Sayed Mohd Ali

@Deusovi I think you should move all this conversation in the chat :P...

@Sinh yes, I saw it...

so this can be a partial answer

also JMP answer

it seems like people are trying to do that like i read hdsdv chat

@Adam we will see will you vote for reopen because I added the link?

@Adam what you are fighting is nonsense because the question isn't closed for the reason too broad, it is closed because the puzzle is found from somewhere else, I already mentioned the link. so please vote for reopen... "This looks like a puzzle you found elsewhere. For content you did not create yourself, proper attribution is required. If you have permission to repost this, please edit to include (at minimum) where it came from, then vote to reopen. Posts which use someone else's content without attribution are generally deleted." – Deusovi

okay adam I will give you another example of today question here it is ... puzzling.stackexchange.com/questions/87571/…

@Adam there is no open-ended tag on the question I have given a link. and both the question is having a proper answer. you are comparing this question with something else...

@Adam, in that case, this problem clearly is also having many valid answers, puzzling.stackexchange.com/questions/72865/…

@Adam yes, there is the unique correct answer and I have already mentioned and accepted the answer... It is also having the most upvotes on quora and StackOverflow. and who are you to response it is for Gareth

@GarethMcCaughan I think after adding lateral thinking tag the question should be reopened...

@GarethMcCaughan check the upvotes of the 1st answer here and also second answer... quora.com/…

@GarethMcCaughan puzzlersworld.com/picture-puzzles/picture-puzzle-killer

@GarethMcCaughan classywish.com/best-whatsapp-puzzles

@Koray do you know what riddle means? there is clues and hint in the riddle to solve the question and riddle you need to use them. it is not story... and most of the downvotes are because of this is old riddle not because it is bad riddle...

@Koray you come up with good story clear all the other suspect and find the victim and I will accept your answer... this is all the part of the riddle. and yes about down votes I don't care I enjoy solving puzzle that's all :P you can give downvotes to all my questions and answer good luck

@Stiv i have no issue with your views and even I don't care about down votes. what I need is correct and justified answer not the answer of 1 word copied form other site like DEEM did. I have added so many hint so that makes everyone suspect... If someone can figure out the whole scene from the hints then only the proper answer can be given...

@Stiv can you proove it is the right solution? I have asked cross question to the deep, let him justify the answer instead of googling. I added hint that will make harder for you to identify suspect.

@DEEM does already answered on another site marked as duplicate here?

if you don't have a proper answet to the question that means you are wrong...

adam I want your answer, I will take screenshot and discuss the matter in stack exchange site, so you don't worry

and if you have a better answer then why you didn't posted it is put on hold recently

@Adam okay tell me your answer.

@Adam I have mentioned lot of points for suspect 3 and suspect 4... please go through all of them and counter it with your answer instead of making fault stories...

@Adam, the image gave you simple clues, this is visual puzzle where you need to find the clues from the image and tell who is the victim. but what you are doing is making your own assumptions and stories you are wrong about it... if you do those assumptions you will ruin the riddle. the assumptions you are making will not help to solve the puzzle but you are making it too broad... it is not the puzzle which is broad, it is you who is making it broad...

@Adam it is mentioned in the image that the victim is in weakened state? as you can see in the image both women are of normal size, yes you can determine the strength by looking at their body. go with the clues in the image don't make your own assumption, in the case women was not killed she did suicide she was stressed out .... are your happy now? I mentioned the clues in the image... the man in red shirt gave the most of the clues...

@Adam for a women to kill another women with knife in washroom without any noise and struggle? is it even possible?