Conversation started Feb 28, 2021 at 17:12.
Feb 28, 2021 17:12
New user + calculus related question = close as no context
RRL
RRL
Close: PSQ
@RRL All are now gone!
@user64742 I don't understand why this should be closed..
3
@an4s it’s a PSQ. They provide no external context.
ok I’m done for now. Taking a break from hunting for PSQs.
@user64742 What kind of "external" context do you think is required? This user presented their work, and explained their confusion. There is no such requirement that an asker post "external context" whatever you decide that to be.
@amWhy they never said /why/ they asked.
@user64742 What's wrong with this question?
Feb 28, 2021 17:46
@amWhy I believe it is someone farming for homework assistance given the calculus tag and their incredibly low rep and also low effort put into the post.
Isn’t closing those sorts of posts what you’ve been requesting lately, Amwhy?
@user64742 Then flag their posts for moderator attention. There are far more heinous examples than you provide above. In fact, I think you were off-base in "new user troll post", which for a new user, ain't all that bad.
I don't find some of these questions as PSQ. I see reasonable work/thought presented. I did vote-to-close some of them which should be closed.
@user64742 I do not know what you are referring to. Do you understand what a PSQ is?
@amWhy that’s not an appropriate flag reasons.
@an4s Exactly.
Feb 28, 2021 17:50
Flags are only for actual destructive or rude behavior such as foul language or bullying in comments.
@user64742 Please do not target a specific user.
@amWhy I never did.
@amWhy a PSQ is when a brand new user makes a one-off post related to a school problem and then never comes back and abandons the post and the account.
And never makes an effort to answer their own question
@user64742 You have much to learn about this site. If you believe a user is trolling the site, flag an example for mod attention, and explain, with links to other posts, why you are concerned about the user's behavior.
@amWhy nonono I assume any brand new user post with low effort is just a sock account trolling
i always assume that
My reasoning for that is that in my opinion our user base grows far faster than reasonably supported by any actual believable growth in site traffic. Therefore we have a severe sock account problem.
so 90% of new accounts are likely socks
@user64742 There are PSQs asked by users with 2K rep, 5k rep, 8k rep. Please, until you deal with your biased assumptions, to not recommend post closures here. If you want to post one or two in a day, then along with your link, explain what you see the problem as. Being a new user is not equivalent to being a troll.
6
Feb 28, 2021 17:55
@amWhy when the front page of the site is filled daily with new user spam, I have a reason to be concerned and annoyed.
The higher rep user PSQs are rarer.
@user64742 Have you ever heard about Covid?, schools and universities shutting down classed,
And when I see them I report them too
The new user spam was long before covid
its been happening since 2017
I recall many conversations in chats and meta about the issue of too many new users
Too many to not appear suspicious
@user64742 I think it is easy to deal with questions you think maybe spam. I usually look up approach0 and report questions as duplicates if I find matches. Otherwise, it is reasonable to flag questions if the OP does not present any work.
@an4s but the flags go to site admins, not close vote holders and then the flag is shot down as not appropriate for mods?
@Xander If you have a chance, could you review the above conversation starting about an hour and fifteen minutes prior to this post?
Feb 28, 2021 18:27
@amWhy: something weird is going on here. Many of the posts presented by @user64742 are not really worth closing.
3
@ParamanandSingh I think I know who this user is, based on the frozen rooms in his chat profile, and his long history of bouncing back and forth, one moment acting like a victim, the next, extremely judgemental and close to offensive agains other users' questions from "newer" users.
@amWhy : Let's hope @XanderHenderson deals with this in proper manner.
@ParamanandSingh Yes indeed. I may ping @quid and @AlexanderGruber, as well. If this is who I think it is, their behavior in the past was quite erratic, regarding their own posts, and about users he interacted with, and was prone to cause trouble through the casting of inappropriate flags in chat rooms.
 
Conversation ended Feb 28, 2021 at 18:40.