@wolf‐revo‐cats If "extraordinary" merely means "unlikely", then reading that the numbers are 1 8 12 15 46 48 5 would be extraordinary evidence. "But this is exactly the argument Dawkins makes." No, it's not. Dawkins is not comparing X and Y, but the arguments for X and Y. "You (or Dawkins) claimed that agnosticism is irrational." Not in the quote presented in the question.