Also, you gotta understand where people are coming from here. BESW is most used to
Role-playing Games, which AFAIU tends to delete non-constructive or answer-like comments. Mith, despite being a mod here, is also influenced by
Interpersonal Skills, which is massively intolerant of comments since they get so many. I come from
Science Fiction & Fantasy and
Puzzling, which are both very permissive about comments.