9:55 PM
I haven't played any of those, but I've enjoyed all of Gloomhaven, Legacy of Dragonholt and T.I.M.E. Stories (and I'm about to receive my copy of 7th Continent which I'm super excited for).
Legacy of Dragonholt is basically a cross of a choose-your-own-adventure and DM-less D&D. It's very light on the "game" part, but tells a pretty fantastic story.
Gloomhaven is of course very heavy on the game part, so you'll only want to play it with people who don't mind complicated rules and challenging games, but it's my favourite game by a landslide (and I've never sunk this amount of time into a board game, and probably not even into a video game).
And T.I.M.E. stories is somewhere in between. It's fairly puzzle-y and story-heavy. But it's also designed to be almost unbeatable on the first attempt (you'll need 2-3), and after you've beaten it there isn't really any replay value so you'll need to start buying expansions (which I haven't played but which I'm told are also very good).