« first day (75 days earlier)      last day (3840 days later) » 

10:16 AM
@RicardoAndrade: I wouldn't say that "people" are flocking to elementary-number-theory, instead "person" is flocking there, as only one user has assigned that tag. Personally I think the tag is superfluous, but anyway quid has thought much more about these things so I await his pronouncement.
 
Hello, may I repost my question from SE to MO to attract more people?
 
11:09 AM
@Michael Zieve: You are correct that it is only one person who is using the tag for now. I was hasty in my evaluation. Sorry about that. Also, thank you for your opinion on the tag itself.
 
 
4 hours later…
2:50 PM
@RicardoAndrade: I only see four questions. Did some get retagged?
I think all elementary-* tags should have wikis.
 
 
7 hours later…
9:27 PM
@François Dorais: I do not think any questions got retagged so as to remove the tag 'elementary-number-theory'. I simply noticed that the tag is only a few days old, yet already has four questions. So I thought discussing the matter here would be a good idea, as the tag appears rather redundant. On the other hand, as Michael Zieve remarks, it appears there is only one person who has used this tag so far.
 
10:19 PM
@RicardoAndrade sorry for being slow to respond (somehow I did not get the notification). For your question, when I cleaned up the elemantary tag I thought about creating elementary-number-theory as elementary was frequently used in combination with nt.number-theory and as I feel it is after all a somewhat well-established term, but I decided against it.
However in the end I agree with @MichaelZieve that the tag does not add much here. And might cause people not using more specific or telling tags of which there are plenty. Or if they are truly only interested in a somehow elementary argument they could use
I had a look at the question tagged. It seems somebody created the tag for one of their new questions and then tagged it on a couple of other questions, two old of their own and one they just answered.
Personally, I would prefer the tag would be removed; I would not do a synonym to avoid to generic tagging with just nt.number-theory. But also I hesitate to retag these on my own as there are worse tags and at least the creator made some effort to give the tag some usage.
 
10:52 PM
@quid: It appears the notification system can be a bit finicky... Thank you very much for your informative opinion. What do you think of François Dorais suggestion above? He says "I think all elementary-* tags should have wikis."
 

« first day (75 days earlier)      last day (3840 days later) »