« first day (2305 days earlier)      last day (2359 days later) » 

2:21 AM
0
Q: Is my controlling idea for my poem analysis accurate?

Tom ZhangThis is my current controlling idea of my essay on the poem "On Pleasure": "The speaker challenges the idea of pleasure in the minds of the audience, and argues that pleasure is an unavoidable part of life; only by accepting this, and giving and receiving pleasure, can one enjoy life to...

 
 
3 hours later…
user15026
5:19 AM
And I find it kinda funny I find it kinda sad That your breakfast for tomorrow Was the plums that I just had
 
user61230
[snrk]
 
user61230
aaamazing
 
user15026
Oh good I was hoping there'd be someone around to appreciate that :D
 
user61230
That has to be one of the best ones I've seen
 
user15026
5:40 AM
It's definitely high on the list for me
 
7:16 AM
Add "Don't trust the storyteller. Only trust the story." (The Sandman) to the list of pro-death-of-the-author quotes.
 
7:57 AM
0
Q: Is there any American literary work, especially a novel, on the fulfillment of the American Dream?

A playgoerThere are lots of literary works concerning the failure of the American Dream. Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, Dreiser's An American Tragedy, Miller's Death of a Salesman, to name but a few. Now the question is: Is there any literary work taking a positive view on the fulfillment of the American ...

 
 
1 hour later…
9:20 AM
0
Q: What is a typical example of a fulfilled American Dream in a literary work?

A playgoerUnfortunately, my previous question was regarded as off-topic. But, I'm not asking for recommendations! While there are many examples of an unfulfilled, shattered American Dream among the literary works, there might be some with a positive attitude toward American Dream. For example, everyone agr...

0
Q: Why is there so little character to the character of Shadow in American Gods?

Matt ThrowerI recently finished American Gods by Neil Gaiman. Among the criticisms I felt fair to level at it was that Shadow, the central protagonist, is very much a blank slate. We rarely get any insight to his inner thought processes, and his speech and actions don't seem to imbue him with much character ...

 
 
8 hours later…
5:33 PM
I feel like whether I post a question on lit or SFF, if it's on-topic for both, is driven by which theme is better for the time of day
 
 
2 hours later…
7:21 PM
0
Q: Scope of 'style' and 'language' tags: retag 'language' question?

Christophe StrobbeWe currently have both a style tag and a language tag. The language tag currently has one question, namely about whether the language used by a 15-year old character intentionally represent the language of a 15-year old (Kafka in Kafka on the Shore). The style tag currently has four questions...

 
8:05 PM
0
Q: Why did Eddie refer to himself as a "feudal serf"?

EJoshuaSIn the beginning of the book, when Eddie Willars confronted Jim Taggart about the poor condition of the Rio Norte Line, they had the following exchange: "Jim, what are you saying? Does it matter that no one blames us - when the road is falling apart?" James Taggart smiled; it was a thin smi...

 
8:55 PM
1
Q: Are questions about teaching literature on topic?

Christophe StrobbeThe site's current description on Area 51 says, Q&A site for scholars and enthusiasts of literature This is a broad description, but just to be sure, I would like to know whether questions about teaching literature would be on topic. I have not seen any questions about this so far and I thi...

 
0
Q: What kind of an engineer was Owen Kellogg?

EJoshuaSTowards the beginning of Atlas Shrugged, Owen Kellogg was described as following: [Dagney Taggart] knew that the superintendent of the Ohio Division was no good and that he was a friend of James Taggart. She had not insisted on throwing him out long ago only because she had no better man to p...

 
9:28 PM
0
Q: Tudor or Jacobean plays that are sequels to a Shakespeare play?

Christophe StrobbeWilliam Shakespeare wrote around 40 plays (depending on how the Shakespeare canon is defined). Except for some of his history plays (Henry IV, Henry VI), Shakespeare did not write any continuations or sequels to any of his own plays. Marlowe, by contrast, wrote Tamburlaine the Great as a two-part...

 
9:46 PM
Something funny happened: I can't edit the tag wiki for , even though I can edit other tag wiki excerpts. This happened just after I reached 1000 reps but it only applies to that specific tag.
 
10:15 PM
@neilhimself At least they got the title right this time.
Can we add as a synonym to , please?
 
@ChristopheStrobbe Because someone else's edit is pending.
Same way you can't edit (or suggest edits to) a post when there's a pending suggested edit.
 
@Randal'Thor Ah, that makes sense. Somebody jumped on it before I could :-)
 
@ChristopheStrobbe Not sure if you have enough rep to review tag wiki edits yet, but it's here.
 
@TimE.Lord I don't think the haircolor suits him. :(
 
@Catija Maybe it's meant to suggest the idea of a fiery demon?
 
10:29 PM
Oh, I'm sure it's intentional... I just don't think (at least in that photo) that it suits him. :P
 
It's more the shape of the hairstyle that looks weird to me.
@TimE.Lord I'm sure someone has already made this joke, but ... the Doctor is finally ginger?!
 
@Randal'Thor I can see the edit, but I need 1500 reps to review them. Just a matter of time, after going from 101 to 1014 in a few weeks ;-)
 
@Randal'Thor It would seem so :-D
We should send a tweet to Neil Gaiman and thank him for this
 
@ChristopheStrobbe Ah well, @TimE.Lord can do it then :-)
@TimE.Lord Is Crowley described as ginger in the book?
 
I'm not sure at all
I approved your edits, @ChristopheStrobbe, but I'm not sure if we need the and tags
 
10:37 PM
@TimE.Lord I already killed .
 
Look like the kind of semi-useless tags SFF is plagued by.
 
@ChristopheStrobbe I'm debating whether this should count as a recommendation question. It's reasonably well scoped, since there are only finitely many Shakespeare plays, but still ...
 
My favourite is love, with its excerpt being "A deep sense of emotional attachment to another person."
 
@TimE.Lord The tag wiki excerpt for sexuality is pretty bad too.
 
@Randal'Thor Why would it be a "recommendation" question? I am not looking for recommendations. It's a matter of history of literature. At the moment, I know only two plays that fit the description.
 
10:43 PM
(Wow, heck of a lot of downvoted questions in that tag.)
 
Ah, yes, pubic hair and gay Captain America
 
user15026
@TimE.Lord Okay I saw this out of context in my chat site switcher and was like "what"
 
@TimE.Lord Sequels are pretty common, though.
 
flags inbound
 
@ChristopheStrobbe It's a "recommendation" question in the sense that you're asking for a potentially open-ended list of works satisfying some desired criteria.
 
10:46 PM
@ChristopheStrobbe the tag would make sense if we're asking about any and all sequels in general, otherwise work, series, and author tags are enough.
 
The (or a) main difference between a story-ID question and a recommendation question is that the former should only have one possible answer (if not, it might be too broad) while the latter may have unbounded answers.
@TimE.Lord boflagsund?
 
@Randal'Thor Hmm, I never thought of the concept of "recommendation" as similar to "list". This seems to be a StackExchange meme.
 
@ChristopheStrobbe Disclaimer: the custom close reason for this on SFF says "lists of works or recommendations", so I may be biased here.
Let me check the Lit meta on recommendation questions ...
 
@Ash we had questions about those on SFF
 
@Randal'Thor As I said earlier, I know only two plays that fit the bill (and one is just a masque), even though English renaissance literature is the main type of literature I read or read about nowadays.
 
So I added a note to my question to point out that the Jacobean period ended in 1625, 9 years after Shakespeare's death. We'll see how it goes.
 
11:49 PM
@ChristopheStrobbe I have to admit, I'm very confused by your recent meta activity.
 

« first day (2305 days earlier)      last day (2359 days later) »