@Tsundoku Only vaguely. I read a paper about it some time ago. I have not read the novel but I've seen one of the (many) movie versions, if that counts, and the story is well known. The answers to that question speak about it in general terms; let me see if I can track down the paper that specifically used psych terminology to discuss the novel
Explanation: there are four vedas, Rg Veda, Yajur Veda, Sama Veda, and Atharva Veda. Each consists of poems (Vedas proper) + commentaries on sacred ritual (Brahmanas) + philosophical explorations of sacred ritual (Aranyakas) + philosophical texts more broadly that riff on the themes of that particular veda (Upanishads). The "Vedas" as generally used refers to that entire corpus of texts. They're all Vedic literature.
Indian philosophy is neatly divided into: "orthodox" schools that accept the Vedas as scripture (various forms of Hinduism) and "heterodox" ones that don't (Buddhism, Jainism, Charavaka).
Oh I should have said earlier that the Vedic poems are typically the words that accompany specific ritual sacrifices, hence the connection between the poems and the Brahmanas, etc. Sorry, it's so transparent to me I wasn't thinking about the audience. Apologies.
Is spamming the site with low quality questions grounds for suspension? It's explicitly listed as one, I thought. Don't remember where I saw it, but I thought if a person posts multiple questions in a short span of time that cause more than a certain (not fixed, but judgment based) number of downvotes and flags, that triggers a warning.
This is a small thing, but it annoys me. A lot of their questions have last lines that aren't phrased as questions but as commands. "I want an explanation of this" as opposed to "What does this mean?"
Generally "what does this mean?" questions applied to an entire poem or other work of literature annoys the fuck out of me too. That's not a real question; you're asking for an interpretive essay, not an answer. I say we should declare such questions off-topic.
@Tsundoku I disagree. "Verse" is not a literature-specific word. It's like "paragraph." What is a verse? is a question for a lexicographer, not a literature site.
Wow, I have never reached my close vote limit on any site until today. I'm barred from casting any close votes for the next 18 hours. Hey folks with sufficient rep, please do go through the close vote queue!
@verbose Yes, there's a suspension reason for low-quality contributions. However, although there were a whole lot of questions posted yesterday, I'd say most of them are on-topic and reasonable, several of them even inspiring good answers already. It's a bit odd to have so many from one user on one day, but in the long run it'll probably be a net positive contribution to the site's Q&A.
@verbose That type of question is essentially what Gareth created the interpretation tag for. It does teeter on the edge of being too broad, but can make for very interesting Q&A when used for short works such as poems which can reasonably be analysed in the space of a single SE answer.
@Randal'Thor There's a difference between asking "Is this a reasonable interpretation of this poem?" or "what does this image / situation mean?" (which are reasonable questions) and "What does this poem mean?" (which is not). I'll come up with a meta question about this tomorrow.
@Randal'Thor Actually that's a good case in point. There is a specific claim asked about: "Is it true that there is only one epic in English literature." That is an answerable question without getting into genre theory: No, plenty of other works up to and including Walcott's Omeros are epics and in English.
The question of whether anybody has considered a particular work an epic is also answerable. But a more broad "why is this work considered / not considered an epic?" seems unanswerable to me except as opinion.
@Randal'Thor Thanks! When I saw that it took me a moment to realize what "Over 9,000" referred to. I honestly wondered whether it was the number of questions asked on this site today.
@verbose Agree that question isn't a clear genre-classification question like the new one. Personally I've always been in favour of genre-classification questions, and I've argued for them on meta both here and on SFF, but I can see the case for closing that War and Peace question according to meta consensus.
I feel like this question is perfectly fine if we edit out the sentence about Wordsworth. It's reasonable to ask how a particular choice of narrator affects the poem and why it might have been written like that.
Maybe this one too - we've had several questions of the form "can X be considered literature?" which were left open.
@Randal'Thor Except the on-topic section of our Help guide specifically stipulates we consider essays literature. And what is a good argument not to consider essays literature? We study essays in literature classes all the time.
@Randal'Thor Why does the poet make this choice? is always a terrible question when asked of an entire poem, IMO. "It's because that's how the poem is" is the only possible answer.
@verbose But the question of whether we consider something literature, i.e. on-topic for Lit.SE, is separate from whether it's considered literature in general or by scholars. And the answer being obvious isn't a VTC reason, although certainly could be a reason to DV.
@Randal'Thor Big difference between asking *Is this a consistent theme in this writer?" and asking "Why is this a theme in this writer?" Particularly when it's not even true. One novel and one short story each about painting across Wilde's entire career does not make artists in general a major theme of his work.
@verbose I prefer to think of those questions as "what does this choice add to the poem?", which can sometimes be reasonably answered by some analysis, independently of authorial intent or what reason might have been in the writer's head.
@KnightwantsLoongback It was unwise of you to store up all your questions and then ask them at once. This deprived you of the feedback that you would have got by asking them one at a time. Feedback would have allowed you to improve the later questions you asked, and perhaps avoided getting so many of them closed.
@verbose The Wilde one is more begging the question, true. I wonder if it would be too much of an edit to change it to "Is this a theme in Wilde's stories, and if so why"?
@Randal'Thor But essays are considered literature in general and/or by scholars. What is the argument to be made here? "Why do scholars of literature consider essays literature?" That's unanswerable without getting into "Well, how do you define literature?"
@Randal'Thor The answer is going to be "No, this isn't." Short of listing all Wilde's works and saying, look, artists appear in only these two (or maybe a couple others I can't recall—certainly nothing comes to mind), what possible answer is there?
Well, that'd be the answer then. (It could even be a frame-challenge answer to the question in its current form.) Who knows, maybe "no" is the answer to my Narayan question too. That makes it less interesting than if there is a major theme to be explored, but we shouldn't close "is this a theme" questions just because the answer is no - then everyone would be afraid to ask such questions unless they know the answer is yes, and we might miss out on some interesting themes!
I'm looking for a book I read about 20 years ago, in which one of the main characters explained to somebody else the way Japanese factories operated and the difference with US. He stated something like:
"After WWII the USA government wanted to help Japanese economy to recover, so they decided to ...
@verbose (CC @PrinceNorthLæraðr) I prefer not to get my definitions of literary terms from general-purpose dictionaries. I go to glossaries of literary terms.
‘At night, because of the noise of people laughing, they turned up the
treble on the jukebox. But in the early mornings, in the peaceful shift when
customers on their way to work were reading the papers, you could clearly
hear the trip and run of the bass lines. Some people came alone, with a
li...
I think I've answered all of the ones in the flood that I can; any others would require further research and time that I would rather devote to my timeline answer
@Randal'Thor Thanks for the ping! Might have to have a look at them a bit later though as workload a bit substantial atm. Also just saw that I completely missed your third Withered Arm question, but @verbose 's answer was very interesting to read!
From "Who list his wealth and ease retain", by Thomas Wyatt:
Who list his wealth and ease retain,
Himself let him unknown contain.
Press not too fast in at that gate
Where the return stands by disdain:
For sure, circa regna tonat.
What is the meaning of the phrase in bold? The word return proba...
(cc @bobble who correctly added the poetry tag - we have a policy to not use specific-work tags if the work in question is too short to merit it - "too short" is a bit subjective, but so far we haven't run into any big debates over it)
While writing up the wiki excerpt for william-mcgonagall a couple of weeks back, I came upon a rather surprising remark about him in Wikipedia:
He won notoriety as an extremely bad poet who exhibited no recognition of, or concern for, his peers' opinions of his work.
The next line down, it says...
I wasn't sure if the poetry was needed. I wasn't really asking about a poem as much as an author of the poem, but I guess asking to deconstruct a bit of his poem would constitute the poetry tag
(I'm also hoping that it's click-baity enough to hit HNQ)
In "In the Midst of Alarms" (1894) by Robert Barr, Yates, who was a reporter for Argus newspaper in US and was camping in Canada, was negotiating with a telegraph boy who demanded one hundred dollars to deliver his article to Argus office in Buffalo.
Yates said: “Quite so. I think you will be ab...
The first half of Maya Angelou's "Woman Work" details the extremely busy life of the narrator, ranging from taking care of a baby to mending clothes to picking cotton.
The second half longingly describes how she needs a rest.
The last verse, however, goes like this:
Sun, rain, curving sky
Mounta...
> The system will suspend users under three circumstances: when a user is recreated after being previously suspended, when a user is recreated after being destroyed for spam or abuse, and when a network-wide suspension is in effect on an account.
And that was likely just a sugar lump to shut people up, so I wouldn't count on it becoming an actual rule (not that they might not do a similar thing in the future).
Well, I have a cunning plan: ten of us start collecting questions until each of us has 30 of them. Then we start posting them, i.e. each of us one per day. That would mean at least 10 QPD for an entire month ;-)
Actually, I might have run into something like that when clicking the vote balance button too often or when opening too many tabs in quick succession. It should go away soon, though.
"These rate limits usually disappear within a minute if it was just a one-off glitch or something (such as refreshing the page many times in short succession)."
I would post the screen, except it has very very personal information like my IP Address, so yeah no
@NapoleonWilson I scanned it, and consciously read through it. It's... not something like out of the ordinary I do, like for example, going through tags or something
I think it was probably a system glitch
Comparatively to other sites, our 4 QED isn't too bad
Also, yessss, new tag!
Yeah, I just realized that it was from a short-story collection ;-; I even made a new tag!
These old folks, you must know, were quite poor, and had to work pretty hard for a living. Old Philemon toiled diligently in his garden, while Baucis was always busy with her distaff, or making a little butter and cheese with their cow’s milk, or doing one thing and another about the cottage. Th...