The Nineteenth Byte

PhiNotPi

12:02 AM

I'm on Windows. Sometimes I've heard sound notifications from other accounts that are logged in.

Will

@COTO Ended up asking said question here: stackoverflow.com/q/25634191/765294 :)

VisualMelon

I was once convinced I had some adware on my machine, because my computer kept making "ping" noises - I later realized this was my email client telling me I had mail. After that I changed all the system sounds to be completely ridiculous so I couldn't mistake them for anything else.

COTO

@Will: lol @ "a deviant number of parameters".

Just out of interest: have you compiled the C code to make sure it actually works?

I mean, just because something is on PPCG doesn't mean it's syntactically correct.

VisualMelon

well

this would be semantics, I don't think anyone would argue against the syntax, but this is also irrelevant

dammit, I spend so much of my time arguing over semantics, now I'm probably going to rope myself into an argument about the actual word

Will

@COTO Well, the strange thing is... it doesn't seem to work on my own comp, but it does work on ideone.com...

COTO

12:09 AM

...doesn't mean it's a legal overload. ;)

Also, when did C start accepting no-type arguments like main(a) { .... }?

I must be getting old.

Will

type defaults to int in c

at least in params and ret vals

COTO

Is that a new feature or is it something that every piece of C code I've read for the past 20 years has (by random chance) never used?

Will

This "feature" is as old as the language, but the reason nobody uses it is well... self-explanatory I assume :)

found very often in obfuscated C contests though

COTO

Feh. Learn something new every day.

Will

Maybe the code example given isn't entirely correct, but I figured somebody would have pointed that out by now given its upvotes and exposure.

COTO

12:30 AM

@Will: People simply might not know for sure. There are literally thousands of library functions in C. You'd need to get somebody who i) reads the answer, ii) knows that the method requires three methods in every conceivable implementation of the C standard libraries, iii) notices the error, iv) is confident enough in his/her assessment to say something and risk appearing foolish if wrong, v) cares enough to say something, and vi) is either a PPCG user or willing to sign up as one, since guests can't comment.

The function wouldn't even appear to do what it claims to do. For example, the recursive invocation of main() leaves out the argument to main. So unless C has also started accepting function overloads, that's wrong too.

PhiNotPi

I updated the leaderboard for the Rosetta Stone Averages question.

(I don't think anyone in here is participating, actually...)

Will

@COTO That last statement is false though. That variable is set by scanf() on every iteration, so it doesn't matter what it initially holds.

COTO

But main(void) isn't the same as main(int) in C. It should fail with a compiler error.

Will

It doesn't. I've tried it in many forms succesfully. Just warnings.

COTO

Then that's another undocumented C hack somewhere. Every C language resource I've ever seen says that you can't have a function with signature abc( int ) and abc( void ). Maybe some compilers let you get away with it.

Transcript for