« first day (1091 days earlier)      last day (123 days later) » 

03:05
0
Q: Who has green eyes and was/were killed by Arya?

KharoBangdoIn Game of Thrones S08E03, when Arya meets Arya says she was right that Brown eyes are pretty common but do we know anyone with green eyes that Arya has shut forever?

03:25
0
Q: How did Arya manage to sneak up on the Night King?

JJJContains spoilers on S08E03 (please edit the title too if necessary, I don't know what would be appropriate here):

 
2 hours later…
05:24
Holy Shit! I'm only 45 minutes into it but I needed a breather. Whew. I'm not looking at the main boards yet, but I just saw some blue dragon fire on the show. I can't believe no one is here yet! Alright, I'm going back in.
06:02
0
Q: What was the point of Bran warging into those birds during S8E3?

yuritsukiI still don't understand what exactly he was hoping to accomplish during that scene where Theon fights to protect him, because it looked like nothing of any major significance happened besides warging into a flock of birds for a minute and then tapping back in.

06:12
I can't believe no one is here!
Well i am but I havent watched the episode yet so can't really discuss it
It does not disappoint.
I just finished it. I had to take several breaks 'cause I was crying too hard to see.
That is good. One super snob Fb group I am in is apparently in love with the new episode. Which is something they never do
So I guess it must have been good
And I cried out several times.
In all kinds of emotion.
Oh wait, turns out they have two threads goin. One love thread, one hate thread. I saw love thread first
06:19
It was awesome
Okay I am gonna watch it before my lunch break then :D
The hate thread is wrong
You can find stuff to complain about if you try, but I don't see the point of trying.
I loved it. Watch it in a darkened room if possible.
Well don't think I am gonna get a darkened room at work. Will rewatch it at home
Idk why is this season so dark
And be prepared, it's 1:22 long.
Like literally dark.
06:22
It's OK in a semi-dark room, but any glare makes it hard to tell who just bit it.
I'm still not sure about everyone.
My living room doesn't get dark while it's still light outside. It's 10:30 pm and still not quite dark enough. I'll watch the episode again in a half-hour or so. Ain't Alaska grand.
Do you know The Last Harpy on YouTube?
06:37
gosh, I expected this end, still surprised
0
Q: Did she even qualify for being Azor Ahai or The One Who Was Promised?

Ankit SharmaIn the books and somewhat in the show it was referred about Azor Ahai being prophesied. But in the latest Game of Thrones episode (S08E03) we see Arya killing the Night King. However in a past question we discussed​ all possible candidates but nobody thought about Arya. Does she even fulfill the...

@Kepotx I was shocked many times.
JAD
JAD
@Aegon Because night has to gather before your watch begins
I was talking of the last scene, but yeah, I was also surprised many times during the episode
First by Melisandre. Great entrance!
JAD
JAD
06:43
I'm watching it this evening, so pls be nice :)
or if you must discuss, please say, and I'll rejoin tomorrow
Fucking awesome episode. Best yet, IMO.
I need to go to work so I won't discuss a lot
I'm going to watch it again now that it's finally dark.
I watch it this morning (french frog here), in a quite dark room, and I struggle to see things time to time, good luck for those who see it in full bright
Better to watch it on your phone in a locked bathroom. :/
06:49
expected more death honestly, but I guess we need some character left for the last 3 episodes
I'm going back in! I'll be back in a half hour or so.
07:27
@JAD Night is dark and probably full of terrors, we can't see them so can't be sure.
And LOLOLOLOLOLOL after pointlessly losing a lot of men, now they are falling back to the walls? Niceeeeeeee
07:44
@Aegon I was upset with the battle plan in episode 2, like "dude? don't you thing walls are usefull?" I thought they were dumb. But actually, I was sumb, walls are useless
@Kepotx You mean episode 2?
seriously, they lost the wall quickly
I am about to discover
oh, sorry
Oh its not a problem, I don't mind spoilers
Still comparatively, they lost all of Dothraki and best of Unsullied for a hopeless stand outside the walls.
The Walls might be lost eventually but the field would certainly be lost without any doubt, as it did
No pitch and oil đŸ˜«
07:48
yeah, the dothraki do a small charge, and it end
Dothraki need to be on open field, but unsullied can do a very good job on the walls rather than in front of it
Imagine what oil and pitch would do to them
@Kepotx Doesn't mean you have to waste them. You can keep them in reserve inside the wall. A living dothraki is better than a briefly mobile one
also, a wall without machicolation?
@Kepotx Yup, the great Castle of the North. Apparently lacks everything of defensive value
Hot pie should have commanded
Also did you note, they conveniently depleted Dany's army (Well at least till now). Jon's is more or less intact. And Jon's got a dragon too. So Dany is automatically the junior partner?
07:53
well, no dothraki anymore, and unsullied suffer heavy lost
isn't rhaegal dead?
Well s***, I don't know, he's alive so far
So Dany remains relevant
oh sorry, you didn't finish yet
Running commentary is much more fun :D
Lol Lyanna Mormont. I am sorry I shouldn't laugh but some dude on r/Freefolk called it weeks ago that she's gonna fight to delight of all the Lyanna fans who keep hyping her up as a great warrior and then she's gonna die in seconds because she's just a little kid.
not the best warrior in term of skill compared to other fighter like his cousin, but still impressive for her age
Oh and unrelated, but turns out Robert's coming was prophesied
The prophecy said "When the hammer falls on the Dragon, a new king shall arise and none shall stand before him"
People during Dance of Dragons thought it was Hugh Hammer who was supposed to fall on the Dragons
08:04
where that come from?
@Kepotx Fire and Blood.
oh, still havn't read it
i bought it, but need more time to read it
also, even if the writing style is quite easy to understand, I struggle to read in english
Isn't it out in French (Your native tongue, I think?) yet?
only half have been translated
same goes for ASOIAF books, they are split in smaller books
GO ARYA!!!
08:15
Boom, you looking for this!
That was undoubtedly one of the best things I have ever seen
Whoa, apparently Arya kills the Night King! O_O
Wait, is Rhaegel dead?
Can't wait to check that episode.
Or is he just exhausted/wounded or something
08:20
@NapoleonWilson I spent like 20 minutes being like 'where's Arya'? Is she going to do it? And it was epic
I think Rhaegal is dead, was so bloody dark I couldn't tell though
I don't think Rhaegal's dead
Well Viserion's death was pretty anticlimatic.
He seemed more curled around Daenerys protectively or something
That was Drogon no?
08:21
seems like he is in the trailer for next episode
@TheLethalCarrot Ahh, yeah, it was
And they ruined most of what probably could have been a great episode due to the dark
Yeah, I thought Rhaegal was dead too
@Aegon It wasn't too dark for me at all
3 mins ago, by Mithrandir24601
That was undoubtedly one of the best things I have ever seen
So...the dead are...dead and the rest of the season will either be people continuing to bitch about the Iron Throne or a LotR überending?
@Mithrandir24601 Well lucky you
08:22
The rest will be vs Cersei aye
@NapoleonWilson The King returns after casting the usurper/steward aside
they still have two dragons, but the army seems annihilated, so it's an unfait match. This mean one thing to me: golden company betrayal
That is probably going to happen, otherwise there is not really going to be a way to win
I can't even think about what's next - I'm just sitting here stunned at what I just watched
even two dragons aren't enough, since cersei now have scorpions
08:25
Well I mean if you're not daft you don't fly in a straight line at them haha
episode 4: aftermath of Battle for Winterfell, and preparations by Cersei at King's Landing, Golden company betrayal
episode 5: Jon/Dany VS Cersei
GC will betray in 5 or 6 if they do, it's not gonna be straight away
@Kepotx Two dragons mean two armies. Change my mind
More likely 5
episode6: better-sweet ending, maybe several years in the future to see the aftermath of all that happen
08:26
The GoT lot like to leave that suspension of will they won't they hanging around so GC can't change sides too soon
they way I see the betrayal is that Euron bought the golden company with cersei gold
Remembers boyos, Aegon I conquered the whole damn thing with just 3000 men and three dragons
so, golden company is loyal to euron, not cersei
Golden Company is loyal to gold and their own skin
Plus if Eps 1 and 2 are anything to go by ep 4 will just be an aftermath ep with not much happening
08:27
basically, the golden company don't switch sides, euron does
They like gold but do they like it enough to side with the losing side?
No
@Kepotx Not like They will take Euron
well, dragons were new things back in the day
@Kepotx Were they? Valyrian freehold emerged centuries ago
is Essos, not Westeros
So newer to Westeros then?
08:30
Don't think it has anything to do with familiarity tbh
Rhoynar gave them a real tough fight in Essos
And then again in Westeros
Aegon's conquest was more because of blunders of his foes
also, it was 3000 men at the beginning, but as soon as several Houses bend the knee, he had more forces
Black Harren refused to leave his castle, Argilac the Defiant gave battle in the open, Loren and Mern IX gave battle in the open. Sharra Arryn thought Eyrie can keep dragons out. Only the Rhoynar realised they had to take the third course
@Kepotx Men of dubious loyalties who'd have turned cloaks again if the war turned sour'
Field of fire was basically "screw your dragons, we have more forces, you have no chance". seems like he had
Yup, Guerilla warfare was a good strategy
Val of Arryn could have done a great place for guerilla too
Lol who the guys breaking into the Crypts? Just dead dudes or dead Kings of Winter?
and the neck, like Vietnam war
08:34
@Kepotx Precisely. Exhibit A, no one has yet tamed the Mountain Clans
0
Q: Who died in Season 8 Episode 3, "The Long Night"?

TheLethalCarrotI'm mainly talking here about any named characters we know that died in the episode. I was trying to pay attention to see who died but it was so damn dark that I probably missed who and when. Those that I can remember seeing are: I think there were others and I can't remember if some did die o...

@BaeltheBard I expect this one will be used to close a lot of new questions as dupe, make it good carrot
The hell viserion still lives. Goddamndarkepisode
08:52
Well NK's death was disappointing
But I guess after touting his and his army's invincibility for so long, any end would have been disappointing
I quite liked it, he got too coky and Arya bad assed him haha
At least Rhaegel lives
Two dragons were over KL in the next episode trailer.
I'm answering carrot's question, not sure how to handle spoiler tags
Meh leave 'em out of the answer
@Aegon Viserion lives? Were you watching the same episode as me?
well, the whole answer is just a list of who died, i just don't see what could i put outside spoilers
09:00
Yeah no need to add spoiler tags, if you click on the question you know what you're in for so you're own fault
he only died when the NK died
Yeah that's what I meant
FWIW I'm not self answering, I'm pretty sure I missed some deaths
indeed, we are not 100% sure somes are dead
like melissandre is maybe just doing a nap in the snow
only the first tree are confirmed as they are resurected, and the night King
also, not sure if I should quote Viserion's death
Yeah put Viserion in
Also the Dotkraki bloodrider dies but I can't remember his name
for me it was just horseman#56
we saw some dothraki come back, I wasn't even sure if some were relevent
09:15
There's the main guy Dothraki but I don't actually know if he is named
He does get certain emphasis like Melisadre using his Arakh and focusing on him turning to a wight etc.
And of course he's the "leader" Dothraki
Also WHAT THE DUCK happened to Ghost!!!???
I was promised cool things with Ghost but he just disappears at the start
I swear to god we better get more Ghost in these last 3 episodes
everyone who was resurected by NK should alo be on the list, but meh
too long and too speculative
but lot of named character from the night watch should be there
@TheLethalCarrot At that moment it did. I thiught it died after fight with Rhaegel when he ripped Viserion's face off
Well I was of course asking about names characters, random soldier #3653 doesn’t really matter
09:30
And the prince that was promised didn't do anything?
of course, but maybe some named character died at hardome
5/10. 5 Solely because of filming effort
I though Viseriom and Rhaegal both died fighting each other but so much happened and was so dark I was inferring so who knows
0 for substance
or if they didn't burn craster/mormont at craster house, they are probably resurected
09:31
Actually make it 3/10. -2 for Dark
too much dark, indeed
but it was better than i feared
And why did Melisandre had to die?
well no the question was who died in the episode Craster doesn’t count
I mean sure they said she would die before dawn
I just thought she'd kill herself to work some magic
Like lighting up that trench
had more goosebumps in LOTR battles than this one, but had it's moments
09:33
That was one proper battle, Battle of Minas Tirith
yup, she just died after, wich make no much sense
just so she can tell arya "add blue eyes to your list"
So Arya was the Prince that was promised
yup. therefore, a Targaryen
Stupid Rhaegar killed hundreds of thousands of people including his family for that
At least it now shuts up people who thought GRRM would try to gauge public response to his intended ending via show
There is no way GRRM ever imagined that sort of ending
2
@Aegon Too old, tired of living, served her purpose?
09:35
And now that the dead are dead, what are they gonna do for the upcoming episodes? Drag the fight between Cersei and Dany?
That's gonna get tiresome like the first two episodes
@TheLethalCarrot Mehhh.
@TheLethalCarrot dude, when I finish a project at work, I also sevred my purpose but i don't die doing a nap
Yup we'll get some long ass winded ep 4 which ends with them mobilising
Dany will keep annoying show fans with "MY IRON THRONE" ****
@Aegon actually, i like the dirst two episodes. Season 7 was rushed, and fear this one would also be rushed, but they take time to end some arcs
09:38
They took too much time, eps 1 and 2 could easily have been 1 episode
Hah this. Twice she came to our rescue. Rest in peace, sweet princess
Lol
@Kep does your Theon image actually contain an image or is it just black? ;P
@TheLethalCarrot between two black pixel, if you blik your eyes really hard, there is a grey-ish area with theon
So basically:

1. Dany did nothing
2. Jon did nothing
3. Bran did nothing
4. Brienne did nothing
5. Jaime did nothing
6. Clegane did nothing
7. NK did nothing
8. Random White Walker dudes did nothing
Nobody ********** did anything
Pretty much
09:42
And Dumb and Dumber are blaming it on Dany
The whole episode was full of "WHY THE HELL WOULD YOU EVER DO THAT!?" moments
"Akshualli when Dany took wing, the plan fell apart". There was a bloody plan?
the whole WW crew did nothing
At least NK tried something
Yup the NK was the only one who seemed to know what was going on
but yeah, lot of them were useless
09:44
He just got too cocky at the end
Please don't put spoilers in the title... — BlueRaja - Danny Pflughoeft 2 hours ago
ugh
I was expecting more when bran warg
"oh gosh, he will do some 3 eyed raven stuff"
I think it'll be him sending for help
nah, just lurking with crows
To either Reeds or Yara
this, or see if Cersei send army
09:45
Nah they all know Cersei isn't going to advance
Full episode in four frames
@Aegon I had goosebumps on second image
this scene was awesome
09:47
The only scene that actually had some "oooooh" value was mel lighting up them arakhs
yep. followed by another "oooooh" of disapointment when they fade up
And to be honest, i expected a counter-charge
I mean, why didn't the NK resurect the first wave of dothraki? take 1 minut, and he could have charge the flanks with it
dothrakis and unsullied are not a good match, but they would have decimated northman
2
Q: What happened to the Dragon Jon Snow rode?

aolsanIn Game of Thrones S08E03 ("The Long Night"), the Night King's dragon tore at the one Jon Snow rides (Rhaegal). He falls off of it and we don't see the dragon anymore, is it dead?

1
Q: Did Bran know what was going to happen at the end of S08E03?

ShevliaskovicMajor spoilers for S08E03. Towards the end of the episode, we see that the We see that the latter simply sits in his wheelchair, looking the former in the eyes and doesn't even lift a finger, when It seems pretty obvious that Bran couldn't defend himself against anyone, We do know that h...

10:02
Too grainy and brownish too tell
Heh posted the rant on r/Freefolk
They hate it
The rant, not the episode :D
they hate the rant or episode,
10:03
They probably think it was the greatest thing ever aired on TV like they do with every c*** episode of the previous seasons
FWIW apparently they've had Arya in mind for killink NK since about S5/6
They change their mind every now and then
Last season it was boat baby
Or was it just a meme?
Meme but sure we'll go with it haha
carrot's question reach HNQ quick
Did you not think it would? :P
10:11
not that quickly
I mean, european will probably watch it this night, only few watch it in the morning
and americans are still sleeping
True, but it only needs a handful of votes to reach the HNQ
I don't understand why your question was downvoted
Spoilers? People thinking it could be searched easily, people being bittwer
It was quite long episode so the count of death may be hard to remember, and between dark and the fact that we jump to other scenes quickly, some are one probably dead
I assumed jon's dragon was dead before the trailer of episode 4
as you said, hard to know when jorah stop breathing in the dark
and the whole melissandre death scene was "just why?"
She's taken the necklace off before and been fine, I think she's just too old/exhausted at this point to carry on
Watching the Inside the Episode at the moment to see if anything is revealed
10:25
Hah so they were aware of the damage it would cause for their side if they were risk their persons? But apparently the most important person, by that logic, the NK took no such precautions.
this. They have pletore of wight, they could have killed everything without coming close to bran. This is "The evil guy explain Evil plan while hero untied herself" level
The Night King's whole purpose with attacking was to kill Bran, in the end he gets too cocky thinking he's easily about to finish his mission
And then died because a tiny little dagger pricked him. Yeah that makes total sense that such a powerful figure could be brought down like a common stableboy. And how convenient that his death kills his army as well. => this also. a bittersweet end (to the battle or to the whole tv show) would be a night king death, without real win from the humans
Nope nothing revealed on Melisandre
0
A: Did Bran know what was going to happen at the end of S08E03?

TheLethalCarrotYes In the Inside the Episode video David says the following: David: I think what was really important for Theon at the end was hearing that thank you from Bran because Bran knows what is going to happen. Game of Thrones, Season 8 Episode 3, "The Long Night " - Inside the Episode He's...

> David: I think what was really important for Theon at the end was hearing that thank you from Bran because Bran knows what is going to happen.
Bran knew Arya was going to save him by extending that quote from Theon to Arya
Lol apparently a lot of people are ranting on r/Freefolk
10:29
Show's own Swords and Stars aren't having none of it
I liked the episode but overall it was quite a let down for what they could have done
A pure show fan is asking if that's how vulnerable nk was, why didn't the children just shoot him down with an obsidion tipped arrow
same. This was a good hour of action, it could be way more, but I expected to be way worse
Would have been so much better had they just gotten defeated at Winterfell and retreated
They could fill out the next two episodes
And use the last to bring down cersei
as we didn't see the NK at king's landing, i expected to fly to kings landing
10:33
Yeah I was hoping for more, there's been so much build up for an amazing last fight and then it's all over in one night
Not even one night actually, probably only a couple of hours
^^^^^^^
11:14
@TheLethalCarrot Yeah, I really liked it as well - I've tried that specific movement before and it was essentially luck as to whether it works against someone experienced but works really well against someone inexperienced
So, was Arya lucky, or did NK just not do much actual fighting?
I'm of the opinion that he was just too cocky so didn't even think he was vulnerable
@Aegon 10/10 from me for filming, the intensity, the tense moments, Tyrion and Sansa, the Hound, Arya's path through the episode, the Lord of Light fulfilments, and the question it raises about ' did the faceless man know this would happen as Melisandre did?'
@TheLethalCarrot yeah, also possible
@Kepotx prophecies are easily misinterpreted - isn't she effectively a sister to the 'rightful' heir to the throne? Oh also just realised that I should add John attacking NK to the above list
@Kepotx To my mind, NK took every precaution, but was bested by a faceless man
11:44
every precaution? he did take some precaution (only enter winterfell when the walls fell) but could have been way more precautionous
good guy bran
12:13
2
Q: Why was this episode so dark?

Gustavo GabrielIn Game of Thrones, everyone who watched the S0803 episode noticed one thing, the episode was so freaking dark, it was almost impossible to see anything. Audiences were left confused as all hell because the screen was so dark. It was next to impossible to tell who was fighting, who just died ...

12:42
@Kepotx under the assumption that Bran knew where he'd be, what more precautions could he have taken?
Do we know that Arya is the Prince(ss) that was Promised? Yeah, she killed the Night King, but does that absolutely mean that she "brought the dawn"? It isn't dawn yet. I mean, that's the prophecy, the dawn.
@Jolenealaska not sure how much tv show care about this prophecy at all
I'm with you, @Mithrandir24601. I absolutely loved it.
the title says it all. A Song of Ice and Fire: prophecy and battle against others
Game of Thrones: screw prophecy and white walkers, only the throne is important
and @Mithrandir24601, it was a joke about @TheLethalCarrot answer about "did bran know what will happen"
I'm renewing my long dead hope that Syrio is Jaqen H'ghar and Arya was groomed all along.
Since she saved the world by being a super-ninja-badass
12:51
D&D have known for "3 years" that Arya would kill NK so maybe not
0
Q: What is the extent of damage that Viserion's blue fire can cause?

polfosol à° _à° In another post on Game of Thrones, it is already discussed that Viserion's breath is a sort of fire. And we have already seen that it is a quite powerful fire But in episode 3 of season 8, we also see that I am interested to know about the capabilities and limitations of this sort of fire.

@Jolenealaska nope, we don't. We also don't know what 'promised' means though
I was guessing that "promised" meant "promised to the Night King" and Dany and Jon's kid was going to be TPWWP.
But, it doesn't look that way.
@M&TVFeeds I'm confused by this kind of question. Did he expect a "it give 4D12 damage, +50 damage against walls"?
13:01
I'm torn because prophecy has been a bit of mixed bag. Some gods are real, others arn't.
The show does what it wants for the plot and ignores everything else
Why does dragon fire not work against the NK? both dragon glass and dragon steel work
Cos "badass moment"
it felt like a Last Jedi rip off lol
It was obviously not gonna work though
The more you mention TLJ, the more parallels I see haha
13:03
no seriously. did arya kill with blade drop. otherwise that is a tlj rip off to
@Skooba according to behind the scenes, even valyrian steel should be at the exact location wher children of the forest put dragonglass
and NK just happens to have a gap in his armor there.... NK is a melt lol
Didn't it go through the armour?
also i thought the COF put the blade right through the middle of his chest
They did, centre chest
13:11
and arya hit the chest, didn't she?
cause def not where arya stabbed him
it was more like mid rib t the side
I thought Arya hit the side but rewatching from the Inside the Episode it looks potentially like the chest
I think she actually stabs him in the belly
14:08
@TheLethalCarrot The file still up? My stupid system got corrupted. Just got back and reinstalling everything ugh
 
2 hours later…
15:47
2
Q: Why was Jon snow resting with his dragon on the wall?

Anu7At around 25 minutes into Game of Thrones S08E03 Jon Snow and his dragon (Rhaegal) were resting on the wall of Winterfell when he could have been burning the army of the dead whom the living were fighting and struggling against. Or most importantly, he could have lit up the trench. Why wasn't he...

2
Q: What happened to Ghost?

Anu7Is Jon Snow's direwolf Ghost dead? Do we know what happend to him in Game of Thrones S08E03 after he ran along with the Dothraki into the dead horde?

16:07
1
Q: Can Jon Snow command the dragons like Daenerys or is he limited to just piloting them around?

Anu7In Game of Thrones S8 E3, there weren't any scenes where we heard Jon say "Dracarys" and set things on fire, so the question. There was this one scene 15 minutes into the episode where both the dragons sent the dead on fire... but apart from that one scene there weren't any scenes where Jon stepp...

16:26
2
Q: If Melisandre foresaw another character closing blue eyes, why did she follow Stannis?

AegonMelisandre came from Asshai to serve Lord Stannis. We were told that she did it because she believed he was the Azor Ahai who'd save the humanity by slaying the encroaching darkness. She even forged (a fake) Lightbringer for him, the heroes' sword which presumably the last Azor Ahai used to bring...

16:45
2
Q: What was the plan that Daenerys abandoned?

DKuIn S8E3 of Game of Thrones, Jon unsuccessfully tries to stop Daenerys from leaving the mountain they are perched on as they watch the Dothraki get chewed up by the undead hordes. In the "Inside the Episode" after, one of the writers states that "the plan" begins to unravel when Daenerys takes off...

17:00
@M&TVFeeds Of course, he's Azor Ahai
I am sorry, Azor A-who-i
3
Q: What is Bran doing in S08E03?

FirstSlackWhat is Bran/Three-Eyed Raven doing in Game of Thrones S08E03 when he goes into GreenSight? Is he spying on the Night King or is he providing insights into the battle or is he searching for some key information which he has to communicate to the rest of the cast?

17:24
3
Q: Why is Arya visibly scared in the library in S8E3?

Anu7In Game of Thrones S8E3, Arya fiercely kills a way lot of wights after which she has to escape from them and enter the library. In the library Arya seems pretty shaken and also not as brave as she usually is. There were around 10 wights or so in the library all of whom she would be able to kill e...

18:03
0
Q: Why didn't the other White Walkers inform the Night's King?

AndurielArya is a skilled assassin, master of stealth and whatnot. However, the area around Bran is mostly clear as shown in earlier scenes. They must have seen something rushing to their leader. Why did they decide to stay silent?

18:57
I've watched it again and Arya did stab in the chest. Also, we've been thinking about who's dead. My question is, who do we know for sure is alive?
0
Q: Did the hound know his role?

FirstSlackWhy did the Hound comply with Beric and decide to help Arya, when Beric pointed at Arya as she was fighting a lot of the dead? Did the Hound know his role? Did the lord of light tell him something about this situation? or Did he feel bad for Arya and he decided to help her? Or Is he sticking to...

19:18
The episode was epic
19:40
And I'm starting to wonder if we're completely off with the end of the series - what if Daenerys goes mad? What if she and John get assassinated? It seems like we've all just kind of assumed that the next three episodes will be Daenerys v. Cersei but I've got to wonder, is that actually going to be the case?
20:11
Jon being a Targaryen will obviously be a topic
 
1 hour later…
21:17
1
Q: Why was the second line of the Battle for Winterfell comprised of catapults?

starseekerI don't really understand why they had the second line using trebuchets and catapults instead of the last line next to the wall, so they could continue to fire. Feels like it closes down the retreat path having them close to the wall but I don't know. Maybe someone can explain?

1
Q: Why did Melisandre do this in GOT S08E03?

SavaTrying to keep the question as spoiler-free as possible, thus the generic wording. So, in The Long Night, at the end, we see Melisandre It makes little sense to me that she would do that after managing to survive through the whole battle. She did told Seaworth that she was going to die, when ...

21:36
1
Q: What's the role of Melisandre?

MJ13I was always confused with Melisandre and was never sure about the purpose she was serving in Game of Thrones. It seems to me that she had been always serving the Lord Of Light. That's why she had so many visions in flames all this time and had some sort of superpowers. However,she made many mist...

-1
Q: How did Arya get back her dagger from Sana’a?

MomchillI am not sure how this plays out in the books as I haven't read them, but I just watched the last episode of GoT and it went down like this: Arya gave her dagger to Sansa at the beginning of the episode before Sansa made her way to the cript. A whole lot of shit went down. Arya finds out she i...

1
Q: Did the blade that stabbed Jorah snap?

SeamusthedogIn GoT s8 ep3 when Jorah is fatally (?) stabbed defending Daenerys, does the dragon glass blade snap? Rematches it a few times now and can't tell if the full blade is there when pulled out. If not, does that mean Jorah can come back as the new Night's King?

22:35
-1
Q: Did the spear of Night King reach its target?

Ravi AIn Game of Thrones S08E03 the Night King threw a spear at Daenerys after she unsuccessfully tried Dragon Fire on him. When the spear reached to Daenerys, we can hear a hurting reaction sound from her, but later she was shown unhurt and the spear was never shown. Even the Night King smirked after ...

0
Q: How could this character survive this action in the Game of Thrones episode "The Long Night"?

TGarIn the S08E03 episode of Game of Thrones, we see Daenerys on her dragon standing against the and the dragon throws flames at them. This character survives without harm (even smiling a little). How is that possible?

0
Q: Why was the battle set up *outside* Winterfell?

Federico PoloniThe whole point of building a castle is that it is an excellent defensive stronghold: the attackers need to climb walls, and the defenders have the high ground and can defend very efficiently using archers, oil, etc. So what is the reason why the army of the living lined up just outside Winterfe...


« first day (1091 days earlier)      last day (123 days later) »