12 hours ago, by user21820
If ¬∀x∈S (P(x)): If ¬∃x∈S (¬P(x)): ¬∃y∈S (¬P(y)). // Rename Given x∈S: If ¬P(x): ∃y∈S (¬P(y)). // Exists-Intro since x is unused. ¬∃y∈S (¬P(y)). // Restate since y does not occur in it. P(x). ∀x∈S (P(x)). ¬∀x∈S (P(x)). // Restate Contradiction. ∃x∈S (¬P(x)). ¬∀x∈S (P(x)) → ∃x∈S (¬P(x)).