feature doesn't specify whether the cantrips use the default stat (my guess), or whether they use Cha (to make the feature more useful/avoid MAD).
Contrast the omission with Magic Initiate, which explicitly calls out the stats, accord...
Control Weather is useful spell for certain plot, story, and exploration purposes. It can solve problems for adventurers or whole communities. However, its utility in combat or even in exploration of the stereotypical dungeon or lair is fairly limited. Why is it an 8th level spell?
And is there ...
@Ben Any reason for D&D rather than something else? I ask because there's a lite (microlite? Never quite sure how small it has to be to earn that descriptor) independent game that was awesome when my kids were 4-7.
@Ben If it is D&D, I've been perfectly happy running 5-room dungeons with them. No need to get any more complicated. My kids, at least, have tended not to have plot/outcome stick with them through the years as much as individual elements. I.e. I never hear them talking about whether they saved the minister from the assassination, but they talk about the mostly-transparent dragon with all its veins and arteries showing through until sunup.
@KorvinStarmast To be fair, I've definitely played games (Mage for more than a year) that I never read the whole rules for. My stuff, certainly, but not the DM side.
@nitsua60 My main fallback is dungeon making/adventure writing. And for kids you obviously don;t want to get too complex otherwise they'll lose interest pretty quickly.
So I am looking for simple systems that are easy to follow, witch simple dungeons to run around in. Make it a one-off game that can get them interested
This issue came up in a recent session:
A character used Shocking Grasp against a Fire Elemental. Due to the Fire Elemental's ability Fire Form, the attacking Character took damage. Can they use Shield as a reaction against the damage from Fire Form?
Pretty new to D&D5e, I've been playing 3.0/....
RFS seems like the system won't get in their way, and will reward them for doing things they like. On the other hand, it won't provide you much of a crutch.
Is the Arcana Skill capable of influencing or effecting actual spells being cast or other spell-centred details? For example, are you able to influence the effect or characteristics of a spell by rolling a high enough Arcana check? Or does that fall primarily within relation to magic items and no...
Player Characters gain hit points each time that they level up in addition to a corresponding increase in maximum health points.
What about monsters though? If a monster gains hit-dice, does it also gain maximum hit points?
To put it differently, are hit-dice the source of maximum HP or are the...
I am GMing for a Pathfinder 2e group. A player noticed that cantrips are automatically heightened to half the PC's level rounded up. They therefore believe that a level 1 wizard casting Ray of Frost should count the spell as "heightened" and therefore deal damage equal to 2d4 + spellcasting modif...
I an a total noob in D&D and just started LMoP (the Starter Set adventure).
We are now in a room before Klarg's cave (the Twin Pools, I think). One goblin escaped to tell Klarg that there's an attack coming. The book says Klarg, the Wolf, and the Goblins hide to prepare to ambush the PCs.
Now,...
The newest question posted to 5e was marked as duplicate when it was a duplicate but worded in a way that it is just kinda related but the surprise question was clearly a duplicate but wasn't marked as duplicate.
Related:
Non-duplicate question with answer in another question
Should/can we change the Duplicate notification?
Situation — there are two different questions Aq and Bq. Question Aq has a specific answer Aa. Question Bq has a good detailed answer, which includes points Aa, Ba and Ca.
Should ...
I an a total noob in D&D and just started LMoP (the Starter Set adventure).
We are now in a room before Klarg's cave (the Twin Pools, I think). One goblin escaped to tell Klarg that there's an attack coming. The book says Klarg, the Wolf, and the Goblins hide to prepare to ambush the PCs.
Now,...
About 15 hours ago I posed two questions as duplicates of another question and since then one has been voted as duplicate while the other hasn't. The one not closed has a very good answer but it is a duplicate of another question. The older question does need a better answer.
Pact of the Tome gives Warlocks access to any 3 cantrips. The feature doesn't specify whether the cantrips use the default stat (my guess), or whether they use Cha (to make the feature more useful/avoid MAD).
Contrast the omission with Magic Initiate, which explicitly calls out the stats, accord...
I want to create a celestial warlock and I want to have Shillelagh as one of my Pact of the Tome cantrips.
I also wanted wooden staff as an arcane focus so I can use melee and free up my other hand.
Are the Pact of the Tome cantrips treated as warlock cantrips, which would let me use my arcan...
@Eternallord66 Can you explain this? On a breif reading they seem very different. One looks to be about casting stat and the other about material components. Am I missing something?
you can see that in both of those questions the fundamental question underpinning is "are the cantrips learned through Pact of the Tome considered to be Warlock spells"
but that's not what the questions are asking - they're asking which stat you use with the spells you learn or whether you can use a warlock's arcane focus when casting the spells you learn
if there was some grander question which covered all the mechanical implications of knowing a cantrip via the pact of the tome feature, those would both make sense as duplicates of that question since they would be strict subsets of it
but the questions as they are are not duplicates of each other
Yeah, I do agree that both questions are "circling around" the same core question ("is Shillelagh learned through Pact of the Tome a Warlock Spell?") but the essences ("do I use Charisma?"; "Do I use an Arcane Focus?") are too different to be called duplicates.
I get what you are saying but I guess i'm just concerned about the level of inconsistency when closing as duplicate. There have been many times I have noticed a situation like those questions with one being marked as duplicate and other times, like now, where they aren't. There have been times where the two questions are even further from being the same and one being marked as duplicate.
I have seen it done to new users and to people with many thousands of reputation
well, not a lot that can be said to that except that it's difficult to expect consistency on a site with a large userbase, especially when the overwhelming majority of them do not participate in meta discussions about site content
There can be lots of reasons for that. If you notice issues and inconsistencies, feel free to bring them up as you have. The tricky part is that duplicates are often not clear cut. We have guidlines, but they still largely rely at times on best judgement. And obviously what is best can differ from person to person.
I think I'm personally pretty consistent in whether or not I judge various things as dupes of each other, but I'm not watching the site like a hawk 24/7 and I don't go chasing down questions I wouldn't have otherwise read just to see whether or not other people judged the same way I did
@Eternallord66 You are allowed, and encouraged, to question duplicate markings. When doing so, be specific: target specific closed questions and focus on the fact that they are closed, not the people who did it.
I'm usually on the stack at work, so as carcer said, I'm not constantly reading every question.
And I certainly don't search for keywords on every question, so it's "do I remember this?" from any questions I happen to read.
If I think a question is a dupe, I always mark it.
@Carcer yes
and I think, even if 3 people mark a question as unclear, and a mod comes in and super closes it as a dupe, it's a dupe from all 4 (but I'm less sure on that)
When voting to close a question, it's possible for users to vote for any close reason, even if others have voted for different reasons. However, in the end, once the question reaches five close votes for any reason, only one of those reasons can be displayed.
How does the system determine which ...
I know when I first started I asked a question and within minutes it was marked as duplicate and I eventually got it repealed because it wasn't a dupe. For new users that can be discouraging and can make them leave the stack. It would be better to close in another way where the poster can see it may be temporary.
@Eternallord66 It's generally held that closing as fast as possible is useful. If it turns out the question was actually different, any answers to it would have been incorrect aswell. Having to reopen a question after edits is way better for the stack that answers having to be reworked.
@Eternallord66 Well they certainly aren't aiming to be inconsistent. It seems possible that they might just have a different way of thinking about it. It doesn't mean people aren't being inconsistent necessarily, but I think I would be hesitant in assuming that.
I'm not sure if it can be done but maybe have instead of "close as duplicate", have it as "close as possible duplicate" and then with enough information it can be reopened or marked as a true duplicate. That would help with not discouraging people and close the question before answers are made.
@Carcer Correct. Additionally, the moderators aren't the ones that should be solely responsible for doing that. We're there to be exception handlers and guidance, but the community should be responsible for moderating themselves day to day.
(which, BTW, I think we do a very good job of here)
Ok then the "close as needs details or clarity" seems to be the better option. It can be reverted or made a duplicate after all the information is gathered.
@Eternallord66 I think this is already the way we do things. I only ever close as a duplicate if I'm sure I know what the question is asking and I'm also confident it is the exact same as another question.
If I'm not sure about the former, closing as unclear is the natural option.
My goal is to help with not discouraging people because of quick fingers saying that a question is the same as another when it really isn't. Sometimes it truly is a duplicate and many times it isn't.
so fundamentally your issue here is ironically a duplicate of one that's come up many times in the past, which is to say that - the systems of stack exchange are intrinsically hostile to new users, closing/holding questions for any reason is very discouraging to people who are not used to stack exchange
EG # of questions closed as duplicate later reopened. Though it likely won't be granular enough since there are many other reasons that the question could be reopened.
@Eternallord66 Personally I'd switch sometimes and many times in that last sentence. Don't get me wrong, I think you are on to something, but I think it is smaller than your wording makes it out to be. Rubik's data should shed light on the scale of it.
@Someone_Evil My intuition is that you are correct as well. I'd say a majority of dupe closures end up sticking. Especially if you exclude questions that were edited later to not be dupes and reopened.
@Eternallord66 No matter what though I really do appreciate you bringing up your concerns here. We can't know about issues unless people talk about them.
I get that. I guess my issue is that marking as duplicate seems to be final to some new users while closing for other reasons can seem to be temporary. Some people just word things incorrectly for this site for whatever reason. English may be a second language or maybe grammar is not a strong point for them.
@Eternallord66 I will say that I would appreciate being told if someone thought I were inconsistently applying my powers to the site. I suspect I'm not alone in that--most people who spend lots of curation/moderation time on site I suspect would be very glad for feedback. So please take this as an explicit invitation to help educate me, and if there's someone else who particularly catches your eye in a worrying way please feel free to use a flag to make sure the mods' eyes see your concern.
@Eternallord66 Right. I'm just saying that if you, for hypothetical example, were thinking "man, Korvin just seems all over the map with dupes" that a flag to the mods would be a way to get some other eyes on your concern without calling out anyone publicly.
@Eternallord66 And as Nitsua said, another thing you could do with others is raise a custom flag on a post and ask us to look into the close history and see if there's an issue.
@Eternallord66 If you recall, I posted a meta in which I made clear my frustration with the treatment of new users on RPGSE, and SE in general, which was before SE/SO woke the heck up and realized that "hostility to new users, which was sort of OK when it was mostly an expert coder's site, could (finally) use an adjustment in assumptions"
Before I was elected I once or twice dropped a flag to the effect of "I know <blank> has contributed a lot to the site, but their last dozen answers were pretty rude to newer querents." I don't know if anything came of those, but I can say (from this side of the UI) that the message did get to them the elected moderators behind the scenes.
Flag semaphore (from the Greek σῆμα, sema, meaning sign and φέρω, phero, meaning to bear; altogether the sign-bearer) is the telegraphy system conveying information at a distance by means of visual signals with hand-held flags, rods, disks, paddles, or occasionally bare or gloved hands. Information is encoded by the position of the flags; it is read when the flag is in a fixed position. Semaphores were adopted and widely used (with hand-held flags replacing the mechanical arms of shutter semaphores) in the maritime world in the 19th century. It is still used during underway replenishment at sea...
@Eternallord66 I was, and once was able to send short messages in semaphore, but that's 40 years ago and if you don't use it you lose it. (Well, I did) I have also lost my proficiency in visual/blinking light morse code ....
If the majority of you are then that could be a possible reason for the discrepancies I have been talking about. People in those professions, generally, have a different way of understanding things and writing.
Well, "Senior Associate Et Cetera" I'll make "Intermediate Et Cetera" sometime this year. Hopefully will be an "Lead Assistant Et Ceteral to the First Et Alia" by 2025
Things like semaphores and printing presses are a lot more viable when dealing with a written language that is alphabetic or syllabic in nature where words are composed of a smaller subset of repeated syllables or letters. Printing presses were actually first invented in China, IIRC, but little progress was made afterwards because the rudimentary technology didn't really work well with the nature of the Chinese written language.
@GcL I thought about it, but I didn't want to set the standard and make people follow it without having a meeting first with the BA and PO and rest of the team
@Carcer You have just proven my point on you thinking differently. I was talking about anything working with computers and software and you respond like that.
SMH coders/scripters, can't live with them and can't live without them.
I naively assumed that this query should turn up all the monsters that can swallow things, but it doesn't - it only lists things that have actions/special properties called Swallow
@Rubiksmoose well, if you're curious, the reference is to a scene where they're trying to get a new couch up the stairs to an apartment, and it gets stuck on a corner with one of the characters repeatedly yelling at the other to "PIVOT! PIVOT!"
I really need to add a function to my probability calculator to handle the Bonus-Action attack from Great Weapon Mastery, because I keep needing that to be handled and it's always a pain to figure out.
I'd ditch the last section and focus on the fact that (assuming accurate) the book says you can get rid of him, but doesn't offer guidance on how to do so.
but the words "Does anyone have a good idea" are usually an instant close
I got a notification to Blitz TheKraken's comment "Thanks, very new -- just learning the system", though there was nothing there @'ing me (link). Anybody know why?
On a question, you will receive notifications automatically for comments on the question only, not the answers.
One exception is auto generated comments, like closing as duplicate: you will not get notified of such comments.
On an answer, you will receive notifications automatically for comm...
"If you are the only user to comment on a post, and its author posts a comment without an @notification, you will be notified."
Naturally these are all lies to prevent you from discovering the ghosts
At level 20, Druids get access to the following feature:
Archdruid
At 20th level, you can use your Wild Shape an unlimited number of times.
Additionally, you can ignore the verbal and somatic components of your druid spells, as well as any material components that lack a cost and ar...
Star Wars Betrayal by Wadabadah. A tabletop rpg game set during the First Jedi Purge. In Star Wars Betrayal you will find the essentials to play your own adventure across the galaxy as a Force user in the exile during one year before the events of Star Wars Knights of the Republic II: The Sith Lords.
It uses the Cthulhu Dark engine! And it's free!
Kickstarter: Libreté: an RPG of Lost Children by GMDK. A macabre tabletop RPG about children trying to survive in a haunted, abandoned city. The city is dead. The grown-ups are gone. And the rain never, ever stops.free quickstart guide here
the original output had line breaks that might have made it more legible
but zopflipng is basically the best png compression you can possibly get, and zopflipng-in-place is just a wrapper script I wrote around that to optimise files in place and produce a little output on the resulting change in filesize
Currently there is a prompt "Show 1 more comment" below this answer and even when logging out and back in it is still there. Is it there for anybody else?
@BESW KOTOR II was fairly cool. Bit weird though that one of the cogent viewpoints in the narrative came from a deeply deceptive individual who you absolutely shouldn't trust nor listen to.